07 August 2018

'The Originalist' Squared


[I posted a report on a television performance of The Originalist, John Strand’s 2015 play about Supreme Court Associate Justice Antonin Scalia, back last year.  I’ve now seen the play live, still starring Washington, D.C.’s Edward Gero as Scalia, and I’ve decided to write another report, this time focusing on Gero’s acting in the play (which, you’ll no doubt guess, I think is superb).  I also suggested to my friends Kirk Woodward and Diana that they see the performance, especially for Gero's stage work.  As a result, Kirk, who’s contributed many articles to Rick On Theater over the years, also composed a report of his own.  I’m posting both Kirk’s and my articles together so ROTters can see both our opinions side by side (figuratively speaking, of course—they’re really above and below).  Take note that my new report does not cover the same ground as my theater reports usually do since I took care of that last year.  (I have included a round-up of the New York reviews, however.)  Readers who want to see what I thought of the whole play and production should refer back to “The Originalist (PBS),” 17 July 2017.  ~Rick]

THE ORIGINALIST
by Kirk Woodward

When I attended the play The Originalist by John Strand, directed by Molly Smith, at 59E59 Theaters in Manhattan, New York on August 1, 2018, all I knew about it was that it was based on the career of Antonin Scalia (1936-2016), an Associate Justice of the United States Supreme Court from 1986 to 2016, and that the performance of Edward Gero as Scalia had been highly praised. I had also read the entry about the play, as performed on PBS, in this blog on 17 July 2017, titled “The Originalist (PBS).” Having now seen the play on stage, I don’t want to fill in again the observations and the detail covered by that blog entry, with which I heartily agree, but only to reinforce some of its observations as I saw them.

Reading the program after I saw the play, I learned that Molly Smith is the Artistic Director of Arena Stage in Washington, DC, and that The Originalist is one of a series of commissioned theater pieces under the umbrella title Power Plays, described by Molly Smith in her Director’s Notes as

an ambitious initiative to commission 25 new plays or musicals spanning the history of our nation from 1776 to the present decade . . . which explores stories of presidents, broken treaties, governmental secrets, lost parts of American history, and more. Learning and understanding American stories of politics and power makes us more informed as a democracy and sheds life on how we face personal and political adversaries. Sometimes the way we understand our lives is through stories about this moment in time, and sometimes through stories from an earlier era that underscore where we are in history. These plays will not fall along party lines – they will challenge all of us and I am eager to open these dialogues.

It makes sense that Arena Stage, as a preeminent theater in the nation’s center of government, would institute such a series of plays. It also makes sense that despite the best intentions, such plays might take on the character of assignments, rather than products of organic growth, and although I haven’t seen any of the others in the series, I do feel that such is the case with The Originalist, a result best seen in how the three characters in the play are presented.

About the portrayal of Justice Scalia by Edward Gero, no qualification is needed. He is brilliant in the role. He not only looks the part, he inhabits it. His performance left me convinced at the end of the evening that I now knew the Justice personally. Edward Gero deserves every bit of praise he receives for a really stunning performance. I was particularly taken with the way he ages his character by subtle shading over the course of what is supposed to be a year. Hats off to him.

But the play is not a monologue; it contains two other characters as well, and if Scalia as a character is convincing, the other two are not, in two different ways: the character of Cat, the black, liberal law clerk, has to represent too many things in the play, and the character of Brad, the conservative law researcher, has to represent too few.

Cat on the one hand is required to be both a top-rate law student and a fairly naïve idealist; a member of a racial minority and of a sexual minority as well; an independent woman and a girl searching for a father figure. That’s a lot of baggage for one character to carry, and the strain shows. Cat’s ways of approaching ScaIia often seem arbitrary – why for example after a particularly sensitive encounter with Scalia, does she in the next scene bait him aggressively as though she were determined to tear him apart?

And if she was so brilliant in law school, why are her legal jousts with Scalia often so flimsy? For example, there is an argument early in the play between Cat and Scalia about the Second Amendment to the Constitution. The text of the amendment reads:

A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.

Cat argues the importance of the first two clauses of the Amendment, Scalia counters with the last two, and Cat retires defeated – never asking him why the first two clauses are in the Amendment at all, if they do not modify the last two. However, at that point the play needs Scalia to win a point, so the discussion is over.

I did not feel that the acting of Tracy Ifeachor in the role of Cat overcame the limitations of the script. However, I am inclined to blame a good bit of this on Molly Smith, the director, who seems to have worked off the premise suggested in publicity for the play that it is a comedy, and to have directed the actors to perform accordingly.

The Originalist is not, as far as I can tell, a comedy; it is a play with humor in it, quite a different thing. I suspect that a calculation was made that a biography of a Supreme Court Justice might not appeal enough to the theatergoing public, and that the play was recalibrated accordingly.

So Ifeachor is required to put a spin on a great deal of what her character says, and I simply did not find that aspect of her role believable. The role of Brad, on the other hand, can barely be referred to as a character at all. He might as well wear a sign reading “Conservative Opponent.” He is of course male – boooo! He is of course a sycophant and an underminer. He of course knew Cat in law school and crossed swords with here there too as well. He knows a secret about Cat – of course. He is, I suggest, a walking dramatic contrivance, and the actor, Brett Mack, has quite a thankless job with the role, because there is really nothing in it.

Such are the dangers of writing plays about preexisting material or ideas. They tend to seem designed to prove an already settled point, or to make sure the audience finds drama in events that were dramatic already without the playwright’s contributions. Certainly a playwright can transcend such limitations; Shakespeare did, but then he was Shakespeare. John Strand is not Shakespeare (and neither are any of us), but I don’t mean to suggest that his play is by any means valueless, only that he has taken on a difficult assignment. In this case a remarkable performance makes of the material a great deal more than that.

*  *  *  *
THE ORIGINALIST (59E59)
by RICK

There are certainly scores of reasons for going to see a play—especially if you’re a theater enthusiast like I am.  (My friend Kirk Woodward and my frequent theater companion Diana are as well, each for their own objectives.)  Aside from having a subscription to the producing theater or the series, or following the hype and buzz, I might be interested in the playwright or, for musicals, the composer; I might be curious about the play if it’s one I don’t know (I’ll be doing that later this month when I see Lillian Hellman’s forgotten 1936 Days to Come).  The director’s work can be the impetus for going to a production, or the acting ensemble’s (often the draw for me with the Acting Company).  Probably the most powerful attraction, however, especially in the current theater in the United States, is the appearance of a particular actor whose work I admire.

Such was the case when I decided to see John Strand’s The Originalist, his sort of bio-play about Antonin Scalia (1936-2016), the late Supreme Court Justice—for the second time at 59E59 Theaters, between Park and Madison Avenues on Manhattan’s East 59th Street.  (To be precise, this was the second time I saw the play, but only the first I saw it live.  On 13 March 2017, I watched The Originalist on Theater Close-Up on WNET-Channel 13, the Public Broadcasting System outlet in New York City.  I reported on the viewing on Rick On Theater on 17 July 2017.)  I encouraged Kirk and Diana to come along, too—all for the purpose of seeing Edward Gero’s performance in the title role, irrespective of how they might end up feeling about the play itself.  (Kirk has written his own report, posted above, on his response to The Originalist.) 

My opinion of the play, as I expressed it in the 2017 report, hasn’t changed.  In fact, I confirmed that I hadn’t misjudged the script, and may have even overlooked some possible criticisms.  (Kirk’s assessment, I’m gratified to see, agrees in large part with mine.)  Well, I don’t see any reason to reiterate my report on Strand’s play or the Arena Stage production, which has been doing a stint here in New York City since mid-July.  (Gero’s fellow cast members are different from the actors I saw on PBS, but the rest of the production—Molly Smith’s staging, Misha Kachman’s sets, Joseph P. Salasovich’s costumes, Colin K. Bills’s lights, and Eric Shimelonis’s sound—is as close to identical to what was presented at Arena’s Kogod Cradle as 59E59’s Theater A can manage.  Tracy Ifeachor has taken over the role of Cat, Scalia’s “flaming” liberal clerk, from Kerry Warren and Brett Mack is now playing Brad, a conservative legal researcher, originally portrayed by Harlan Work.)

For the record, The Originalist premièred at Arena’s Mead Center for American Theater in Washington, D.C., on 6 March 2015.  It was subsequently produced by the Asolo Repertory Theatre of Sarasota, Florida, from 18 January to 7 March 2017 (it opened on Inauguration Day).  Productions from coast to coast followed from Southern California’s Pasadena Playhouse (11 April-7 May 2017), to a return stint at Arena (7 July to 6 August 2017), to Chicago’s Court Theatre (10 May-10 June 2018).  (Scalia died at 79 on 13 February 2016, shortly after the first run at Arena closed.)  Oddly, the text of Strand’s play still has not been published, but an audio book, a recording of a performance with Gero, Harlan, and Work, is available from LA Theatre Works (2016).  (As far as I can tell, there’s so far been only one staging of The Originalist with an entirely different cast and unconnected to Arena Stage: Indiana Repertory Theatre in Indianapolis staged the play 17 October-19 November 2017 with Henry Woronicz as Scalia under the direction of James Still.)

Previews of The Originalist, which runs an hour and three quarters with no intermission, began at 59E59 on 14 July 2018 and the production opened on 19 July; the production is scheduled to close on 19 August.  (The New York presentation is a co-production with Middle Finger Productions, LLC, a company formed by Arena trustee Beth Neuberger for the purpose of effecting this commercial transfer.)  My friends and I saw the show on Wednesday, 2 August, at the 7 p.m. performance.  59E59’s Theater A, on the ground floor of the three-story complex, is the venue’s largest house, seating 195 patrons. 

Theater A has a proscenium stage, which for the first scene of the play represents a law school lecture hall, and the raked house (the play’s spectators are the law students attending Scalia’s lecture) has a single aisle down the center and a transverse aisle about a third of the way up from the stage; Cat makes her entrance in the first scene, guided by an “usher,” half-way across the transverse and then down the center aisle to take a seat at the far left of the first row just as the performance begins.  (This entrance, which is made to look like a late audience member arriving—unless you already know how the play opens—didn’t occur in the TV version of The Originalist.)

Since I wrote a report on the PBS broadcast a year ago, I’m not sure whether I’ll be able to write a different report now, even though two members of the three-member cast are different.  I’ve said all I can about the play itself.  (Those who want a description of Strand’s play, read—or reread—my 2017 report at https://rickontheater.blogspot.com/2017/07/the-originalist-pbs.html.)  I certainly don’t want to debate an absent Scalia on originalism--even though I think the whole concept is absurd and impossible.  (I did make a few comments about this theory in the earlier report, however.) 

The only idea that came to me is to write something about Gero’s acting here.  I think it’s gotten better since the version I saw on TV—with one exception; he’s gotten more comfortable and less “actorly” in the portrayal.  As Kirk says, he “inhabits” the role.  To be honest, I was afraid that after all this time—Gero estimated in July 2017 that he’d played Scalia “over 100” times by then; another year later, he may have doubled that—he might have become technical and mechanical, but he hasn’t.  It may have something to do with the fact that he’s working with a different supporting cast—but considering how much those roles are ciphers to start with, I wonder how much influence they ever had.  In the end, I suspect that it’s simply a matter of Gero’s high level of professionalism and artistic integrity.

I can’t add any information about John Strand’s background to the small bio I provided in my 2017 report.  (It’s amazing how much he’s stayed off the grid!)  Edward Gero also had little personal information on the ’Net.  He was born in 1954 and grew up in Madison, New Jersey, a town of about 16,000 inhabitants 26 miles west of New York City.  (Note that Antonin Scalia was also born in small-town New Jersey before his family moved to Queens, New York.)  Gero attended Catholic schools for elementary and then public Madison High School before going to Montclair State University in suburban Essex County, New Jersey, where he studied theater (and roomed with fellow student Bruce Willis—with whom he would later appear in 1990’s Die Hard 2 and Striking Distance in 1993, two of Gero’s few film or TV performances). 

Though he’d contemplated studying for the priesthood, he became attracted to acting while in high school after seeing Stacy Keach play Hamlet in “the greatest American” staging of the play “in the 20th century” at the New York Shakespeare Festival’s Delacorte Theater in Central Park in the simmer of 1972.  (Directed by Gerald Freedman, the rest of the cast included Colleen Dewhurst as Gertrude, Barnard Hughes as Polonius, James Earl Jones as Claudius, and Sam Waterston as Laertes; Raul Julia played Osric, Charles Durning was a gravedigger, Linda Hunt was the Player Queen, and Christine Baranski was a lady of the court.)  “When I saw it the first time,” proclaimed the actor years later, “I knew I had to come back and see it again and again, and I did."

(Gero later played the Duke of Clarence in a 1990 Richard III opposite Keach—and with other Washington stage luminaries-to-be, Floyd King as Edward IV and Franchelle Stewart Dorn as Queen Elizabeth—and then Gloucester to Keach’s Lear in 2009, both at the Shakespeare Theatre Company in Washington.  Gloucester garnered one of Gero’s 13 Helen Hayes nominations.)

Even before graduating from Montclair State in 1976, he went to New York City, 10 miles across the Hudson River, to ply his new trade as an actor, doing a summer season of small roles at the Classic Stage Company (CSC) in Manhattan’s East Village.  Gero lived the peripatetic life of a tyro actor, while taking gigs at theaters anywhere in the country and returning to New York between jobs.  He was doing a play at the George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia, in 1981 (the famous Barter Theatre was in residence at the school) when John Neville-Andrews, the director of Washington, D.C.’s Folger Theatre Group, saw him in Shaw’s Arms and the Man and asked him to join the rep company.  Gero immediately said yes and soon found himself living and toiling in the Nation’s Capital’s burgeoning theater scene. 

Since then, the actor has won four Hayes Awards, Washington’s acknowledgement of excellence in theater, the regional equivalent of the Tonys and OBIES (named for native Washingtonian Helen Hayes, known as the First Lady of the American Theater).  (In the interest of full disclosure, my late father was a member of the Folger board for several years under Neville-Andrews and was also a Hayes voter.  In 1986, the Folger Theatre Group became the Shakespeare Theatre at the Folger under artistic director Michael Kahn, and then in 1992 was renamed the Shakespeare Theatre Company.)  Gero is an associate professor of drama at George Mason and also teaches at the University of Maryland and George Washington University in the District.  He lives in the Washington suburb of Bethesda, Maryland, with his wife, Marijke Ebbinge, an elementary school and special ed teacher;  their son, Christian, 30, is an award-winning sound designer and audio engineer.

Gero is an experienced Shakespearean actor, having played Macduff in Macbeth (1989), Bolingbroke in Richard II (1994), and King Henry in both parts of Henry IV (1995), all for the Shakespeare Theatre Company and all Helen Hayes Award winners.  (He was nominated for The Originalist; his fourth award was for Skylight at the Studio Theatre in 1997.)  He’s also played other larger-than-life figures, such as the title roles in Sweeney Todd (2010, Signature Theatre, Arlington, Virginia) and Nixon’s Nixon (2000 & 2008, Round House Theatre, Bethesda, Maryland; Helen Hayes nomination).  I’ve personally seen him as Antonio Salieri in Amadeus (2011, Round House; ROT report: 6 July 2011) and Mark Rothko in Red (2012, Arena Stage; ROT report: 4 March 2012).  In that sense, playing Associate Justice of the U.S. Supreme Court Antonin Scalia is business as usual for the actor.

An odd thing about the acting in The Originalist, both on PBS and at 59E59 (and, I gather from reviews, all the other presentations of Arena’s production), is that Gero’s performance is realer, more natural than those of either supporting actor—Ifeachor and Mack in this staging.  That’s odd because, since both the clerk and the researcher are fictional characters, they can speak and behave in any way Strand wants them to, while Scalia’s dialogue is made up of quotations or paraphrases from his writings and speeches or language based on what the playwright believes the justice would say on the basis of his public pronouncements.  That ought to free up Cat and Brad to be more like ordinary people, since a writing artist can invent what they say and do, while Scalia suffers from the same problems a character in a documentary play does.  (See my essay “Performing Fact: The Documentary Drama,” 9 October 2009.)

But that’s not what happened in The Originalist.  I don’t blame Ifeachor and Mack, and only partly fault director Smith; it’s largely the responsibility of writer Strand for devising such stiff and bloodless characters whose inhumanity the actors had little chance to escape.  To paraphrase Jessica Rabbit from 1988’s Who Framed Roger Rabbit: They’re not cardboard.  They’re just written that way.  Gero, however, avoided or defeated the potential for artificiality that Ifeachor and Mack (and the other actors who played those roles) couldn’t. 

How’d he manage that when his castmates couldn’t?  Let’s start with the main reason so we can get on to some particulars: Gero’s just a far better actor than the rest of the company.  Ifeachor and Mack are probably excellent actors (I don’t know their other work, but Arena has its pick of the casting pool); if they weren’t, they wouldn’t have come as close to making their characters as alive and warm as they occasionally did.  But they are far overmatched against Gero—who might very well be able to make a reading of the phone book (assuming someone can still find one these days) seem warm-blooded.  Both his Salieri and Rothko, neither of whom are innately sympathetic figures, came off as pitiable (Salieri) or searching (Rothko) and worthy of concern.

One reason for this ability, I think, is provided by Gero’s own words.  A self-described “utility infielder,” an actor who seems to be able to do any kind of part and is an invaluable member of any repertory company, Gero thinks “there are two kinds of actors: actors who don’t want to disappear into a role and actors who do. And I like to think of myself as the second ilk.  To disappear into the role and to serve the play.”  That pertains, as far as Gero is concerned, to supporting roles and lead parts.  The Post’s Scott W. Berg, a freelancer, characterized the actor’s reputation among the Capital area’s theater leaders as a “Shakespearean actor who knows in his bones how to parse a dramatic text and perfectly capture a character’s emotional arc.”  In my own observation, that nails it pretty accurately.

I can’t really parse native talent.  It’s a God- (or nature-) given gift and pretty much a mystery as far as I’m concerned.  Either you’re born with it or you’re not—and Edward Gero was.  But raw talent isn’t enough to carry an actor through a performance, especially a challenging one.  (That’s the rationale for acting teachers when outsiders ask, ‘Can you really teach acting?’  As Humphrey Bogart’s character in The Barefoot Contessa told Ava Gardner’s character: “If you can act, I can help you.  If you can’t, nobody can teach you.”)  So we can look at what Gero did with that talent, on and off stage, that might have made a difference.

First (only because it comes first chronologically), Gero does homework.  Not every actor does, but Gero does conscientiously.  When he prepared to do Mark Rothko in Red—a role and a play that aren’t unlike Antonin Scalia in The Originalist in scope, stature, and structure—he not only read the biography of the painter that playwright John Logan consulted when he composed the play, James E. B. Breslin’s Mark Rothko: A Biography (University of Chicago Press, 1993), but visited the Rothko Room at the Phillips Collection in Washington where he spent “a few hours” to experience Rothko’s paintings as the artist, who designed the special gallery for this purpose, had intended.  Gero read other published material on Rothko and also corresponded with Rothko scholars.  In one reply to a researcher who shared his findings with Gero, the actor wrote: “I strive to find connections, as is my wont, with the characters I create to make comprehensible, or rather, recognizable, the struggles we share in the journey of being human.” 

Gero did the same thing to prepare for The Originalist, except there was much more to read: all of Scalia’s opinions, dissents, and law articles, and so on.  He read Joan Biskupic’s American Original: The Life and Constitution of Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia (Sarah Crichton Books/Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009) and watched countless videos on YouTube and other sources.  He even went further, which wasn’t possible for Rothko: Gero went to listen to Scalia on the bench in a Supreme Court hearing and met with him several times to learn his mannerisms and spent time with the justice in his chambers. 

The actor also went to lunch with the justice and even went hunting and skeet shooting with him.  Gero told Scalia, “Mr. Justice, this is my entry into the way you think, not what you think, but how you think.”  For one thing, the actor explained, he discovered that “Scalia’s textual interpretations of the constitution [were similar] to how [Gero] . . . parses through Shakespeare scripts.”  To get a different perspective on the man, Gero also sought out “court watchers, other attorneys, friends, colleagues” to talk to about Scalia.

All of this was aimed at analyzing Scalia’s behavior and his way of thinking.  It wasn’t in pursuit of prurience or titillation.  The two men talked about Italy—both their families came from the same region of the old country, about 10 miles apart—and families, and fathers.  They never talked about politics, specific cases, or the play.  (Justice Scalia never saw The Originalist, but he told Gero he was “glad they got a good actor to do it so I won’t be embarrassed.”)  The same was true of conversations with other court people; it was all about building a character.  Gero had extraordinary access, and he took advantage of where he was living and his subject’s openness and generosity—which no other actor assaying the role will be able to do.

So, Gero was well primed to develop the stage role of Antonin Scalia.  He’d gathered a great deal of valuable and useful information about the man, plenty to project a portrait of him to an audience that probably knows—or thinks they know—who Scalia is.  That’s not like playing Mark Rothko or Antonio Salieri.  So, what did the actor do with all his raw data?  That’s the rub, of course.  That’s what separates the actor sheep from the actor goats.

Well, first he worked to turn his observations and info-gathering into actions—that is, stage behavior.  If you’re a mystic, you see Gero “channeling” Scalia, becoming a medium for the justice’s persona to communicate with the audience.  What the actor’s actually doing, of course, is taking control of his body and voice—what many actors call their “instrument”—to train it in rehearsal to do what he wants it to do, in this case, to conform to the physical and vocal image of Antonin Scalia that Gero had assembled from his study of the model for the character Strand wrote.  The same way a dancer learns steps and a singer learns notes, an actor learns movements and speech patterns and timbres.  Gero learned to stand, gesture, and speak like the man he’d been meeting and watching on recordings.  Indeed, the actor has superb control over his physical instrument: the Washington Post  once pointed out that Gero’s eyebrows, for instance, are “capable of any manner of gymnastics.”

With repetition—and that’s what rehearsal is for—the assumed behavior becomes natural; it no longer requires conscience attention and takes on the appearance of ordinary behavior.  (Uta Hagen, in her invaluable book on acting technique, Respect for Acting (Macmillan Publishing, 1973), points out that the French word for ‘rehearsal’ is la répétition, which means exactly what it looks like, and the German is die Probe, which also means ‘test’ or ‘trial.’)  Little by little—and I’m assuming here that Gero didn’t get it all right instantly just because he looks so much like his model (Scalia called the actor his “doppelgänger,” a German work that means ‘lookalike’ with overtones of mysteriousness)—the learned behavior becomes second nature to the actor, something he puts on when he comes into the theater like his costume and make-up.

One example, because it’s clearly not Gero’s natural behavior, is the way his Scalia stands with his arms folded in front of his abdomen, each hand grasping the opposite upper forearm.  The first time I saw Gero do this role, on the Theater Close-Up broadcast, I found it studied and artificial.  It was the sole bit of physical or vocal business Gero did that didn’t seem natural to me—and it still was at 59E59.  Nonetheless, it was obvious that the actor never stopped and thought about taking this pose before doing it, so, appearances aside for the moment, Gero’d certainly made the gesture part of his stage behavior for his Scalia.  Now, I don’t recall ever having seen the late justice take that stance, so maybe he looked awkward doing it as well, and Gero’s appearance was true to life.  But what I saw on stage was one bit of behavior that was automatic, even second nature—because Gero didn’t have to think about doing it—but still not organic, if that distinction makes sense.  As I determined in my first Originalist report, this is a minor glitch in an overall remarkable performance.

The study of how Scalia thought is a little different for an actor.  The physical characterization is somewhat independent of the script, or even the director’s staging.  An actor can move, pose, and speak in pretty much any way he wants and still be doing exactly what the playwright and director want.  Indeed, it’s part of what an actor brings to the part, what he contributes to the production.  But the work Gero did on how his character’s mind works, how he approaches ideas and subjects intellectually—that’s directly applicable to Strand’s text, the words he wrote for Scalia to say (and the ones other characters say to which Scalia reacts). 

What Gero did was try to understand, from the real justice’s writings and speeches, not what Scalia thought about given topics, but how his mind got to that decision.  If the actor could suss that out, then he can apply the same reasoning to the lines Strand wrote and speak them with the same emotional and psychological content, the correct subtext, that Scalia might have given the words.  That’s what makes stage dialogue come alive in an actor’s mouth, that’s why one actor’s Hamlet or Hedda Gabler lives and breathes and we say, ‘Yes!  That’s it exactly.  That’s so right!’ and another’s just sounds like someone dressed up declaiming famous lines and speeches we’ve heard many times before.  (That’s what Stanislavsky was all about, incidentally.)  It looks to me like all Gero’s homework paid off like gangbusters.

Finally, there’s the unquantifiable part: the talent, the art.  What I’ve been talking about up to now had been technique—the application of skill, craft, and training to the work of preparing a performance.  What Gero applies all that to is his innate talent.  He’s a consummate professional, so he doesn’t just rely on his gift, even though by now, he must know he has a prodigious one.  He still does all that homework—and probably more that he doesn’t discuss—even after over 40 years of stage work, but at some point in the rehearsal process, art takes over.  Undeniably, this is where Gero excels, because I have never seen him give a false or actorly—that is, where the craft and effort show though in performance—acting job.  He doesn’t in The Originalist, either (even though his castmates often do).  In fact, one theatergoer, a constitutional law professor, confessed that “the depiction of Scalia feels very accurate.  In fact,  the resemblance is so on point that I found myself forgetting that it was not the real deal.”

As for keeping the character fresh after three years and however-many performances, Gero gives his key.  “It goes back to being a priest,” he declared—a profession for which he contemplated studying before the acting bug bit him in high school.  

You have to say that Mass every day.  I remember when I was an altar boy, Father Callaghan was saying the Mass at 6:30 and barely staying awake, and I thought if you just did it like you believed it, everybody else would.

The the actor continued: “How do you make it fresh?  Well you have to listen to the play.”

As there were no reviews of the TV broadcast of The Originalist, I went back to the original stage production at Arena in 2015, of which the Theater Close-Up presentation was a clone, for a critical summary in my 2017 report.  When Strand’s play hit New York City, as you might imagine, the cyber press all came out.  Show-Score included reviews of the Chicago run and the return engagement at Washington’s Arena in its tally, so I have recalculated Show-Score’s average based on the 13 reviews of the 59E59 production alone.  With a top score of 92 (TheaterScene.net), followed up by one 90 (Broadway World), and a low rating of 45 (Lighting & Sound America), backed by a 65 (TheaterMania), the average score of the New York notices was 80; 85% of the reviews were positive, 8% were mixed, and 8% were negative.  My survey will cover nine published reviews.

No newspapers covered the current mounting of The Originalist, not even the New York Times, which ran a review the of Washington première (summarized in my PBS report), or the Village Voice.  Among the rest of the print press, there were two notices.  David Kortava wrote of the play in the New Yorker, “The setup strains credulity, but the ensuing debates and outings to the rifle range are amusing,” and of the title performance, he reported, “Edward Gero’s hammy portrayal, with those energetic eyebrows, is no conceit.”  The National Review’s Kyle Smith labeled The Originalist “a smart, challenging, heterodox, and delightful look at Antonin Scalia.”  The politically conservative editorial magazine, which doesn’t regularly review plays (though it also ran a notice of the Washington première), reported, “Befitting its placement in the left-wing milieu of New York’s theater scene, the piece is shrewdly constructed by playwright John Strand to give considerable airtime and a sympathetic hearing to the progressive viewpoint.”  In the title role, Smith felt Gero “is a force of nature, by turns funny, exasperating, and exuberant.”  The NR critic-at-large affirmed that “one imagines [the real-life Justice Scalia] had as much fun vivisecting their arguments as Gero’s Scalia does here.”

On TheaterScene.net, Victor Gluck described the play as “part courtroom drama, part debate and partly a portrait of a man who never compromised on his convictions” and Molly Smith’s production as “both riveting and enlightening” under her “swift and powerful”  direction.  In it, reported Gluck in Show-Score’s 92-rated notice, “Edward Gero gives a bravura performance.”  “Gero’s portrayal is a towering achievement in a difficult role which could easily have been one-sided or totally callous and repugnant,” asserted the cyber reviewer, making “Scalia into a colorfully pugnacious and three-dimensional character.”  A “robust and impressive performance,” it “will likely be one of the 2018-2019 season’s very best.”  In conclusion, Gluck asserted that “The Originalist is provocative, stimulating theater” that’s a “surprisingly deep play for summer theatergoing.”

Marina Kennedy declared on Broadway World that The Originalist “is a vital story for our times” and “a thought provoking, insider's view of our American judicial system.”  Kennedy characterized the production (in the review Show-Score rated at 90) as an “enthralling theatrical piece [which] features the finest staging and stellar acting,” and advised her readers, “See it while you can.”  Lauding Gero, who “masters the demanding role of the controversial judge,” the BWW review-writer felt, “The cast’s excellent character portrayals and the well-crafted dialogue makes you feel as though you have entered Scalia’s Supreme Court Chambers.”  CurtainUp’s Elizabeth Ahlfors proclaimed that “John Strand's The Originalist rings with relevancy, highlighted by vibrant encounters of quick-witted minds in dazzling interaction.”  Ahlfors reported that the production is “[d]irected with a sure hand by Molly Smith” and that Gero “paints the larger-than-life Scalia with a love-hate spirit.”

“John Strand’s play is a brave and talented work,” asserted Hazen Cuyler on Theater Pizzazz, and Smith’s staging is “[d]ignified, simple.”  “As Scalia,” Cuyler affirmed, Gero “is effortlessly charming, distinctly cultured and frustratingly dogmatic. . . .  A compelling duality, this emotional and intellectual life revealed by Mr. Gero is a major reason why you may wish to see this divisive production.”  On New York Stage Review, David Finkle warned that “The Originalist is little more than a thinly disguised debate [which] does have its drawbacks.”  Finkle explained: “As the confrontations mount . . ., the question looms as to whether any intern, no matter how comfortable she or he is with a justice, would become quite so vehement.”  The reviewer noted that the play makes frequent mention of Scalia’s reputation as “a monster,” of which the justice even boasts, and Finkle remarked, “As directed by Molly Smith, Gero surely gets that aspect across.” 

Zachary Stewart described The Originalist as a “thought-provoking (and equally contrived) play” which is also “saccharine and affected” on TheaterMania.  The sparring between Scalia and Cat, contended Stewart, makes “The Originalist feel a lot like a Norman Lear sitcom featuring Scalia as Archie Bunker with a Harvard Law degree.”  As a consequence, the TM review-writer, in the notice Show-Score gave a rating of 65, found, “This results in a certain amount of sitcom acting from Gero” and his sparring partner “who commit to the more ludicrous exchanges in Strand's script . . . with forced gusto.”  Stewart complained about “Gero . . . arming himself with bulging eyes and sarcastic one-liners.”  Of the production, the TM writer reported that “director Molly Smith wisely spotlights the text with an uncluttered and highly focused staging.” 

“Theatre companies can be tripped up by the exigencies of scheduling, especially when topical works are involved,” warned David Barbour, whose review on Lighting & Sound America was awarded a rating of 45, Show-Score’s lowest for this show.  “Some months ago, the idea of presenting a cuddly comedy about the rabidly conservative Supreme Court justice Antonin Scalia may have seemed like a good, even daring, idea,” Barbour noted, but circumstances have changed, he pointed out, listing the abortive nomination of Merrick Garland, the subsequent appointment of Neil Gorsuch, and the coming “savage battle over Brett Kavanaugh.”  The LSA reviewer asks, somewhat testily to my ear, “[D]oes anyone think that a healthy chunk of the New York theatre audience wants to see a play in which Scalia rants and raves for over an hour, only to be revealed as a teddy bear under the black robes?”  Turning to Strand’s script, Barbour declared, “The premise of The Originalist is pure sitcom,” and contended, “It's a setup designed to yield all sorts of crackling confrontations; trouble is, Strand struggles to make it minimally believable.”  He further complained, “Strand undermines his plot with tired television-comedy tropes.” 

As for the performance of the title character, Barbour found, “The role of Scalia is designed to be a rich dish for an actor to feast upon, and Edward Gero tucks into it with gusto—perhaps too much so.”  The review-writer added, “He has been playing the role on and off since 2015 and if it ever was more astringent it is now being delivered with a wink and a nudge that only makes the character more irritating.”  Barbour lamented that “one wishes the director, Molly Smith, had exercised a little more judicial oversight on her cast.”  In conclusion, Barbour felt, “Too much of the time . . ., The Originalist settles for easy, odd-couple comedy at the expense of character and real conflict. . . .  That we are supposed to find such an outcome both adorable and emotionally satisfying only demonstrates how out of touch with our current political reality this play is.”

02 August 2018

Stephen Schwartz

by Kirk Woodward

[Soon after I got out of the army in 1974 and moved to New York City, I started trying to catch up on theater.  After almost five years of active duty, including 2½ in West Berlin, Germany, I was woefully behind.  I had one advantage when I got to New York: my family was connected to a business headquartered here—just a few blocks up 5th Avenue from where I ended up living—that had a ticket broker on retainer and allowed members of the owners’ families to take advantage of this perk (intended for sales reps to entertain buyers) on the company.  I decided I’d go to as many shows as I could manage—and, when I started classes at the American Academy of Dramatic Arts, I treated my classmates with a freebie, too. 

[I started making my way through the ABC’s in the New York Times, crossing off shows as I saw them.  I started with productions that had been running for a while, feeling that I ought to get to them before newer show in case they closed soon.  I think the first Broadway play I went to was the musical Raisin and I went on to such productions as Scapino, Thieves, Clarence Darrow, and Equus, as well as musicals like The Wiz and Candide, and each of them offered some special impression and a lasting memory.  But one I remember particularly well was Stephen Schwartz and Roger O. Hirson’s musical play Pippin, which had opened in 1972 under Bob Fosse’s direction and was still running when I got to the city.  Everything about Pippin attracted me—the characteristic Fosse choreography, Tony Walton’s abstract expressionist scenic design, Patricia Zipprodt’s mod-inspired “medieval” costumes, Hanson’s smart-ass, hip book (enhanced by Fosse’s uncredited assistance), and, most of all, Schwartz’s wonderful, fanciful, knowing, and delightful songs.  I loved the characters, including Pippin and Berthe, his wise—and wise-ass—grandmother, and the amazing idea of the non-representational Leading Player.  (I can’t recall whom  I saw in all those roles, and I seem to have misplaced my Broadway Pippin program, but I'm pretty sure Ben Vereen had left the show by then, as had Irene Ryan.  I think John Rubenstein was still doing Pippin because I had never liked him much, but revised my opinion on the basis of this performance—so I must have seen him.)  

[When I started taking voice lessons some years later, I chose to work on “Corner of the Sky” as a potential audition piece.  It seemed to describe me—or my view of myself.  (Remember, I was still just around 30 at the time—though moving up fast!)  I also saw several other Pippin productions, including one directed in 1983 by my friend Kirk Woodward—who just happens to be the author of this article for Rick On Theater based on his recent reading of Defying Gravity: The Creative Career of Stephen Schwartz, from Godspell to Wicked, a “creative biography” of the composer-lyricist by Carol de Giere.  Kirk’s better situated to tell you about a musical artist and his work, so I’ll just let him take over from here.  ~Rick]

In 1972 or ’73 I went to Ford’s Theatre, in Washington, DC, to see a matinee performance of what I believe was the first national company production of the musical Godspell (which had opened in New York City in 1971), about which I’d heard good things.

Those reports underestimated the effect of the show on me: I was amazed, overwhelmed, thrilled by the audacious theatricality of the piece, by its commitment to the ideals of love and community, and by the fact that as a piece of theater it seemed to succeed in actually reinforcing those ideals – something I wasn’t certain that theater could do.

The cast of that production spoke a few months later to the drama department at Catholic University in Washington, where I was then enrolled. The Jesus in that production was Dean Pitchford (b. 1951), who later became a successful songwriter. I remember the obvious camaraderie of the cast – being in Godspell often seems to create that effect. Since those days I have both directed and musically directed the show myself.

In 1972, the musical Pippin opened in New York City, directed by the outstanding choreographer Bob Fosse (1927-1987), and I remember hearing a professor at Catholic University say that Fosse had told him, during the Washington out-of-town tryout for Pippin, that he was scratching his head trying to think of staging ideas for some of the songs in the show.

Pippin became “my show” in New York City, where I was living by that time – I saw the original cast and the first replacements perhaps a dozen times. I couldn’t get enough of – well, its audacious theatricality.

The link between these two shows, Godspell and Pippin, is, of course, that both musicals included scores written (or mostly written, in the case of Godspell) by the songwriter Stephen Schwartz (b. 1948). Schwartz was brought in to write a replacement score for the original production of Godspell; Pippin was conceived by Schwartz and a classmate, Rob Strauss, at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh, and Schwartz nursed it along all the way to Broadway.

I learned those facts, and many others, from a used copy I picked up recently of an excellent “creative biography” of Stephen Schwartz titled Defying Gravity, written by Carol de Giere and published by Applause Theatre & Cinema Books in 2008.

Carol de Giere is an admirer of Schwartz’s work – she has edited a “fanzine” about him – and the tone of the book can occasionally be a little breathless. However, the book is not a hagiography; she keeps it at the level of the factual and the objective.

A list of Schwartz’s musical theater work includes Godspell (1971), Pippin (1972), The Magic Show (1974), The Baker’s Wife (1976), Working (1978), Rags (lyrics only, 1986), Children of Eden (1991), and Wicked (2003), among other shows.

Of those listed, three had initial runs of over nineteen hundred performances each on Broadway (Pippin, The Magic Show, and Wicked), and Godspell had a similarly long run Off Broadway. Over time Schwartz has reworked many of these shows, which have gone on to be produced frequently around the country, internationally, and again on Broadway.

Wicked, still thriving on Broadway, has so far achieved overall earnings of over three billion dollars, illustrating the maxim of the playwright George Axelrod (1922-2003) that on Broadway you can’t make a living, but you can make a killing.

Schwartz has also written the lyrics for songs in the movies Pocahontas (1995), The Hunchback of Notre Dame (1996), Enchanted (2007), and music and lyrics for the film The Prince of Egypt (1998). In addition, he collaborated with Leonard Bernstein (1918-1990) on Bernstein’s Mass (1971). He has won Tony, Academy, and Grammy Awards for his work.

Schwartz cooperated on the book Defying Gravity, with the proviso that it be about his creative, rather than his personal life, so we only meet his wife, Carol, as an intelligent and supportive voice, and his son Steve as a successful director. Some basic themes emerge from the book:

Schwartz is a definite “personality.” He comes across in the book as focused, knowledgeable, opinionated, and sometimes, for those reasons, a real pain to work with.

As I mentioned above, the book is called a “creative biography,” which means that its focus is on the process of building a musical, rather than on the personalities involved. Still, personalities can’t be avoided. A musical is very much a group endeavor, which means there is always potential for conflict between song writers and book writers, the producer, director, choreographer, musical director, scenic designer, and so on.

With such dynamic tensions, and with a great deal of money at stake (Wicked’s initial cost was estimated at $14,000,000), two things are likely to happen: most of those involved in a show are likely to have to take subordinate roles, and some – usually one – is likely to be the dominant voice, or, as William Goldman labels it in his great book on Broadway The Season, “the muscle.”

Carol de Giere makes it clear that Schwartz was always prepared to be “the muscle” in his shows; however, this did not always happen. The trait can be traced to Schwartz’s childhood:

There was one language-based trait Schwartz seemed to be born with that sometimes got him in trouble: he spoke his mind. His mother reports on problems at school related to her son’s willful expressions. “He would speak out of turn, and maybe want to talk without giving other people a turn. He didn’t do anything seriously delinquent in any way, but he was not a docile little boy in class.”

Carol de Giere describes how this trait worked out in adult life (in this case with Wicked):

Schwartz’s inner game was perfectionism – something he found hard to release even in those stressful times. When the fussing over changes got out of hand, it could drive cast members a little crazy. “For the most part, we all respected Stephen a great deal,” says [performer] Robin Lamont. “And if we worked hard, he worked three times as hard. We would leave at midnight, come in the next day at nine in the morning to rehearse after having done a show the night before. And he would have been up half the night. He was always, always, always working.”

“We had terrible fights. I remember feelings running very high. There was frustration. We’d ask ourselves, ‘Why isn’t this playing as well as it should?’ We’d come in and Stephen would say, ‘I want to try this; I want to try that.’ I think sometimes there was the feeling that, ‘We’re sick of this, we don’t want to try it one more way. We want to go home and sleep.’”

And this was for a musical where the working process went fairly smoothly! By contrast, when Bob Fosse (1927-1987) was hired as director and choreographer for Pippin, Roger Hirson (b. 1926), who wrote the book for the musical, told Schwartz, “This is our last happy day on this show.“

Schwartz had worked on Pippin from the beginning; it was “his baby.” But Fosse was by this point “the muscle” in any show he worked on. Carol de Giere writes that

Bob Fosse may have believed he was doing Broadway beginner Schwartz a favor by directing his show. [David] Spangler [a friend of Schwartz’s] suggests, “Fosse was truly interested in keeping current with trends that were beginning to happen, like rock music, which was starting to enter the vocabulary of Broadway. He just thought he’d whip Stephen into shape.”

Between Fosse’s ego and Schwartz’s, a collision was bound to occur, and it did. Interestingly, years later Schwartz commented that for the amateur version of the show, he and Roger Hirson had removed a number of the additions that Fosse had made to the script, and

In recent years, I’ve come to feel that the show is better with them, and we’ve put the majority of them back in. It’s ironic that I’ve become the champion of Bob’s vision. When asked about the revisions I sometimes joke, “I know somewhere Bob is looking up and laughing.”

I would guess, then, that at a minimum Schwartz is no pushover in the case of a difference of opinion, and that this characteristic can make him a formidable force to reckon with. He is aware of this:

If someone says to you that a song isn’t working, you think, well, maybe they’re right. So when do you stand up and believe in yourself? When do you say, “I don’t care what you’re saying, I know this is right” – when is it stubbornness or arrogance, and when is it [appropriate] conviction? It’s a tricky thing.

The impression of Schwartz’s potential for “digging in” is reinforced by another major theme of de Giere’s book:

Schwartz has plenty of technique to help him in his work. He is a conscious, thoughtful, and fundamentally methodical worker, so there is no need for him to feel insecure or self-conscious about his ideas.

As I said above, de Giere calls her book a “creative biography,” and much of the book describes in detail how Schwartz puts together his scores.  For me, there are few subjects more interesting than how an artist goes about creating her or his work. Schwartz’s processes are fascinating.

I could quote numerous examples, but here are two. Talking about working on the score for the film Pocahontas (lyrics by Schwartz, music by Alan Menkin, b. 1949), Schwartz says:

Because I didn’t think I was good casting as lyricist for the project, I consciously thought about who would have been better casting and then modeled my work on theirs . . . . I decided on Oscar Hammerstein II and Sheldon Harnick [the lyricist for Fiorello, She Loves Me, and Fiddler on the Roof], because they wrote for ethnic people and folk people, and they dealt with issues of prejudice and cultural misunderstanding. And so as I wrote, I consciously tried to assimilate their styles. When I wrote “Colors of the Wind” I thought, “What would Oscar do? What would Sheldon write?” I just recalled their sensibility. It was just a matter of adjusting my mindset to think how they would approach a song. I didn’t steal anything specific from them. I just took in their sensibility and filtered it back out again.

And here is an example about structuring a song from Wicked. Schwartz describes how, in the musical A Chorus Line, there is no “kick line” of dancers until almost at the end of the show, making the audience wait for an obviously obligatory event until the last possible moment.

So I started thinking about this new song, and the fact that we now had Idina Menzel in the cast as Elphaba. People who knew her would be expecting her to come out and do this great big belt. I thought that as long as I was writing this song again [he was writing a replacement for an existing song], what if I saved the big belt until the very end of the song? So I really tailored the song to Idina in that way. Notice that the big belt section comes way late, at the very end of “The Wizard and I.”

Schwartz’s songwriting process is in many respects a highly conscious one. This aspect of his technique brings to mind Stephen Sondheim (b. 1930), who has said that he doesn’t have the instinct to just sit down and write a song – he needs a situation for it to come out of. Schwartz works on a show the same way:

For me, when I am working on a musical number for a show, the story I am trying to tell comes first. It is a little like an acting exercise – I try to become the character, think about what the character’s action is (what he or she is trying to ‘do’ at that moment), and then express myself as that character would.

However, Schwartz may or may not be restricted to that way of working. He has released two very fine solo albums of songs, only three of which were written for shows. (He has co-writers on a number of the songs; collaboration is a frequent aspect of his work.)

The album Reluctant Pilgrim was released in 1997. I don’t know how it sold, but the title of the second album, Uncharted Territory (2005) may be an indication. (Schwartz, incidentally, has a career background as a record producer.)

I mention these albums, full of lovely songs that would make excellent material for cabaret artists, to point out a third aspect of Schwartz’s career:

His musical style has been the biggest obstacle to full acceptance of his work. When the book Defying Gravity was published, in 2008, Schwartz had not yet been inducted into the American Theater Hall of Fame (he has now) – this for someone who by that year was clearly one of the most successful Broadway artists of all time.

Why? Largely, I suspect, from an initial impression that he wasn’t really a “Broadway” composer at all but a “popular” composer. He is, of course, both, but many of his primary early influences were pop rather than musical theater – he feels particularly indebted to the singer-songwriter Laura Nyro (1947-1997) and the Motown songs written by the team of Holland-Dozier-Holland (Brian Holland, b. 1941; Lamont Dozier, b. 1941; and Eddie Holland, b. 1939). 

It should be mentioned that another of his childhood listening enthusiasms was opera! However, when composing the score of Godspell, a popular music sensibility was called for. That score has been criticized for its lack of sophistication in comparison with, for example “golden age” Broadway musicals. This criticism ignores the score’s intent – a mix of pop and folk music is what it’s meant to be.

The score for Pippin also is highly pop-influenced (and its cast album, produced by Schwartz and released by Motown Records, was a big seller); the same is true for compositions in subsequent shows, but Schwartz is not limited to one musical style. His reviewers, however, have often been limited to one musical vision.

The battle between “popular” (often meaning “rock”) and “Broadway” music is no longer worth fighting after the success of the rock-oriented musicals Hair (1967) and Rent (1996), and in an era when the most successful musical of our time – Hamilton, which opened in 2015 – is predominantly rap. [See Kirk’s article “Theatrical and Popular Songs,” posted on ROT on 2 October 2011. ~Rick] The times they were a-changin’ – to quote a Bob Dylan song – when Schwartz emerged on the musical theater scene, and they continue to change.

Schwartz contributed to that process, and in addition his work has held up well on its own. For me, his songs are such an integral part of my musical knowledge that I can hardly imagine doing without them.

Defying Gravity is rich in detail; I have only skimmed the surface of a book invaluable for anyone interested in Steven Schwartz, in musical theater, in Broadway lore, and in the writing process. It’s a book worthy of its subjects.

[Kirk  told me that when he received Schwartz’s Defying Gravity from Amazon, he “happened to open the front cover of the book and found that he’d signed it.”  What a nice little lagniappe!

[I told you above how I responded to Schwartz’s Pippin, and you see that Kirk and I essentially agree in our assessments of that ground-breaking musical.  I might add, in the spirit of full disclosure, that I don’t respond to Godspell quite as enthusiastically.  Whenever I’ve attended a performance of Godspell, I always feel like I don’t really belong there—as if I’ve wandered surreptitiously into a church and sooner or later, everyone’ll turn around and point at me and shout: “INTERLOPER!”  (You see, I’m not Christian.  The gospels are someone else’s holy texts, but not mine.)  Jesus Christ Superstar makes me feel similarly uneasy—plus I’ve never been crazy for Andrew Lloyd Webber.)]

28 July 2018

Short Takes: Some Unique Performances


[Back on 17 June, I posted another “Short Takes,” the ROT shorthand for a collection of brief articles usually too short to post on their own.  That collection, subtitled “Some Art Shows,” consisted of six small reports on art exhibits that didn’t merit extensive discussion.  Now I’m doing the same thing with some reports on four shows, three from 1985 and one from 2006 (all before I started Rick On Theater in 2009) that also didn’t get longer write-ups.  They’re all also, in their  own ways, unusual performances. 

[The last report below, Man of the Heart, was originally a section of a longer one on theater and art that I sent out to friends out of town before I launched ROT.  (Long-time ROTters will know that that was the seed of this blog: reports I sent to those out-of-town friends.)  The three 1985 performances were in-house reports I made for my boss in an abortive theater venture back then.  I briefly worked with a former teacher who was planning to start a theater.  While the founder and artistic director was exploring the possibilities, she often asked me to scout out performances, performers, scripts, and writers as potential future production material and creators.]

THEATER OF PANIC
18 February 1985

Theater of Panic (the title is adapted from Spanish playwright Fernando Arrabal) with Geoff Hoyle and Keith Terry is billed as “a contemporary vaudeville featuring bits, skits, gags, falls, trips, disasters. miscalculations. letdowns, vulgar slapstick and intellectual comedy.”  (Both performers are alumni of the San Francisco-based Pickle Family Circus.)  Presented by the Dance Theater Workshop’s Economy Tires Theater at the Bessie Schönberg Theater, 219 W. 19th Street in Chelsea, the performance was “especially commissioned . . . by Dance Theater Workshop, Inc.”  I saw it at the 8 o’clock show on the evening of Sunday, 17 February [1985].  (The show, which runs Friday through Sunday, opened on 15 February and closes on 3 March.)

It’s a two-man routine, or series of routines, that’s reminiscent of Bill Irwin’s The Regard of Flight in approach and attitude, if not in material (though there is some similarity) or appeal.  [The Regard of Flight first appeared at the American Place Theatre in Mid-Manhattan in 1982 and was televised by PBS for Great Performances in 1983.]  Most of the pieces are essentially solo turns by one or the other of the performers, each with his own specialties, though there are a few in which both men perform.

The program doesn’t identify the individual pieces (which may change from performance to performance—I’m not sure).  Here’s a very simplified description of what I saw:

The first piece seemed to be an abstract mime/dance routine, performed by Hoyle with off-stage accompaniment by Terry on home-made percussion instruments (cookie sheets and the like).  The audience broke out into intermittent peals of laughter, but I had no idea what was happening, or why it was funny.  I got the impression that the audience was full of people familiar with the duo’s work.  (This was the third performance, and the first Sunday show—that is, the first 8 p.m. show; Friday and Saturday shows are at 11 p.m.) 

After this piece, and between all the rest of the bits, Terry did one of his specialties:  Body Music.  For the uninitiated, that’s the use of the body as a percussion instrument, with pops, slaps, taps, clicks, and slides, which Terry sometimes accompanies with vocal “music” as well.  The first of these bits was mildly amusing to me, but subsequent repetitions, though they were all different, did not excite me.  The audience seemed to enjoy it, and met each one with anticipatory laughter when Terry stepped center stage with the sheepish look that signaled he was about to do this bit.  Except for the manual dexterity it demonstrates, I don’t really see the talent in this.

The second bit was a “lecture/demonstration” of the relation of percussion and movement that was primarily a series of slapstick pratfalls which were supposed to be punctuated by Terry on drums, but for which he missed all the cues (on purpose—Terry’s persona is dim-witted.)

One of the cleverest bits, but which, like most of them, went on too long, was a strange routine in which the two men, dressed in overcoats a size or two too large, stood as if on a subway.  While Terry read his paper, Hoyle struggled with a hand which came out of his overcoat, first through the front, then through the neck, and attacked him.  Eventually it was joined by its mate and strangled Hoyle.  Macabre, but funny.

After Terry’s usual Body Music interlude, he returned with two of those “canned cow” toys—the kind that “moo” when they’re moved.  He did a very funny rendition of “Proud Mary” with the cans as accompaniment.

There followed a bit that started with Hoyle doing both Pantalone and Arlecchino in Commedia dell’Arte masks in Italian.  Though fairly standard characterizations, this was mildly amusing until it kept going on, with the Italian dialogue.  This bit was combined with a long piece in which first Hoyle, then both the men, performed in a jester’s belled cap and “nose and glasses” (Groucho) mask, and with a series of puppets which consisted of a stick with a head mounted on it which was made to look exactly like the two men in their masks.  This piece had no dialogue, and very soon became uninteresting and repetitious.

Terry’s next bit was an amusing piece in which he made “music” with a collection of children’s toys.

Hoyle’s final solo piece was a true clown performance, which was marred again by its length.  It centered on his attempt to play a trombone: at first he can’t assemble it, then he can’t remember the music, then he can’t hold the music and play, then he assembles a music stand, but extends it nearly to the ceiling, then he tries balancing on a chair on top of the prop trunk to reach it.  Toward the end, Terry hands him a violin, which Hoyle proceeds to play in a poor man’s Victor Borge routine (not Jack Benny).

The last bit was a routine with wooden batons.  It combined syncopated “martial art-like” exercises, rhythmic rapping, and a little balancing and acrobatics.  I found it mildly interesting.

Though the New York Times made the obvious comparison to Bill Irwin, Theater of Panic isn’t anywhere near as funny, clever, or antic as Irwin’s work, and Hoyle and Terry don’t measure up in the talent department either.  There were a few clever bits (the “hand” routine, for instance), but all of them went on far too long.  The evening was an hour and a half, but should have been an hour at most. 

I also acknowledge that the audience seemed to enjoy the evening, and gave the men two extra curtain calls (they came out for a third while everyone was putting on their coats, which got a final laugh).  I may just not be the right audience for this material—clowns are not generally my favorite humor.  Theater of Panic was also apparently taped for the Dance Collection of the Library and Museum of the Performing Arts at Lincoln Center; it may be available for viewing there if anyone’s curious.

Mel Gussow of the Times characterized Hoyle and Terry as “polar icecap opposites and therein lies the key to their New Vaudeville comedy.”  The Timesman continued: “Mr. Hoyle, who is English, would not be out of character in the Monte Python company.  He is a fervidly expressive clown, always in a rush or in a dither—or a rushing dither—while Mr. Terry, a bearded American, is his calm, deadpan straight man and musical accompanist.”  Gussow found that the pair “are an amusing team, though in Mr. Hoyle's case there is a tendency to attenuate the circumstances.” Like me, the reviewer felt, ”Careful pruning would enliven the evening.” 

*  *  *  *
DANITRA VANCE
27 February 1985

On Saturday night, 23 February [1985], I went down to the East Village to catch Danitra Vance and the Mell-0 White Boys at the La MaMa Cabaret.  Vance is a black, female, solo artist who performs in a cabaret atmosphere.  She works with a “back-up group” called the Mell-O White Boys who accompany her when she sings. (One of the “Boys” was sick and replaced by a Mell-O White Girl the night I saw them.)  The New York Times described her as “feminist,” but that label is misleading in the sense that her material isn’t aggressively political or hostilely anti-male.  She does deal with the role of women in our world with humor and biting satire, but her tongue is planted so firmly in her cheek that it’s a kind of feminism without tears.  I laughed continuously throughout the entire hour-and-a-half, despite the late hour (11 p.m. starting time); excruciatingly uncomfortable, hard, wooden chairs; and the crowded, small, close cabaret in the basement of La MaMa. 

The audience for the performance was a very mixed bag.  There were as many blacks as whites, the ages were decidedly mixed, ranging from 20’s to 40’s and 50’s, and, though there was a majority of women, there were also a large number of men, mostly accompanied by women.  (I think I was the only single person there.)  Many came with wine or beer, expecting small tables and a night-club set up.  Instead, there were only small, wooden chairs set up in a proscenium arrangement with a center aisle.  The cabaret had a bar in the rear of the room that sold coffee and tea.  The audience didn’t seem to mind the long wait upstairs in the small lobby or the fact that the house was opened late and the show was delayed for some reason.  Everyone was very convivial and social, jockeying for seats, and opening drinks.

The stage had a piano, a microphone, and several pieces of costume draped about, ready for quick changes of character.  As it turns out, some of Vance’s changes also take place off stage.  In the hour-and-a-half, she did 10 character turns, all of which are unique and startling.  Her characters aren’t recognizable types, but strange exaggerations created from her own imagination, touching on reality only in the sense that they are those kinds of situations we would like to see (remember the old Mad Magazine bit, “Ads We’d Like to See”?) 

Among her most outrageous characters are a Lesbian Recruiter; Harriet Hetero, a feminist stripper; and Robin Reluctant, a female-to-male transsexual.  Some of Vance’s more off-the-wall ideas: her entrance bit with a tommy gun swaddled in a blanket like a baby; a character who is a “Mydol junkie”; an “avant-garde rap artist” who will be performing her new rap opera, “Feinstein on the Beach” at SLAM—Some Little Academy of Music.  Harriet requests that we call her “ma’am—in honor of my mammary glands”; Robin introduces his back-up group as the TIT’s—Transsexuals In Training.

Vance has a fondness for using lyrics to popular songs in her dialogue, and the results are often hilarious.  She also parodies the songs themselves in some of her routines (the Lesbian Recruiter sings “My Girl” and Robin uses “I Am a Man” as his routine).  She likes to play with her audience, and she knows how to get them to respond and play along.  This isn’t, however, an “audience-participation” show.  She doesn’t restrict herself to the stage, moving up and down the center aisle, and doing the Lesbian recruiter turn from the bar in the rear (this wasn’t particularly easy to see, however). 

Vance, who calls herself “Everywoman—and some men,” is a clever, funny, imaginative, and creative performer. (Comparisons with Whoopi Goldberg seem to be based on two similarities: they’re both black and female.  From what I know of Goldberg, the similarity ends there.)  According to La MaMa, she will be performing her current show weekend evenings (11 p.m.) “indefinitely.”  She is usually sold out a week in advance.  Go with a friend or two, bring a bottle of wine—and a cushion.  And keep an eye on her!

In the Village Voice, Alisa Solomon wrote, “Danitra Vance creates magic of a sharper sort.  [Solomon was comparing Danitra Vance and the Mell-O White Boys with a Sam Shepard play which shared the Voice reviewer’s column.]  Her comedy stabs while it entertains, actually causing a physical catch in your laughter as she undercuts every pose she takes.”  Solomon characterized the performer as “[b]eginning with and then undermining stereotypes” and adding that “Vance creates an unsettling tension among stereotypes, reality, and the conditions that create stereotypes.”  She reported that Vance “doesn’t stop to let zingers sink in; she hits and runs.” 

Stephen Holden described Vance and her back-up group as offering “incisive, cheerfully liberating musical comedy that knowingly turns sexual and racial stereotypes inside out.”  In an earlier column, Holden reported that Vance’s “comedy is as endearing as it is incisive.”  The review-writer characterized the comedian as a “classically trained actress who is equally cognizant of Shakespeare and Motown” and “takes special delight in overlaying highbrow and pop cultural references in amusingly drastic combinations.”  Holden explained, “The theme of Miss Vance’s show, repeated in many variations, is the comic thrill and liberating insights of every sort of role reversal.”  He cautioned: “Miss Vance will inevitably be compared to Whoopi Goldberg, but she’s no carbon copy, and the town is big enough for two of them.”

[Danitra Vance did a brief stint as a regular member of the cast of Saturday Night Live from 1985-86, the sketch-comedy show’s 11th season.  She was diagnosed with breast cancer in 1990 and after a mastectomy and a brief remission, the cancer returned in 1993 and Vance died of the disease in 1994 at the age of 40.]

*  *  *  *
MARY ELLEN BERNARD
30 March 1985

You must see Mary Ellen Bernard sing.  I caught her on 27 March [1985] at Panache, the cabaret at the Magic Pan (1409 Avenue of the Americas, between 57th and 58th Streets).  On the surface, her act is a standard cabaret solo turn, but her material and style are fresh and unusual.  I can’t really describe what she does because it falls flat in words, but I can give you a taste.  Most of her material is either original (by friends of husband Paul Guzzone, who’s her musical director) or seldom-performed material by the likes of Noel Coward and Stephen Sondheim.  Furthermore, what she does with the songs makes even the familiar numbers new and fresh. 

Emmy draws heavily on her background and experience as an actress.  At the risk of sounding over-intellectual, she imbues her performance with abhinaya, the quality of Indian performance that indicates that the artist is experiencing and communicating something special through her technique.  An example:  One of her numbers is an operatic version of a musical-comedy version of Thomas Mann’s Death in Venice.  Emmy plays all the roles, switching costume pieces for each character.  Not only is the idea wonderfully absurd, but the presentation had the entire house on the floor. 

I know Emmy slightly through some friends with whose acting company she used to perform before she decided to turn her energies to preparing a cabaret singing act.  She was a good character actress, but she’s special in her new guise.  There’s something in her of the qualities of Edith Piaf and Lotte Lenya, though they haven’t fully matured yet.  I saw her act for the first time this week, though she’s been performing around the cabaret showcase circuit for about a year now.  My estimation is that as soon as she gets either a major review or the kind of exposure TV can provide, she’ll take off. 

She has no current plans for her next appearance, but she won’t be idle too long.  She’s promised to send me two flyers for her next performance.

*  *  *  *
MAN OF THE HEART
9 May 2006

I got an e-mail from an acquaintance—Suman Mukherjee—informing me that he was here in New York City with his latest directing project, Man of the Heart: The Life & Times of Lalon Phokir, a one-performer, multi-media piece about the life and philosophy of a 19th-century Bengali sage.  (‘Phokir’ is an alternate spelling for what we commonly call ‘Fakir,’ a Sufi Muslim ascetic who’s taken a vow of poverty and religious devotion, renouncing all connection to the secular world.)  The piece, written and performed by Sudipto Chatterjee from research he conducted, with Suman’s assistance, over some 15 years (including a recent trip to Bangladesh, where Lalon died in 1890 at about 116—and no, that’s not a typo!), reminded me very generally of Peter Brook’s Tierno Bokar, which I saw in 2005.  [My report about this play was posted on 28 August 2011]. 

It’s not that the pieces were alike in terms of production, or even theme, but both Man and Tierno Bokar are essentially single-performer pieces (Tierno Bokar had other actors and characters, but the focus was almost exclusively on the title character) and they’re both about religious figures, sages and teachers, who are generally unknown in the West, both of whom have ties to Sufi Islam, and both of whom lived in regions under the rule of European colonial powers (Lalon in the India of the British Raj and Bokar in French Africa).  Tierno Bokar, however, is about that colonialism and the devastation of intolerance (in this case, Muslim-on-Muslim intolerance) and Man is an exploration of the profundity of Lalon’s true philosophy, as opposed to the myths and legends that grew up around him and his legacy after his death.  Granted, the similarities are superficial—but nevertheless, unmistakable.

Though Tierno Bokar included some of Bokar’s teachings, most of the text of that play—and it was more of a conventional “play,” despite Brook’s proclivities, than is Man—was ordinary prose (performed entirely in English) adapted by Marie-Hélène Estienne from Amadou Hampaté Ba’s biography of Bokar (Tierno Bokar, le sage de Bandiagara, 1957; translated into English as A Spirit of Tolerance: The Inspiring Life of Tierno Bokar).  Man of the Heart’s text—in English and Bengali (with supertitles)—is a combination of research (there is very little record of Lalon and even less that is reliable) and the songs he composed to spread his philosophy, which preached tolerance and an abhorrence for religious conflict. 

Brook’s physical production was simple, but it was a stage set; Suman designed a non-representative playing area—essentially a long white bolt of cloth and a stand-alone doorway, various parts of which also served as the screen—very interestingly used in several different ways—for the projections which were an integral part of the show at the little Off-Off-Broadway Kraine Theatre across from La MaMa in the East Village, where the show ran from 27 April until 7 May [2006].  (In this one, small aspect, Suman’s staging brings to mind the use of projections by Ariane Mnouchkine in Le Dernier Caravansérail at last summer’s Lincoln Center Festival, projected, like Suman’s, on different parts of the set and surrounding drapes—and, in several instances in Man, onto the back of Lalon’s robe which Chatterjee held spread out.  Mnouchkine’s projections, though, were all text, while Suman’s are text, occasionally title slides like Brecht might have used; charts, such as an abbreviated family tree; drawings; photos; and film/video—both original and “borrowed.”) 

Another difference between Brook’s effort and Suman and Mr. Chatterjee’s: Tierno Bokar was only curious for a while, then became entirely unengaging to me [as you can see from my report] but Man, though less smooth and polished (not necessarily a fault) than Tierno Bokar, was almost always interesting.  I attribute this to the content more than anything else: Brook was examining intolerance—certainly a worthy and potentially dramatic subject—but his vehicle was an extremely narrow point, whether a particular Muslim prayer should be said 11 times or 12, that is totally irrelevant and incomprehensible to us here in the West.  It was like Swift’s Little-Endians and Big-Endians.  But Man is an attempt to examine Lalon’s lessons about life and the spirit—a subject that has more resonance for all of us, regardless of our faiths (or lack of it). 

Some of Lalon’s songs are hard to interpret (part of his legend, because he had to disguise his intent in codes and misdirection to avoid persecution by both Muslims and Hindus), and the passages that are essentially lectures by Chatterjee were hard to stick with because they are uncharacteristically untheatrical, but enough of what Lalon and Man are examining is worth hearing to make the whole endeavor worthy.  While I didn’t walk out of Tierno Bokar wanting to know any more about Bokar, I left Man curious to learn more about Lalon.  That may have been in the nature of the two subjects, or it may have been because of the two performances.

[There were no reviews of the New York production that I could find at the time, but Suman and Chatterjee have staged the play many times around the world and I’ve collected several notices of other productions.  First, there’s a review of that Kraine Theatre mounting by Prachi Deshpande, who teaches history at the University of California, Berkeley, on a website called parabaas.com in 2007.  In it, Deshpande stated at the outset, “The writer-performer Sudipto Chatterjee and the director of the performance Suman Mukherjee deserve tremendous praise for their efforts to showcase the oeuvre and philosophy of this remarkable poet and thinker.”  He declared, “The performance succeeded above all in conveying the sheer joyousness and irreverence that pervades so much of devotional, mystic poetry across the subcontinent in so many of its languages.”  He praised Chatterjee’s performance, “which combines an intensely physical and energetic command of the stage with a clear monologue and rendition of some of Lalon’s most well known songs.”  The history prof, who speaks Bengali, added, “The live singing, it seemed to me, enabled Chatterjee to ‘become’ Lalon Phokir.”  Deshpande found the “multi-media format . . . rich and informative” as an effective way to place Lalon into the context of Indian and Bengali history, though he felt that Chatterjee’s lectures were presented “a little heavy handedly at times.”  The history teacher also appreciated the play’s “success in conveying complex philosophical concepts through an extremely sparse stage set up” of a few props and stage decorations.  “Mukherjee's direction makes excellent use of these props to convey these abstract ideas,” said Deshpande.  He concluded:

In all, this was an ambitious effort to showcase one of Bengal's most well known mystic poet saints; the broader questions it raises is testimony to its success in presenting on stage the rich philosophy and music of Lalon Phokir.

In the Times of India, Sreemita Bhattacharya wrote in January 2017 that Man of the Heart “narrates the story of 19th century Bengali Sufi saint and song-maker Lalon Shah Fakir . . . in a way that the moner manush [one of Lalon’s most famous songs of love and separation] tugs at your heartstrings.”  Bhattacharya also declared, “Simplicity is not easy to portray, especially on stage where every action is as deliberate as it is spontaneous,” adding, “Add multimedia elements to such a production and it becomes harder to retain and balance out the essence of the play.”  All together, the reviewer promised that “the play takes you on a haunting musical journey.”  “The elegance of simplicity in Lalon’s life of abstinence are highlighted in the costumes, stage design and props which accommodate only the necessary,” reported Bhattacharya.  Dismissing a few flaws, she concluded, “Above and beyond, the drama progresses on a soothing note as moner manush once again manages to find his place close to your mind and heart.”]

[Suman Mukherjee—or Suman Mukhopadhyay, as he also calls himself—is one of those acquaintances to whom I sent the theater reports before I started ROT.  He’d been a student of Leonardo Shapiro here in New York City, hence his interest in what was happening theatrically here, and I reached out to him when I was doing research on Leo and was looking for information on a production of Samuel Beckett’s Endgame he’d staged in Bengali In Kolkata in 1993.  I didn’t know Suman, but I found an e-mail address for the company that presented the production and he responded and sent me a packet of wonderful material.  We continued to correspond and then he e-mailed me that he was in New York with Man of the Heart.  That was the first time we’d met in person.]