Showing posts with label Oliver Butler. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Oliver Butler. Show all posts

26 November 2018

'Thom Pain (based on nothing)' (Signature Theatre Company)


Until 10 days ago, I’d only seen two of Will Eno’s plays, The Open House in 2014 and Wakey, Wakey in 2017.  (Reports on those performances are posted on Rick On Theater on 16 March 2014 and 24 March 2017, respectively.)  They were both quirky, interesting, surprising, and fun, and I put Eno on my list of writers on whom to keep tabs.  So when I saw that a revival of the 53-year-old playwright’s break-out play, Thom Pain (based on nothing), was to be part of the Signature Theatre Company’s 2018-2019 season, I included it among my subscription selections.  Diana, my usual theater companion (and my STC subscription partner) met at the Pershing Square Signature Center in Theatre Row on Friday night, 16 November, for the 7:30 performance in the Irene Diamond Stage of the intermissionless, 70-minute, one-man show.

The presentation is part of this season’s Legacy Program at Signature, which the theater bills as “a homecoming for past Playwrights-in-Residence,” showcasing premières of new works or revivals of older plays by writers who have had Residency 1 or Residency 5 seasons previously.  (Eno, the first “graduate” of Signature’s Residency 5 program, was a resident writer from 2012 to 2017.  The two plays I saw were presented during that tenure.)  The current revival of Thom Pain, directed by Oliver Butler (who also staged Open House) and starring Michael C. Hall (Hedwig and the Angry Inch, The Realistic Joneses; he’s probably best recognized for his eight seasons as the title character, the serial killer in Showtime’s Dexter) began previews on 23 October 2018 and opened on 11 November; it’s currently scheduled to close on 9 December (after two extensions from 25 November and 2 December).

The world première of Thom Pain (based on nothing), after a Launch Pad reading at the Soho Theatre in London, was at the Pleasance Courtyard at the Edinburgh Festival from 24 to 30 August 2004; the Soho Theatre Company production, directed by Hal Brooks with James Urbaniak as Thom Pain, won the First Fringe Award at the festival.  The production returned to London and the Soho Theatre for a regular run from 3 to 24 September 2004.  Thom Pain’s New York and U.S. première was at the Off-Broadway DR2 Theatre in Union Square from 1 February to 4 September 2005; Urbaniak was nominated for the Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Solo Performance for the production and Charles Isherwood proclaimed Eno in the New York Times as “a Samuel Beckett for the Jon Stewart generation.”  Thom Pain (based on nothing) was a finalist for the 2005 Pulitzer Prize for Drama.  

Since then, there have been many revivals around the U.S. (Seattle Repertory Theatre; Dallas Theater Center; Theatre Wit of Chicago; Austin, Texas’s Hyde Park Theatre; Actor’s Express in Atlanta, and others) and the world (Finland, France, Israel, Holland, Norway, Portugal, China, Mexico, Germany, and more); the script has been translated into over a dozen languages.  The  current STC revival is the first in New York City since the 2005 début.  A filmed adaptation of Geffen Playhouse’s production of Thom Pain (based on nothing) starring Rainn Wilson (and also directed by Oliver Butler) was aired on the streaming service BroadwayHD in January 2018.  (The text of the monodrama is published by Oberon Books [as Thom Pain (based on nothing): Published with Other Monologues for Theatre, 2004], the Dramatists Play Service [2005], and the Theatre Communications Group [as Thom Pain (based on nothing): With Other Monologues for Theatre, 2018].)

I included a brief biography of Will Eno, along with a discussion of his dramaturgy, in my report on The Open House, noted earlier, but to bring it up to 2018, his play The Realistic Joneses was presented on Broadway in 2014, receiving a Drama Desk Special Award; it was named Best Play on Broadway by USA Today and best American play of 2014 by the New York edition of The Guardian.  The Open House won the Obie Award for Playwriting for its 2014 production at the Signature Theatre Company and the 2014 Lucille Lortel Award for Outstanding Play; the cast and Eno all won Drama Desk Award Special Awards for the production as well.  The citation, which was for both the Off-Broadway Open House and Broadway’s Realistic Joneses, read: "For two extraordinary casts and one impressively inventive playwright.”  Last June, New York Times theater writers Ben Brantley and Jesse Green included The Realistic Joneses in their list of “the best 25 of the last 25 years.”  Of Eno’s writing, Brantley and Green wrote:

A philosopher and a wisecracker, Mr. Eno is a playwright who favors ideas over plot.  He also makes space for the language that gets those ideas across, the crackle of a quip, the snap of an upturned cliché. 

At home, Eno and his wife, actress Maria Dizzia, now have a four-year-old daughter, Albertine.

There’s no plot per se to Thom Pain (based on nothing)—which began as a character study of American revolutionary Thomas Paine (1737-1809), then Eno’s concept shifted when he realized his own “present and past pains” were the better vehicle for his message.  Even an event-by-event description of the 70-minute play would be longer than the performance.

It’s a monologue that might be called stand-up Existentialism (a label coined by Charles Isherwood in the New York Times).  Variously described as a “Beckettian monologue of a tortured soul,” “a combination of a Samuel Beckett-like meditation on the absurdist vicissitudes of life and a caustic monologue by one of those lesser late-night talk-show hosts,” “a mixture of a Shakespeare comedy and a (Samuel) Beckett piece,” “a stand-up routine that self-destructs as it goes along,” “a hybrid of stand-up com[edy], motivational speak[ing] and storytell[ing],” and “a Rorschach test . . . that never clarifies the point,” the play wanders with apparent aimlessness (but carefully planned by Eno) from subject to subject like a mental pinball.  An Absurdist mental pinball.  Describing the work, the playwright says: “Thom Pain is trying to tell his life story and gets interrupted by the fact that he’s alive.”

Eno has added a note on the Wikipedia page for Thom Pain that explains that it

is painstakingly constructed to create the effect of humanness in action . . . .  Because of his own defects, strengths, anxieties, and personality, he finds himself asking major questions about human life and how we define it, narrate it, value it, and ultimately live it.

In a program note for the Queensland Theatre Company (South Brisbane, Australia) production of the play, the playwright dismissed the notion of that Thom Pain is a playwriting experiment.  He said: “I guess I just think of it as a play.  Or, to be honest, more of a ‘thing’, I guess . . . I don't know.’"

The bare Diamond Stage is full of junk—not trash or garbage, but odd pieces of furniture, drop cloths, ladders, plastic sheeting on the wall, protective netting on the ceiling, and other odds-and-ends, as if it were a storage space for the detritus, discards, and left-overs of life.  It might be a basement somewhere (there are no windows) or an abandoned building.  It might be the theater itself, under reconstruction but the work has been halted.  Up right is a door to another room inside which is more stuff.  (The costumes and sets were designed by Anita Yavich and Amy Rubin; Jen Schriever's lighting leaves pockets of dark into and out of which Pain moves.)  The lights go to black. 

Pain (Hall), the play’s sole character, enters in the darkness—we can hear his shuffling footsteps—and after some preliminary feints, he asks, “Do you need to see me to hear me?” adding “If so, sorry.  Not yet.”  Then the lights go on and Hall’s standing down rightish, dressed in dark suit, white shirt, and dark tie.  He wears glasses which he’s cleaning with a handkerchief. 

Eventually Pain begins to tell the audience a story about a little boy writing in a puddle with a violin bow.  The story will reappear, but at the end of the introduction, Pain tells the spectators to go fuck themselves.  Hall’s remoteness makes it clear that the audience’s wishes are not Pain’s concern.

The tale of the little disabled boy whose dog is electrocuted in a puddle is just one of many bleak images Pain, a man who himself has suffered pain, imparts to his viewers as he muses about the awfulness of existence: “You just try to keep on living but it all seems so useless,” and “Maybe I was just born with a headache.”

Then he breaks into questions about life (“I disappeared in her and she, wondering where I went, left.”) interspersed with a bunch of non sequiturs: “It’s sad, isn’t it? This dead horse of a life that we beat all the wilder, all the harder, the deader it gets? . . .  On the other hand, there are some really nice shops in the area.”  Is the deconstructed setting a visualization of Pain’s disjointed mind?

At the end of the performance, Pain says, “I’m done with this.  Important things will happen, now.  I promise. . . .  I know this wasn’t much, but let it be enough.  Do.”  Then he adds, “Boo.  Isn’t it great to be alive?”  

That’s about the best I can do, people.  As you can gather, Thom Pain was a decidedly peculiar experience.  I have no idea what to make of it!  It sounded to me like a parody of Spalding Gray on acid channeling Ionesco or Beckett.  If you can conceive of that.  I’d need to read (and, probably reread) the script to unpack this play—and that’s not really any fun, and it’s decidedly anti-theatrical.

I can’t think of a way to report on this play.  I can’t even describe it much beyond what I just said—much less evaluate it or interpret it.  So, I’ve decided to approach this report from a completely different angle.  (Check what I did for Perfect Crime, an awful mystery play Diana and I saw seven years ago.  I couldn’t write about that play, either, so I decided to write about how the producers kept it on stage for what then had been almost 25 years despite how bad it is.  That report was posted on Rick On Theater on 5 February 2011.)

Taking Ben Brantley’s New York Times “review” as a starting point, I’ll examine reviewing a play like Thom Pain.  What Brantley did, which really ticked me off, was write about how this production differed from the Soho Theatre production he saw in London in 2004.  (Don’t confuse London’s Soho Theatre with New York City’s Soho Repertory Theatre.)  Maybe he just couldn’t come up with anything cogent to say about the STC mounting, or he didn’t want to write this review.  (I know—this is similar to my own situation.  But, first, I’m not being paid to render a judgment of the shows I see—that’s not my job, but it is Brantley’s and all who call themselves “drama critic.”  Second, I’m not posting “reviews” on Rick On Theater; I’m posting “reports,” and I reserve the right, as this is my blog, to cover the shows I see from any perspective that strikes me as interesting.)

Brantley wasn’t the only review-writer to use the earlier production of Thom Pain (based on nothing) as a yardstick by which to measure Butler’s version for the Signature Theatre Company.  (Other than Brantley, though, all of the others based their comparisons on the play’s 2005 New York début.)  The Times reviewer, however, was the only one I read who based essentially his whole critique on the comparison.

On 1 December 2010, I posted ”Dante update neither divine nor comedy,” a film review by Kyle Smith of the New York Post.  Smith had found a clever way to write about a movie he obviously didn’t want to bother reviewing, Jackass 3D.  What Brantley did wasn’t close! 

In my introduction to my repost of Smith’s review, I wrote:

I got the sense that Smith didn’t really want to review Jackass.  It’s his job and he was handed the assignment, so he couldn’t just blow it off, and writing a “serious” review would have been dull—both to do and to read, I imagine. . . .  But Smith found a way to do something interesting while still fulfilling his responsibility: telling us what he thought about the movie.

What Smith had done was find references and parallels in Jackass 3D’s “trademarked gross-out shenanigans” to Dante’s Divine Comedy, surely one of the most classic poems of all classic literature.  (He even found parallels between Johnny Knoxville, the movie’s producer, and the medieval Italian poet himself, Dante Alighieri.)  The mismatch was surely meant to be tongue-in-cheek, but Smith never addressed that juxtaposition.  He treated the comparison as legit, even upbraiding Hollywood for sneaking in so much surreptitious education into a boorish popular entertainment.  (I  congratulated Smith for his “delicious—and effective—use of irony.”)

In my afterword, I pointed out, “What gets me most here is how Smith, even while taking a humorous approach that clearly is meant to make fun of the movie itself, still manages to tell us what he thinks of it (even though, until the last sentence, he doesn’t directly state his opinion).”  I concluded: “I think this may be one of the best reviews of a bad movie (in the opinion of the reviewer, of course) I’ve ever seen.”  I added at the end of the intro, “There’s a lesson here for all writers . . . who are required to write about something in which they find little of interest or value.”  (ROTters who are interested—and I strongly recommend this—should read Smith’s review: https://nypost.com/2010/10/15/jackass-3ds-dante-update-neither-divine-nor-comedy/.)  Brantley didn’t learn it.

I feel Brantley’s review of Thom Pain, which I’ll try to summarize later, was a cop-out.  He dodged his responsibility and revisited an experience he already digested 14 years ago.  He opened his review by stating: “Audiences already familiar with Will Eno’s ‘Thom Pain (based on nothing) . . . may find this Stygian space roomier and less oppressive than they remembered.”  Well, that’s not me.  The Timesman went on to describe the STC revival in terms of Soho’s première and Hall’s performance with respect to James Urbaniak’s.  Cop-out.  Unhelpful cop-out. 

What pissed me off was that, not having seen that London production, I have no way to understand what Brantley thought of the Signature version or how he felt about it.  For me, it was a meaningless review because he assumed knowledge or experience I didn’t have; I had no frame of reference.  It’s a version of the blind man and the elephant—me being the blind man and the elephant being the play.

As far as I can find, Brantley didn’t publish a notice on either the 2004 Soho Theatre mounting or its subsequent 2005 transfer to Off-Broadway in New York City so I also wasn’t sure what Brantley’s opinion of his original experience was, either.  That left me with a vague impression of one experience compared with a vague impression of another.  A double whammy.

There’s also the fact that Brantley based his opinion of the STC production on a previous experience, but since I’d be seeing the play (like many in the audience, I imagine, more than a few of whom would have been pretty young 14 years ago) for the first time, that kind of assessment is useless.  As far as I’m concerned, Signature’s is the definitive interpretation of the play—their staging is how the play’s supposed to be done.  (I don’t know how involved Eno was in the STC revival, but since they promote the notion of playwright engagement in rehearsals, and Eno is a former resident writer at the theater, I’d guess he was involved.)  I want to know how Butler and Hall stack up, not against another director-actor team but against their own goals and aims for this presentation.  “Comparisons are odorous” as Shakespeare’s Dogberry proclaimed.

This kind of reviewing really isn’t fair to me and theatergoers like me.  It tells me little about the play I’m going to see and fills my head with extraneous information I don’t need, don’t want, and can’t use.  At the same time, even though this isn’t a reviewer’s responsibility, it’s not fair to the actors, director, and designers who worked on the current production.  Director Butler and actor Hall aren’t trying to make a comparable version of the Soho’s Thom Pain; they’re trying to make the best performance of the play they can based solely on Eno’s script and their artistic imaginations and creativity.  If Brantley didn’t think their interpretation works, that’s fair.  He should say so—and, if he can, say why he didn’t think so.  But simply saying, as Brantley essentially does, that the STC revival is different from the Soho première doesn’t do me any good and does Hall, Butler, his team, and the Signature Theatre a great disservice.

Okay, let’s look at the overall critical record.  Based on 21 published notices (as of 24 November), Show-Score gave Thom Pain (based on nothing) an average score of 76, which is middling in my experience with the review compiler.  Of the tallied reviews, 76% were positive and 24% were mixed; there were no negative notices in the Show-Score survey.  The highest score was one 95 for More Than The Play Blog, backed by two 90’s (WNYC radio and Front Row Center); the lowest a 55 for DC Theatre Scene, preceded by three 60’s (New York Times, TheaterScene.net, and New York magazine/Vulture).  My review round-up will comprise 17 notices.

In that New York Times review (which received a Show-Score rating of 60, the site’s second lowest), Brantley described the play as a “full-frontal attack on the audience that Mr. Eno had engineered” and “a sustained, cryptic, circular apologia pro vita sua” that is “70 uninterrupted minutes” of Pain “wallowing in bitter self-consciousness.”  In comparison to the 2004 London version, Branltey found that Oliver Butler’s revival “lets some fresh air and even a sliver of sunlight into the nocturnal depths of its title (and only) character’s imagination” and Hall’s Pain “appears as less of a lost cause than he once did” in James Urbaniak’s hands.  “I can’t honestly say that this transformation is for the good,” the Times reviewer proclaimed.  (I’m not going to recap all of Brantley’s characterizations of the Soho Theatre staging.  Interested ROTters can read the review for themselves at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/11/11/theater/thom-pain-review-michael-c-hall.html.) 

In 2004, Brantley acknowledged, “I may have wanted to take a shower immediately, but I was also electrified”; however, he found the play “seems to have shed its ability to shock.”  The Timesman posited that “that’s partly because we have had a chance to become accustomed to the skewed perspective of Mr. Eno,” but added that “this relative tameness is also a matter of Mr. Butler and Mr. Hall’s interpretation.”  In Hall’s performance, Pain’s “narrative of self-catechism and self-laceration has the carefully modulated quality of a classically trained actor doing an intense audition piece.”  Brantley felt that “this Thom is seldom lovably loathsome enough to make us squirm” and therefore, “the script now registers as the product of a restless and very talented young dramatist, showing off and playing with the influences he has absorbed.” 

“It’s Mr. Eno’s love for and grasp of rhythmic language that most impress here,” affirmed the Times writer.  “The ghost of Beckett still hovers, but so do, just as visibly, the specters of T. S. Eliot, Edward Albee and Dostoyevsky’s Underground Man.”  In conclusion, Brantley wrote: “Thom’s angst may feel a trifle sophomoric now, like something he might grow out of.  But his way with words, and that of the man who created him, is already deliciously ripe.”

“‘So what was that all about?’” Max McGuinnes[s] quoted his companion at the performance in the U.S. edition of the Financial Times.  “In lieu of an answer to that question,” the FT review-writer continued, he described what he saw on stage.  (Sounds a little like my dilemma, doesn’t it?)  Of Pain’s monologue (a taste of which I’ve tried to supply), McGuinness observed, “It would be wrong to call these musings stream-of-consciousness since they do not flow so much as limp along in fits and starts.”  The reviewer found, “At just over an hour, Thom Pain goes on a bit too long”; however, “the play remains mostly entertaining thanks to Eno’s deadpan humour and some playful audience interaction, which leavens its knowing solipsism.”  Noting that monologues challenge a director to decide what, aside from talking, the actor should do on stage, McGuinness deemed “Butler’s stripped-down staging acquits itself admirably on that front.”  Hall, he felt, “seems at once pitiable yet faintly intimidating.  And by the end, we still only have a hazy idea of who he really is.”  The FT writer’s overall assessment of the STC Thom Pain was: “What we see here is a man struggling, without much success, to hold it all together and make sense of everything that has happened to him.  Which is what life and theatre are all about.”

Sara Holdren of New York magazine and Vulture, whose notice also scored a 60, declared that “I found myself recoiling from [the play’s] aggressive flippancy.  There’s something brittle and deceptive about Thom Pain’s systemic self-deprecation.”  Thom Pain “gropes tentatively, and I believe sincerely, after compassion and beauty, but it cuts itself off at the knees over and over again with its paralyzing fear of commitment—to earnestness, to theatricality, to anything bigger than the self in pain.”  Holdren insisted, “Thom Pain is not Beckett.  Its heart is still about three sizes too small and its ego is bigger than it thinks.”  She reported, “The pleasure of the production is watching Hall in moments of simple, full presence.”  But she continued, “The problem is that what Thom Pain wants to be and what the play is are two different things.”  Holdren explained that she only knows what Eno wants the play to be because she’s read interviews, notes, and analyses of it.  “Meanwhile, the actual experience of sitting through Thom Pain feels like watching someone blow up one tiny, feeble balloon after another and then contemptuously pop them all, one by one.” 

She gave plenty of examples and illustrations from the text of the way “Thom is constantly appealing to our sympathy while simultaneously resorting to snide escape hatches.”  In the end, however, Holdren felt, “I don’t want to be cruel, to dismiss the scale or weight of the character’s suffering, but that’s the kind of gaze that sees the entire world in its own navel.”  The play’s “endless cycle of reaching and running starts to feel self-defeating in ways that go past intention,” she found, and “it’s also addicted to a coldness, a nonchalance that too often exhibits the very same fear it would like to examine.”  She ends by lamenting, “I feel for Eno’s poor Thom . . ., but there are limits to sympathy when its object, for all his trying, still possesses very limited courage.”
. 
In National Review, Kyle Smith (apparently the same writer who composed the Jackass notice discussed earlier) started his review by describing encountering a man in a bar who closely resembles the Thom Pain of Eno’s play.  The NR writer then noted:

The play is a digressive series of melancholy memories interrupted by absurdist asides and pointed witticisms.  There is no story or lesson here, just a drolly self-aware character protecting himself behind the barbed wire of irony.  In other words, the play is almost perfectly on the wavelength of, say, a self-loathing alcoholic theater critic.  No, I’m not thinking of anyone in particular, why do you ask?

“Michael C. Hall . . . nails the role, delivering a series of shaggy-dog stories and updates from his consciousness with a kind of poisoned panache that leaves the audience off balance,” Smith reported. “Thom is playing games with us, like a jaded, WASP Andy Kaufman.”  The NR reviewer confessed, “Eno’s words made me laugh intermittently,” but added that “the intentional shapelessness of the play vexed me.”  His last word was: “Two hours of Thom’s pain would, I think, be insufferable.  Luckily the show ends after an hour.  Like many others in the audience, I applauded politely and walked away briskly.”

Helen Shaw, describing Thom Pain as an “elliptical, existential monologue” in Time Out New York, asserted that “Eno’s text is a wonderfully light thing—a butterfly’s erratic passage through a man’s mind as he tries to narrate both his past . . . and the constant, irritating demands of the theatrical present.”  She explained, “Eno so exactly reflects a scattered self to us that he amplifies the scattering. When you try to recall Thom Pain, your thinking can't penetrate it; it's like trying to shine headlights into a blizzard.”  Director Butler “has given it a very handsome and polished revival,” but Shaw found that the play “has to fight a little too hard to be heard in the” large Diamond house.  Hall, she felt, “performs Eno’s script with immense charm (if not danger), but it’s a piece that requires the intimacy of a mind moving very close to yours.”  The TONY review-writer observed, “You can almost see the lightning leaping between Hall and the first four rows, but he has to cover such a huge space and so many people that the effect is necessarily intermittent.” 

In the Hollywood Reporter, Frank Scheck’s “Bottom Line” was “Hall delivers a riveting turn that makes this challenging play fully accessible.”  He quipped, “If Samuel Beckett and James Joyce had a literary love child, it would be Will Eno’s Thom Pain (Based on Nothing),” which Scheck described as “an existential stand-up routine, delivered by a man riffing on life’s disappointments and absurdities in alternately comic and bitter tones,” but it “never really coheres into a discernible storyline, which will certainly prove frustrating for those looking for a linear narrative.”  Nonetheless, the HR reviewer asserted that “the play’s deliciously clever wordplay and theatrical inventiveness provide myriad rewards for the more open-minded.”  The STC revival “particularly highlights the work’s strengths, thanks to [Hall’s] formidable charisma and charm.”  Scheck reported, “It’s all very dense and requires intense concentration, and you may find your mind wandering at times.  But it doesn’t take long for it to spring back to attention, thanks to the brilliantly inventive language and such memorable phraseology.”  Hall, the review-writer found, “is mesmerizing throughout” and “makes the piece accessible and engaging.”  Scheck concluded that “Thom Pain may not be for all tastes, but adventurous theatergoers are unlikely ever to experience it in a more riveting presentation.”

Marilyn Stasio, calling Thom Pain  “unsettling” in Variety, said that “the play was deliberately designed to make us uncomfortable about all the supposedly immutable verities, from the objective reality of our common language to truth itself.”  Stasio affirmed that “Eno’s intellectually dizzying drama is still a dangerous thrill.”  The Variety reviewer explained:

Although Eno was a protégé of Edward Albee, his absurdist sensibility reaches further back to Albee’s less playful philosophical mentor, Samuel Beckett.  This non-linear narrative—an explosive outburst of dazzling wordplay concocted of unfinished anecdotes, unstructured asides, and stream-of-consciousness ramblings—is decidedly, triumphantly Beckettian.

Hall, she reported, is “persuasive” and his “deadly deadpan is deeply funny, in an unnerving way.”  Stasio found that he “tries his level best to be true to this self-absorbed character; but he just can’t help himself.  He’s a fine actor, but a personable one, much too likable to pull off the character’s blinding, self-regarding narcissism.”  She concluded, “If you look it in the eye, Eno’s soul-searching monologue is nothing less than a searing meditation on the meaning of life.   But if you look at it sideways, it’s more of a sick joke.”

On WNYC radio, an NPR outlet in New York City, Jennifer Vanasco warned that “nothing much happens in this 70 minutes of seemingly aimless ruminating.”  Then she added, “And yet there’s so much beauty and humanity in it.”  Pain’s narrative “should be sentimental or sad or feel manipulative, but it’s not and it doesn’t,” reported Vanasco in her review that scored a 90 on Show-Score.  “Partly this is because of Eno’s beautiful and eccentric verbal imagery,” she explained, “and the way he undercuts each perfect word picture with eerie tragedy.”  Hall, the reviewer felt, “brings out the dark poetry of this play.  He is ingratiating without ever being fully knowable, esoteric while still grounded in his body.  He’s funny, charming and completely believable.”  She summed up by observing, “This is an astoundingly intimate show.  It’s a direct look into someone’s unfiltered brain—sometimes wandering, ugly and shallow, while at other times focused, lovely and profound.”

Show-Score’s highest-rated review, a 95, was Domenick Danza’s notice on More Than The Play, in which the reviewer declared:

The subtleties are astounding in Will Eno’s Thom Pain (Based on Nothing).  This play tells a captivating tale of loss of innocence, finding love, losing love, and maintaining hope.  Mr. Eno plays with words in this seventy-minute, one-character play that vividly depict the dichotomy of life’s journey.  His use of language brilliantly paints the landscape of emotion that floods the turning point events that define a life.  

Butler’s direction “seamlessly connects moment to moment, pulling truth to the surface of this distinctive theatrical work that is rich in subtext.”  Danza felt that Hall “maintains composure and distance, while engaging the packed house on an emotional level” and “evokes a sense of empathy from the audience.”  In the end, Danza found, “This play is a unique and intimate experience that will speak exclusively to each person who sees and hears it.  Don’t miss it!” 

Once again, New York Stage Review posted two notices.  Elysa Gardner asserted, “Thom Pain is . . . something of a magic act . . .—a bleakly comic, brutally detailed study of human frailty and suffering that somehow . . . becomes life-affirming.”  Calling it a “significantly meandering 75-minute monologue of a play” and a “ruminative monodrama,” Michael Sommers labeled Thom Pain “a journey through the existential tangles of one middle-aged man’s mind.”  Sommers was the second reviewer to report that the Diamond stage “is not so conducive to an intimate solo show,” but he added that “Butler’s supportive production and Hall’s intriguing presence usually are able to bridge the distance.”

On Talkin’ Broadway, James Wilson thought that Thom Pain, which he dubbed a “discursive, confounding, and invigorating monologue,” “demonstrates the futility of words and the limitations of language to connect thought with feeling, experience with reflection, and the individual with the world.”  Wilson asserted, despite the difficult personality of his narrator, that “Eno has created a highly entertaining, poignant, and intellectually stimulating evening.”  He affirmed, “Under Oliver Butler's direction, this is also a master class in comedy” and “Hall is outstanding.”  (Unlike the other reviewers who felt that the Diamond’s large stage was a drawback, Wilson found that the “larger space intensifies the feelings of isolation.”)  In the end, the TB reviewer advised, “The most effective way to experience the play is to give oneself over to it and luxuriate in the moments of linguistic playfulness and emotional catharsis.”

“In its own deliberately aimless way, Thom Pain (Based on Nothing) is a profoundly existential work,” observed Kenji Fujishima on TheaterMania, “with Pain’s struggle to give his own life meaning peeking through the numerous bits of trickery and wordplay he employs to avoid confronting the big questions.”  The TM review-writer explained, “Because so much of the interior drama in Eno’s play lies in what Thom Pain doesn’t say, it’s up to the performer to locate and transmit the psychological desperation between the lines” and continued that “this is where director Oliver Butler’s new production falls short.”  He felt that “a sense of pained inner life is lacking in Hall’s interpretation, with the actor seemingly prizing speed over depth in delivering his character’s ramblings, skating right over his character’s tragic pathos as a result.”  Fujishima asserted, “The experience of watching Thom Pain is akin to chasing after smoke.”  In conclusion, the TM reviewer reported that “this new production leaves us feeling more like we’ve gone on an entertaining roller-coaster ride through a man’s mind than truly gotten a glimpse into his agonized soul.  More than anything, this Thom Pain unsettles us less in its evocations of existential desire than in the sense that this material has much more to yield emotionally than it lets on.”

On CurtainUp, Charles Wright, whose review scored a 65, reported that “Thom’s recollections, though colorfully phrased, are often cryptic, with a seeming randomness that guarantees the audience occasional surprise if little in the way of suspense.”  (After quoting Isherwood’s 2005 New York Times praise of Thom Pain, Wright wondered “how Eno . . . might have fared—and what course his career might have taken—had Isherwood not been on the Times theater desk 13 years ago.”)  Having seen the 2005 production, Wright found, “The play struck me then, and strikes me now, as intriguing on the surface, with what’s beneath having only a glancing connection to lived experience.”  In comparison, he felt that “the 2018 Thom Pain is no more satisfying; but the magnified scale of this production suits the grandiosity of Eno’s exercise in synthetic Beckettry.”  The CU reviewer concocted a decidedly unusual finale for his assessment:

The fact that Thom Pain (based on nothing) is getting this superb revival suggests that there’s a sizable audience that will share Charles Isherwood’s enthusiasm for Eno’s Beckett-inflected navel-gazing.  Others, though, are bound to identify with the hapless audience member to whom Hall, as poor Mr. Pain, says, “If I were you, I’d be sick of this already.  I’d feel restless.  I’d feel like eating or urinating.”  Or, perhaps, be wishing for an intermission to permit a discreet exit. 

Joel Benjamin of TheaterScene.net was another reviewer who not only compared the Butler-Hall Thom Pain with the Brooks-Urbaniak production but found the new one a shadow of the original version.  Benjamin based his objections largely on the differences between Hall’s Pain and Urbaniak’s.  (He did complain about the “overzealous production” in the Diamond Stage.)  Hall, the TS reviewer thought, “is a fine actor who keeps the audience fascinated, but he turns the play into a standup routine.”  He asked, “[W]hy spend an hour-plus with a pleasant, slightly irritating person [Hall’s Pain] when you could just as easily be moved, shocked and titillated by a borderline lunatic [Urbaniak] (knowing full well that the relationship would last only a finite period).  Which is the better theatrical experience?”  Benjamin also found that Butler “gives Hall great leeway, making for a relaxed atmosphere, rather than a pacing-in-a-prison-of-his-own-making presentation.”

New York Theatre Guide’s David Walters told us, “At the beginning of the play, Thom says that he doesn’t like magic, but just as nothing is everything, ultimately this is a play all about magic.  The magic of human interaction.”  Walters reported, “The thoughts and observations falling out of [Pain’s] mind are not linear and dance from avoidance, to gallows humor, to deep profundity that will leave you searching those parallels in your own life.”  The NYTG writer characterized Eno’s writing as “a deep poetry . . ., a poetry of reflection, judgement and the bitter irony of what befalls us as we grumble, stumble and tumble through our lives.”

On DC Theatre Scene, which received Show-Score’s lowest rating at 55, Jonathan Mandell (whose review also appears on his blog, New York Theater) quipped, “Like a boxer faking out an opponent, Michael C. Hall as Thom Pain plays tricks on the audience.”  Mandell then observed, “But a prizefighter feints to win the match,” asking “What’s the point of the 70 minutes of  the mild audience abuse, self-conscious digressions and interruptions, deliberately unfunny jokes and funny non-sequiturs, bleak stories, and self-pitying effusions that make up Thom Pain (based on nothing) . . .?”  Answering his own question, the DCTS reviewer stated, “The easy out would be to answer that a good performance at least keeps our attention.”  He surmised, “Those theatergoers who have seen a previous production are likely to be disappointed by the Off-Broadway revival at the Signature.”  Mandell admitted, “I struggle to see anything profound in Thom Pain,” though “I can’t deny Eno’s sly wordplay.”  Still, the review-writer asserted, “For Thom’s jousts and jabs to feel like something more than random cleverness and intermittent entertainment, the actor must somehow show us an interior life that’s seething, longing, striving,  bursting with sadness and anger and resentments and pain that he’s trying to mask.”  As his final comment on the play and the character, Mandell wrote, “When [Pain] asks, ‘Does it scare you?  Being face to face with the modern mind?’ your answer might be: If only.”

I peeked at some past reviews of  the original production of Thom Pain in 2004/05 and some of the earlier revivals, and they all left me just as confused as the STC performance itself.  Still, it’s astounding how laudatory most of them were!  I wonder if there’s an “Emperor’s New Clothes” dynamic operating—no one wants to admit they don’t know what the hell Eno was on about.  

[When I was but a lad, back in the late ’50s and early ’60s, one of the comedians we used to listen to—they were on TV variety shows (anybody remember those?) and we bought the albums and listened to them over and over until we knew the routines by heart—did a bit on the plays of writers like Harold Pinter.  It might have been Shelley Berman, but if not, it was one of his contemporaries.  Anyway, after talking about these plays in which the characters struggle and fail to communicate, the comic raised his voice and proclaimed, “I think that people who can’t communicate should just shut up!”  Of course, if that had happened, about three-quarters of modern drama would cease to exist.  Nonetheless, I think of that line maybe once every three or four months.  This was one of those times.]

16 March 2014

'The Open House'


Family plays.  We’ve been staging the sagas of troubled families since at least Aeschylus’ Agamemnon in the middle of the 5th century BCE; probably the most dysfunctional family is the one in Sophocles’ Oedipus Rex, which came along a few decades later.  The family in Will Eno’s The Open House, currently at the Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre at the Pershing Square Signature Center on Theatre Row, may not involve sacrificing (well, literally, anyway) a daughter, killing a husband (though it might not be far from someone’s thoughts), killing a father or a mother, or committing incest—but the unnamed father, mother, son, daughter, and uncle sure aren’t the Cleavers or the Andersons or the Nelsons.  Hell, they aren’t even the Bunkers!  Even the Munsters and the Addamses were happier.  (Am I giving my age away?) 

My theater partner and I caught the 80-minute, intermissionless Open House, part of the Signature Theatre Company’s All-Premiere Season, on Friday evening, 7 March.  Under the direction of Oliver Butler, the co-founder and co-artistic director of Brooklyn’s Debate Society (whose work I don’t know), the STC production, Eno’s second in his five-year residency, started previews on 11 February and opened on 3 March; it’s scheduled to close on 30 March (after a one-week extension).  Eno, a playwright I’ve know only by name up till now (his first Residency Five production, Title and Deed, premiered at STC in May 2012; his first Broadway opening will be The Realistic Joneses on 6 April at the Lyceum Theatre after a 2012 Yale Rep première; his play Thom Pain (based on nothing) was a finalist for the 2005 Pulitzer Prize for Drama), has said that he wrote Open House simply because “there was this play I wanted to write and I had this idea that didn’t go away.”  In a New York Times profile of the dramatist, he also explained, “I had never written a play that was just about a family.”  He’s further admitted, “I’m not completely sure what it’s about,” which turns out not to be big shock.

Eno, 48, grew up in suburban Boston, the youngest of three children, and cycled competitively from about 13 to 23.  He went to the University of Massachusetts-Amherst for 3½ years, but left before graduating to move to New York.  Eno studied writing with writer and literary editor Gordon Lish, starting with prose work; he came to playwriting late, after he read a short play by Don DeLillo, The Rapture of the Athlete Assumed into Heaven, in 1990.  (Eno’s first piece of theater writing was A Canadian Lies Dying on American Ice, a very short piece published on line in 2002, though presumably composed sometime earlier.)  His work has been produced Off-Broadway in New York City starting in the mid-’90s, by U.S. regional companies, and on European stages.  Thom Pain, the Pulitzer finalist that was his first major New York production, has been staged in Brazil, Italy, Germany, France, Norway, Denmark, Israel, and Mexico, among other countries.  Eno, who now lives in Brooklyn with his wife, actress Maria Dizzia (In the Next Room (or The Vibrator Play), 2009-10, Tony nomination; Captain Phillips, film, 2013), with whom he’s expecting a baby, considers Samuel Beckett and DeLillo influences and Edward Albee, who championed the young writer when he was a fellow at the playwright's foundation, a mentor. 

His writing’s quirky, and despite Eno’s claims to influence (and others’ observation of likeness), Albee wrote of him that “he keeps the voice his own.”  I don’t have enough experience with his work to be certain, but from what I’ve been reading, including interviews and some of his scripts, I think that’s the way his mind works, in unpredictable zigs and zags.  Off-the-wall responses to direct questions aren’t uncommon.  Answering a question about whom he’d like to perform his plays, after listing a number of illustrious contemporary actors, Eno added in all apparent earnestness, “I’ve always wondered what John Wilkes Booth was like as an actor.  Great internal life, you’d have to imagine.”  Asked which superpower he’d like to have, his response was: “The former Soviet Union.”  (These followed a passage of an imaginary dialogue between his character Thom Pain and the Revolutionary pamphleteer Thomas Paine.)  “His plays are formally inventive and verbally dexterous,” affirmed Alexis Soloski in the Times.  Soloski, whose regular beat is the Village Voice, asserted that Eno “has built a career nudging ordinary speech toward the odd, the sad and the marvelous.”  “Some consider Will Eno the Beckett of American suburbia,” wrote Elisabeth Vincentelli in the New York Post.  “Others find him simply maddening,” and Linda Winer of Long Island’s Newsday asserted that the dramatist’s “dry, odd and cutting work has come close to causing fistfights Off-Broadway.”  The dramatist’s the recipient of several major fellowships, prizes, and awards; his Residency Five tenure at Signature began in 2012 and guarantees him three full world-première productions over five-years.  His plays are published by Oberon Books, Playscripts, Dramatists Play Service, and the Theatre Communications Group.

Open House is like an extended Saturday Night Live sketch, but with a gimmick in its structure.  At 80 minutes, it’s amusing and even enjoyable, but if it was any longer, even 90 minutes, it would’ve been way too long.  As it is, it has no depth at all; the whole point is the gimmick.  I don’t know if Eno’s a closet Structuralist, but this play has definite Structuralist aspects.  (Structuralism, according to Michael Kirby, is an “esthetic theory that emphasizes and gives primary importance to Structure,” which is “the way the parts of a work relate to each other, how they ‘fit together’ in the mind to form a particular configuration.”  Kirby insisted that structural theory “relegates any and all other aspects of a performance”—including narrative and character—”to lesser positions.”  I published “Theatrical Structure” on ROT on 15 and 18 February 2011.)  New York magazine’s Jesse Green confirmed that “The Open House shares with earlier Eno works . . . a gem cutter’s interest in formal precision and symmetry rather than content.”  

What the playwright’s set up is a replacement progression: soon after all the family members, none of whom have names in the program (only the actors are listed), are established, about halfway through the play, they start to leave one by one on various errands—the daughter goes out to get sandwiches from a deli, the son goes to bring his new girlfriend to meet his family, the uncle goes to the pharmacy to pick up his invalided brother’s meds.  Shortly after each family member exits, a new character enters, played by the same actor: the daughter (Hannah Bos) is replaced by Anna, a real estate agent who’s showing the house for the open house of the title; the son (Danny McCarthy) is replaced by Tom, the painter-landscaper Anna uses to advise sellers how to spiff up the house for easier sale; the uncle (Michael Countryman) is replaced by Brian, a prospective buyer; and so on.  It’s not quite as pat as that, though.  Anna doesn’t arrive until all but the mother and the father have left the house and she’s accompanied by Brian.  After Tom comes in, the phone rings and the mother learns that her daughter’s had an auto accident and she rushes out to the hospital and actress Carolyn McCormick returns soon as Melissa, Brian’s wife.  Finally, with no one but strangers around him, the acerbic father, who’s had several strokes and heart attacks recently, appears to suffer a recurrence and the visitors all arrange for him to be taken off in an ambulance, only to have actor Peter Freidman reenter as Anna’s brother, a real estate lawyer. 

The house is now occupied entirely by new people, unconnected, except by a possible business transaction which hasn’t actually taken place yet, to the family of the home.  And furthermore, there’s another surprise at the very end of Open House, but I’ll tell you about that momentarily.  (I suspect reviewers were asked not to say anything, and it’s kept under wraps at the theater, as I’ll explain in a bit.  I, however, am gonna let the . . . er, cat out of the bag for you all.  That’s a little joke, you’ll see.)

The plot of The Open House—which theater journalist Soloski described, along with The Realistic Joneses, as “sitcoms broadcast from a weirder, more melancholy world”—is minimal: the two adult children of the couple have gathered at the house, a prototypical suburban two-story bungalow (designed by Antje Ellermann with a spot-on eye), for their parents’ anniversary.  Their platitudinous mother has developed a passive-aggressiveness from years of verbal sniping from their misanthropic father, who never has a nice thing to say to anyone.  Lurking on the periphery of the nuclear (now there’s a pun!) family group is the father’s peculiar brother, who’s still mourning the loss of his wife and living with the family after a stint in rehab.  There’s no real storyline, above what I laid out earlier, except to add that the visit of Anna and the sale of the home is a surprise to the mother and hadn’t been mentioned before the real estate agent’s arrival.  The mother even gets a little miffed when she learns what her husband’s done without telling her, but she quickly curbs her temper.  There’s a lot of dark humor in the family’s essential cluelessness—“Did you come straight from the airport?” mother asks daughter.  “I drove here.  It’s a half-hour away,” the daughter replies nonplussed—and the father’s snarky-to-the-max jabs, which often come out of nowhere—“We should go out for a nice dinner,” the father suggests to his wife. “Just the two of us.  Or, just me.”  Non sequiturs are a hallmark of the writer’s dramaturgy.   Eno’s often described as a sort of Beckett-lite (mostly due to Charles Isherwood’s early characterization in his Times notice for Thom Pain: “Mr. Eno is a Samuel Beckett for the Jon Stewart generation”), but the Absurdist he most reminds me of (though Eno’s not truly an Absurdist himself) is Eugene Ionesco (with a hint of the Edward Albee of The American Dream and The Sandbox).  As I’ve acknowledged, I don’t know Eno’s previous work so I can’t vouch for this, but I’ve read that Open House is the first time he’s deliberately tried to be funny.

Now that little surprise I shouldn’t reveal (but will): In the early moments of the play, there’s business about the family dog’s having run off.  (After the son returns from looking for the dog, he reports that all he’s found is a chew toy and “some fur stuck in the fence.”  “Who are you, Sherlock Holmes?” barks the father.  “I’m just telling you what I saw,” the son responds, perplexed.  “No, seriously—I don’t know who you are.  Is your name Sherlock?”)  It only lasts a few minutes and there’s some coming and going until the subject just disappears as a source of dialogue.  At the end of the play, however, one of the newcomers glances out the window and says, “Hey, there’s a little dog out there.”  Now, it’s all set up as if the dog will either just stay outside or be let in somewhere off stage, say the unseen kitchen (such as occurred in the Richard Nelson play I saw recently, That Hopey Changey Thing), and we’ll never see her.  (There are recorded sound effects.)  But all of a sudden, at the very end of the play, the (real) dog comes bounding into the living room set and sits down while some of the characters fuss over her briefly as the lights come down. (The dog’s a little tan Akita, which may not be entirely irrelevant.  Akitas have the rep of being friendly with family members but distant with strangers.  Since this dog seems happy to accept the new people in the house, it may suggest, on top of the fact that she ran away when the family was at home but came back after they all left, that she approves of these visitors as her new companions.)

As for the issue of the secretiveness, there’s no mention in the program of a dog; even the trainer is credited only as “Special Services.”  But as we left the theater, there was a small sign everyone has to pass by that identifies the trainer (William Berloni, one of the major stage animal trainers, with a 2011 Tony Award for Excellence in the Theatre).  That sign wasn’t there when we entered the theater (or before the house opened, when I came down to the Linney entrance to see what was posted on the usual Signature information board they have outside each performance space).  Obviously, the theater didn’t want anyone to know in advance that there’s a real pup in the play!  I gather Eno’s into gimmicks—though I don’t really know if he’s done this kind of thing before.  He’s admitted, though, “I do love dogs and they stand for a lot to me.”  I wanted to cover this aside, really, because I also like dogs and I just wanted to include it in this report—personal indulgence, no more!  (As I noted in my last ROT theater report, I’ve seen a spate of shows this season with boy actors; now I get to add a canine performer.  Neat!)   And, by the way, Marti, making her theatrical début, is one of the cutest doggies on any stage anywhere.  (IMHO, of course.) 

What any of this means, I can’t really begin to tell you.  Eno, having allowed that he doesn’t know what the play’s about, also asserts, “I’ve always felt . . . that saying ‘what a play is about’ is more the province and right and privilege of the audience, rather than the writer.”  He’s also said, however, “I guess I am sort of dogged by questions about home and growing up and all that stuff.”  The playwright explained:

I’m still sort of dogged [a word, like dogs themselves, Eno favors] and intrigued by the way we grow up in a family and for a while, that is the world.  Then we get out into the world and we either recreate that thing we first knew, or, we mistake the world for that first thing.  Or we willfully deform it into that first thing.  Or are incredibly pleased and surprised or disappointed and saddened that the world is nothing like the thing we first knew.  Or some other strange and complicated—but in some sense entirely logical path is created.  I was interested in taking a sort of normative play arc and applying some new math to it.  Or to say that another way, how do you theatrically and creatively resolve something that doesn’t seem to ever get actually resolved in real life?

My problem with all this is, it isn’t on stage in The Open House.  Well, maybe subliminally or intermittently, but not front and center.  Two things do seem evident to some degree, though.  The open house of the title means more than just the real estate affair that takes up the second part of the play.  It’s an ironic reference to the home of the original family—which is light years from being “open” in any sense of the word.  Everyone who lives or lived there is a sort of prisoner, from the wheelchair-bound father to the defeated mother, to the children who can’t escape the tether.  Knowing full well that his father will snipe at his girlfriend and that his mother will offer nothing but bromides, he can’t wait to bring her over.  And since Eno believes that the brain “does sort of build its connections on its early connections,” there’s little hope for the children to escape the pull.  No one ever talks back to the father or tells the truth in response to off-center remarks by anyone else.  Even the sun is blocked out as the father insists on keeping the shades drawn—until Anna just takes over and pulls them all up and literally lets the light in.  She and her companions open the house.  The dog knew—she ran away and stayed until new folks were in the house. 

The other truth is that the atmosphere in the house is toxic.  Not just metaphorically, either: all the family members are suffering some ailment or injury.  In addition to the father’s strokes and heart disease, the mother has a constant pain in her wrist she’s resigned herself to live with (until Anna relieves it with something like acupressure), the uncle has his depression and bereavement, the daughter’s doctor has discovered a suspicious lump near her spine, and the son gets leg cramps.  No wonder the dog left!  Happiness isn’t an option for his family.  Then the replacements take over, and though they’re connected mostly by a business transaction, they are much more cheerful and contented than the departed family could ever seem.  A prison for the original occupants, Brian and his wife see it as a potential home with “possibilities.”  The painter, after peeling off some of the drab beige wallpaper, discovers to everyone’s delight that a bolder, brighter covering is hidden underneath.  Not everything among the new folks is terrif, though: the painter-landscaper drinks and uses drugs on the sly—a crack in the foundation, perhaps? 

The production was splendid, especially after the disappointment of my last visit to the Signature (Kung Fu, reported on ROT on 11 March).  I don’t know Butler’s work or his ensemble troupe, The Debate Society.  (TDS was founded in 2004 by Butler; writer-actress Hannah Bos, who’s a member of the Open House cast; and Paul Thureen, also a writer and performer.  The three co-founders also serve as co-artistic directors.  They develop works for the company by collaboration and, in their own words, specialize in “unexpected stories set in supremely intricate, vividly theatrical worlds.”)  He would seem, however, a good match for Eno, with whom Butler worked on early readings of the play at Signature over the past year as part of the playwright’s residency.  (Butler’s also worked with Mac Wellman, another playwright known for his idiosyncratic use of language.)  If this production of Open House is any evidence, the collaboration is a good one.  Even assuming that Bos, Butler’s colleague at TDS, knows his methods, the director managed to unify the other four cast members, along with Bos, into a terrific ensemble while maintaining their individuality as both members of the family in the house and the real estate party.  It’s not hard for talented actors to play multiple characters with differentiation, but it’s not as easy for them to blend together in all their guises so that we spectators believe that they all inhabit the same universe.  That takes the guidance of a careful director.  Not only has Butler accomplished this, of course, but he glommed onto Eno’s unique style, which is not Beckett, Ionesco, or Albee, and kept all five actors and all ten characters in tune with the world the writer imagined.  Clearly, working together through the development process made Butler and Eno a creative team.  It will be interesting to see if that continues.  (It looks as if Butler has done all of his work with TDS since it débuted and The Open House appears to be his first break-away gig since then.  The director’s also just been announced to stage Encores! Off-Center’s second season presentation of Jonathan Larson’s Tick, Tick, BOOM this June.  Now that he’s out of the cocoon, we’ll see if stays out.)

Ellermann’s set design, the living room and entrance foyer of a nondescript suburban home with the second story under the peaked roof visible above, is sit-com perfect, but a tad seedy and worn.  Not shabby, but lived in and definitely lower-middle-class.  (Down stage right is a large dog bed, taking up considerable space in the cramped room—and small stage set.  It turns out to be a McGuffin of sorts.)  Not only does the playing space serve Open House well, both from the perspective of the atmosphere and the action requirements (it’s a close space, this home, not a lot of room to maneuver even if it’s not spartan or harsh), but the small second floor, its peak pointing skyward but also confining because of the narrowing slope, unlit and undecorated, more like an unfinished attic than an upper dwelling floor, seems to be hiding some secret.  It suggests an ominousness that the brightly lit (though sun-deprived) lower level papers over (if you will).  (The living room closet also hides a kind of secret world.  Not ominous, but lost: it holds toys and games from bygone years.  They’re not discussed, but when the closet’s opened for a quick look inside, we get to see a bit of the family’s past revealed for a second.)  Ellermann’s bio says that The Open House is her fourth play with Eno.  I’d say they’re on the same page, no?  (If I have any judgment in these things—and maybe I do or maybe I don’t—I’d say that Eno-Butler-Ellermann is a theater team in the making.  Maybe y’all should draw up a contract.  I’m jus’ sayin’.)

Not that Bobby Frederick Tilley II and David Lander missed anything in their costume and lighting designs respectively.  Tilley had a double task, of course: not only to get the clothes character-correct, revealing personality and standing at a glance, which he did nicely and with a light touch, but he had to do it twice over, for two sets of characters played by one set of actors so that there wasn’t a moment’s confusion when, say Bos leaves as the daughter and comes back as Anna.  Tilley nailed it.  Them.  Whatever.  And Lander got the atmosphere in the house right, too.  It’s not gloomy or dark, which might be a temptation with the drawn curtains and the overcast of despondency that hangs over the family like Joe Btfsplk’s rain cloud, but when Anna comes in and raises the shades, the contrast is perfectly noticeable.  A tip of the hat must also go to M. L. Dogg’s soundscape for Open House.  For a short play, there are lots of sound effects, from the dog barking to car engines to the ambulance sirens approaching to pick up the father, and the layers of scene-setting sounds that Dogg constructed for the opening moments of the play—a church bell ringing, a bike bell, birds chirping, the dog, music playing, and a gallimaufry of suburban noises—is actually arresting.  Sounds come and go all through the 80-minute playlet. 

The acting is uniformly excellent—actually, excellent squared, since everyone has to create two distinct characters in a very short time.  (Granted, the characters are little more than a single dimension and card-stock thin, but that’s what The Open House demands.)  It’s impossible to single anyone out in the ensemble, but I’ll just note a few salient points.  As the mother, Carolyn McCormick, probably most recognizable as Dr. Elizabeth Olivet on the early years of Law & Order, does a fine job navigating the narrow path between subjugation and passive-aggressive resignation.  McCormick maintains a spark of strength and resistance to her husband’s viciousness, but it’s almost extinguished (and really only shows up when the two are alone).  Michael Countryman has long been one of my favorite character actors, always turning in superb performances whenever I’ve seen him, in classics like Schiller’s Mary Stuart on Broadway to contemporary parts in plays as diverse as Ionesco’s The Bald Soprano to Terrence McNally’s Stendhal Syndrome.  (I just don’t know why this actor isn’t nationally famous.  He works all the time.  Maybe he likes it that way.)  As the uncle and then as Brian, the prospective house buyer, Countryman creates two distinct and recognizable figures, and his uncle is so convincingly damaged and beaten—by his brother’s abuse, the traumatic loss of his wife, his depression, and his former substance abuse—that it’s almost hard to believe that he immediately transforms into well-adjusted, cheerful Brian.  Bos was the first actor to return as a second character and it took me a few beats to realize that Anna (about whose eventual appearance I was forewarned by the Times review, though not the circumstances) was the same actress as the daughter.  As the daughter, Bos seemed somewhat dumpy, very lost (her brother has a girlfriend, but she seems to have no one), and needy—a superannuated adolescent really.  Her real estate saleswoman is in charge, confident, upbeat, and even looks 10 years older and more mature.  When Anna moves to pull up the blinds over the father’s wishes, Bos just brushes him aside and takes control.  As for Peter Friedman, his lawyer-brother in the second part can’t really measure up to his acerbic father, but the lawyer is more connected and more coherent, a much more grounded person than Freidman’s father.  As written, the first character is a nasty joke machine: drop in a nickel and out comes a jab or a dig.  Freidman delivers the quips expertly—they all land with a zing—but they seem programmed, which is Eno’s responsibility (and perhaps his intention).  I’m not entirely sure how he does it, though, but Freidman did make clear somehow that this nasty streak is not a side effect of his strokes—he’s not a dirty old Sophia Petrillo in male drag—but that he’s been like that for many years.  (I hate to leave Danny McCarthy out, but as good as he was, I’m afraid I’ve shot my wad on the other four.  He did as well as they, but I have no particular remark to impart.  Same with the dog, whose appearance was just a really nice lagniappe.  Dogs make me smile!)

The press was pretty unanimous in its praise of The Open House (and Eno’s playwriting in general).  Though several noted that not everyone enjoys his deliberate obscurity or the brittleness of his language, most reviewers, pointing out that Eno’s structure is more interesting than his plots, nevertheless seemed to be rooting for him to make it big.  (Almost all the notices made the point that The Realistic Joneses is opening soon on Broadway.)  The Post’s Vincentelli, expanding on her opening remark by warning that “the playwright’s deadpan tone, lack of conventional plot and finicky attention to language have driven hordes of theatergoers crazy with boredom,” countered that “just as many find those traits fascinating.”  The Post reviewer complained that the first part of The Open House is “slow-drip torture,” but that “this surreal comedy takes a sudden left turn halfway through and considerably perks up.”  She summed up her appraisal by asking, “What does this all mean?”  Her answer?  “Who knows.”  Vincentelli ended with the truism, “Whether you like him or not, there’s nobody like Will Eno.”  Asserting that “it’s very impressive that playwright Will Eno extracts so much pungent humor and so many poignant observations in a fleet 80 minutes,” Joe Dziemianowicz lauded Eno in the Daily News for his “small but satisfying work” that “creates the delight” of the “impeccable performances” elicited by Butler.

Newsday’s Winer called Open House “a taut, malevolently witty family catastrophe of a tragicomedy” in which “[t]he ground shifts, as even the powerful are made small by life’s mysteries.”  In the Times, Charles Isherwood warned potential spectators that “you’ve probably never seen a fractious family stage the uncanny disappearing act that takes place in ‘The Open House,’” which he characterized as a “mordantly funny but disappointingly hollow comedy.”  Calling Eno “one of the most vital, distinctive voices in the American theater,” the man who solidified the playwright’s Beckett connection declared, “Once encountered, his style is not likely to be forgotten.”  Along with their “wry humor,” Eno’s “plays are also infused with a haunted awareness of, and a sorrowful compassion for, the fundamental solitude of existence,” said Isherwood.  The Timesman admitted to an appreciation for “the cool temperature” of Eno’s writing, but felt that “the flat, stylized comic dialogue that is his specialty sits somewhat uneasily inside the frame of a play set in an average-looking suburban living room.”  Affirming that “never before have I felt that Mr. Eno’s idiosyncratic comic style was sidling up to shtick,” Isherwood felt that “the play begins to feel like a randomly assorted series of comic ‘bits’ arranged in no particular order.”  Explaining that “the play’s starchy artificiality becomes a little oppressive,” the Times review-writer lamented that “there’s not much of a discernible human pulse in these characters”—until, that is, the second part, when “the play acquires an intriguing new layer that jump-starts its stalled engine.”  Then, Isherwood wrote, The Open House, “which seemed to be stuck in an arid groove, begins to acquire intriguing new meanings” and the play comes “to a haunting conclusion.” 

In the Village Voice, Alexis Soloski (back at her regular gig) observed that in The Open House, “there’s no place quite so dangerous as home.”  The play, Soloski wrote, “seems almost a parody of a certain kind of realist play,” but then, “Eno’s writing sets the piece apart, as his lines resemble sitcom dialogue script doctored by Schopenhauer.”  In the end, however, the Voice reviewer felt, “Neither Eno nor director Oliver Butler can make the play’s import outpace its inventive structure.”  The New York Observer’s Jesse Oxfeld explained that Eno “specializes in offbeat, largely affectless wordplay that underscores the fundamental loneliness of existence” and that Open House “may form the apotheosis of that combination.”  In Butler’s staging, Oxfeld wrote, the STC production “is impeccably acted and very funny; it also feels sad, empty and somewhat meaningless.”  Jesse Green felt in New York, “Funny as [the play] is . . . you quickly feel locked into the characters’ misery” until the second part of the play “when Eno shifts gears into surreal.”  Though Green judged that the production was “drolly directed by Oliver Butler,” he observed that Eno’s “is a highly purified dramaturgy” and the dramatist “does not signal [a theme], any more than he provides exposition or explanations.”  The man from New York concluded, “Language is all he gives us to hang on to, and . . . it’s slippery at best.”  In “Goings On About Town,” the New Yorker affirmed, “There’s a whisper of a plot in Will Eno’s new dark comedy”; however, “the main event is watching each oppressed family member leave the stage and then, a few minutes later, come back as a different, healthier character.”  The reviewer concluded, “The writing is sometimes funny, and the acting, under the direction of Oliver Butler, is strong, but, lacking any depth, this twisty sitcom comes across as merely clever."

Stephan Lee hinted, “The living room set of Will Eno's The Open House . . . could easily be the set of a warm family sitcom” in Entertainment Weekly, but warned, “The vitriolic banter, while fun to witness, takes its toll.”  Lee’s final assessment, however, was that “in The Open House, just as the misery and back-biting starts to feel excessive—even indulgent—Eno takes a left turn and finds a way to make harmony as radical and satisfying as discord.”  In Show Business, the weekly theater trade paper, Daniel Glenn called Open House an “odd and poignant comedy” that “really does nothing less than set the genre on its head.”  Glenn singled out as grounds, first, Eno’s “singular way with words” and second, Open House’s structure.  He also pointed out that the production “is a showcase for actors, and the cast takes advantage”  as “Eno effortlessly defines the familiar . . . and then nudges it into the world of the strange.”  In Time Out New York, David Cote called the play “an unconventional take on family drama,” and quipped, “If the American family drama were a trout (stay with me), playwright Will Eno would gut it, shellac it, mount it on a plaque and make it wiggle and croon ‘Take Me to the River.’”  The man from TONY explained: “What I mean is that his work combines studied banality, sneaky weirdness and formal ingenuity.”  “Director Oliver Butler finds the right balance of melancholy and silliness,” Cote assured his readers, and added that “the actors are so attuned, they’ll make you feel like you’re home for the holidays.” 

In the cyber press, Elyse Sommer on CurtainUp called Open House “Eno's at once funniest and saddest play to date” exemplifying “the Eno pattern of having his plots and people stray from the path of normalcy.”  Sommer observed that Open House “is definitely a fresh twist on the much done dysfunctional play genre,” a good reason, she insisted, for potential theatergoers to put the play “on their to-see list.”  “A Will Eno play always seems to leave the audience walking out asking the same question: Was that the greatest thing I've ever seen or the most awful?” asked TheaterMania review-writer David Gordon.  Of Open House, Gordon said that when the play ends, “all you know is that, in 80 minutes, he has picked apart an entire genre, thrown the pieces into the air, and refused to put them back together.  That in and of itself is mind-blowing to watch.”  The TM writer added, “Dramaturgically, not only is the text incredibly well-structured in its dismantling of the classic family-play genre, but it is also quite thought-provoking,” praising both the directing of Oliver Butler and the acting of the ensemble.  On Talkin’ Broadway, Matthew Murray declared that “Eno continues his exploration of this matter”—“Does anyone belong anywhere?”—“and of the limits of audience patience.”  Observing that the playwright’s subject “would suggest at least somewhat meaty potential,” Murray warned, however, that “Eno cares less about telling a theatrical story than in presenting a theatrical style that engages the audience in full defiance of common sense.”  The reviewer declared that Eno’s technique of “disconnect” “results in stage shows that sound like nothing and feel like even less” and that “The Open House feels particularly strained trying to live up to Eno’s wink-wink attitudinizing.”  The pay’s lines “drip with the voice of the playwright rather than individual souls in search of expression,” wrote the TB reviewer, concluding with an admonition: “Existentialist joke machines only go so far.” 

[I don’t often comment on a reviewer’s critical record, though I have occasionally taken exception to or endorsed a writer’s opinion of one play or another.  But I’ve been reading Matthew Murray’s reviews now for some time—Talkin’ Broadway’s been one of my regular stops when I prepare the review round-up for my performance reports for ROT—and a pattern appears to have been revealed over time.  I haven’t gone back and surveyed his collected evaluations and judgments, and I haven’t read any of his reviews of plays other than the one’s I’ve seen and reported on on this blog, so maybe I’m off track.  I don’t think so, though.  Murray seems to be something of a contrarian, forming assessments that diametrically conflict with the consensus of other published reviews, as well as my own opinion much of the time.  Now, of course, he’s entitled to have and to voice his own response to any public performance, and a variety of voices is valuable.  It’s basically why I started doing the survey at the end of my reports, to provide an overview of the other responses to a play in contrast to or agreement with my own analysis.  After all, my opinion isn’t really any more significant that his—or anyone else’s—except maybe to me.  But I find it curious that when the prevailing sense of a performance is positive, Murray seems to pan the show, and when the papers and websites generally dislike a production, he praises it.  I also note that he can get quite vehement, especially in his disapprobation, almost as if he were aggrieved by a bad theater experience.  (I’m reminded of something I read years ago concerning review-writing: a bad play or a bad production are not crimes against humanity.)  The posting dates for his TB reviews suggest that he isn’t waiting until the notices are published and then taking the opposing view, like a debater assigned a position or a sophist who only wants to get into an argument.  He also seems knowledgeable, though I don’t know anything about his background or experience.  I guess the conclusion is that he’s just wired differently from most of the rest of us, not that I always agree with the consensus. (I make it a practice not to read other reviews before I compose my report and state my own opinion, with the sole exception of the New York Times, since that comes to my door.)  I don’t know what anyone else does, but since Murray’s reviews are posted on or around the dates for the first published notices, that is, the day of or the day after the play’s opening, I assume he’s forming his opinion in the theater or right afterwards.  He just seems always to come down of the opposite side from nearly everyone else.

[One last note of significance:  This report on Will Eno’s The Open House marks the fifth birthday of Rick On Theater.  I launched this blog on 16 March 2009; 384 posts later, this is where we are.  I hope I've provided some little edification, some enjoyment, and some amusement along the way.  ~Rick]