Showing posts with label Pudlo Pudlat. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pudlo Pudlat. Show all posts

10 May 2014

The Last Frontier, Part 4: Vancouver, British Columbia


[This is the final installment of my Alaska travelogue, covering the added visit to Vancouver, British Columbia, following our disembarkation from the MS Statendam and the voyage down the Inside Passage.  My mother and I stayed in Vancouver for two days before flying back to New York City.  I suggest that readers turn back to read the first three parts of “The Last Frontier,” posted on 26 March and 10 and 25 April, before reading this last segment.]

After reboarding the ship in Ketchikan on Friday, 15 August 2003, we set sail at about 6 p.m. for Vancouver.  The rest of that day and all of the next, the Statendam cruised along the coasts of Alaska and British Columbia.  Aside from scenery-watching, the ship provided nothing of special interest for the day.  (There were the usual nonsense activities—”final” art sales, “final” pastime activities, and so on—but nothing I’d have been interested in.)  There was a briefing about preparing for debarkation and the process of passing through customs and immigration into Canada the next morning, and instructions about filling out the necessary forms and attaching the appropriate luggage tags.  Then, of course, we had to pack and tag our luggage so we could put it out in the gangway before we went to bed and fill out the customs and immigration forms; we had to settle the ship bill, too, of course.  Other than such mundanities, however, it was a day mostly of just relaxing and watching the coast go by. 

The ship docked in Vancouver early the next morning, Sunday, 17 August, and all the passengers had assigned debarkation “codes” that determined when we got off the ship.  (This is obviously to assure that people with connections can make them without having to struggle through crowds of other passengers who are just trying to get early starts on their own schedules.  It’s actually pretty efficient.)  We had requested the earliest possible departure so we could get to our Vancouver hotel without wasting the whole day.  The luggage had been transported off the ship first thing and was waiting in the appropriate spots in the terminal, depending on your departure plans, so all we had were our carry-ons.  We had a moderately late breakfast in the informal dining room and then just hung around there—we had to wait in a “public” area, not our cabins, and listen for our code to be called—until we were called and told which gangplank to use.  (To prevent people from standing around blocking the ladders and gangplanks in anticipation of getting off, the codes aren’t called in any logical order and the exits are alternated—you can’t guess when or where your group will have to go.  So it pays just to sit some place comfortable and wait.)  We debarked at just about 8:30 or so and made it through the departure process pretty directly.  We were in a cab and at our hotel by 10 a.m. or so.  In fact, we got to the hotel early enough that our rooms weren’t even ready yet.  We had been warned that it might take hours to get through the debarkation process and through customs and immigration, which is why Mom didn’t book a return flight for that afternoon.  Of course, if she had, we wouldn’t have had two nice days in Vancouver at the end of our trip.

We had decided, once again, to take a city tour right off so we could get the lay of the city.  City tours took off in the morning and then at 2 in the afternoon (which we had learned from both the guidebooks and various websites I consulted before we left), and we had obviously decided to try to get on an afternoon trip the day we arrived.  We booked a tour when we checked into the hotel, and then went window shopping along Robson Street, where our hotel is located and which is the main shopping street of Vancouver.  We walked up the street several blocks, just strolling along looking in the store windows—many were not open yet on a Sunday morning, though they would be later in the day—until we arrived at the major intersection.  We found ourselves in front of the Vancouver Museum of Art, so we decided to go in for a look while we were there and had the time anyway. 

This is the regular art museum of the city, the contemporary and western art collection—the native stuff, as I said, is at the Museum of Anthropology, some distance from downtown.  We’d go there later.  It seems, however, that Canada just isn’t very good on contemporary art.  We had made a point to go on our own to the Quebec Art Museum when we were there, and it’s a very unappealing collection—and so is Vancouver’s.  (I certainly have never heard of any Canadian artists—and I guess this is why.)  There was an exhibit of works by “First Nations” artists (in case you didn’t already know, that’s the Canadian version of “Native American”) which was interesting, but not great.  I’ve seen many examples of Indian artists’ work, both live and in books, and there are many that are wonderful; these were more interesting from a sociological perspective than from the perspective of works of art.  Another exhibit here is a collection of paintings of the first local artist to record the native culture in British Columbia, Emily Carr (1871-1945).  She was essentially a realist—maybe a romantic realist, if there is such a designation—who painted scenes of Indian villages, totems, masks, ceremonies, and so on.  But her work is dark (in hue, I mean, not necessary in emotion) and somber, and not particularly interesting as art.  (I wouldn’t want one hanging in my home, that’s for sure.)  I mean, if you consider what she did, again from a sociological point of view—painting Indian culture at a time before it was considered worthy of preservation, much less interest—it was remarkable that she did it; but if you look at her paintings as art, from just an aesthetic point of view, well . . . yuck! 

Anyway, by now it was time to go back down the street to change clothes a little and meet our tour.  We weren’t really hungry for lunch, but we knew we would be at an inopportune time later if we didn’t catch a bite, so we strolled back toward the hotel and stopped in at a pub-type place and had a sandwich (which actually turned out to be huge) and looked in a few more windows.  (I actually found a carving I liked and which seemed to be a good price—it was on sale—but I was uncomfortable buying it on my very first afternoon right up the street from the hotel, and also because the salesgirl kept warning me that it might not be around the next day.  That kind of put me off.  I turned out to be right—though Mother kept saying I should go back and get it.  The next afternoon, I found work by the same carver at lower prices than the sale price in that store, and eventually found a piece I liked better for a whole lot less than either price!)

The tour was pretty much what we expected, and we did get a sense of the city.  Except that Vancouver is built sort of upside-down—what feels like north is actually south—and we just never got our sense of direction right.  We’d look at a map, and be totally confused because what we felt was “up” on the ground was actually “down” on the map.  So much for getting a feel for the city!  (Of course, I’m not necessarily the best one to judge.  I’m the guy who comes out of a subway in New York City and heads off in the wrong direction because I have no sense of geography—and I’ve lived in New York for almost 30 years.)

Anyway, we did go over most of the city, including Chinatown—the third largest in North America (after New York City and San Francisco, I believe)—and Gastown, a kind of Greenwich Village or Gaslight District (in San Diego) that’s where Vancouver started a little over a century ago.  (British Columbia is relatively new, as far as settlement is concerned.  Vancouver was essentially invented by the Canadian Pacific Railroad barons as the terminus of their new railroad.  It had been nothing but a trading post and a lumber camp before that.  Nothing in Vancouver is much more than 100 years old; it was founded around 1875 (as Granville) and only named Vancouver in 1886.  Most of the modern city is very, very new.)  Both Chinatown and Gastown are near the downtown area where our hotel was located, though it’s too much for Mom to walk comfortably.  Vancouver is pretty hilly, like a little San Francisco, because the mountains start pretty much right up from the coast.  We took busses, including two out to the Museum of Anthropology the next day. 

Despite all the new buildings and even the Victorian-era oldies, Vancouver didn’t strike me as a particularly pretty city.  (Vancouverites have a predilection for round buildings for some reason.)  And there’s a lot of construction going on everywhere, which doesn’t help.  It’s obviously a booming city economically—well, for Canada, that is.  Compared to New York or Los Angeles, or even Chicago and San Francisco, it’d be called downright mellow.  Stores on the main shopping strip closed on Sunday morning?  Never happen here!  And when we arrived too early to get into our hotel, we took a short stroll around the downtown area.  There was almost no car traffic!  We’d wait at lights, and no cars would go by.  (By the way, it’s an odd thing, but if you jaywalk in Vancouver, and a car does come by . . . it’ll stop to let you cross!  Even though you’re jaywalking in the middle of the block, nowhere near a crosswalk, the driver’ll stop and let you pass.  Try that in New York City!  German drivers will stop for pedestrians—but you have to be in a crosswalk.)

The city tour got us back to the hotel after 6, and we had made reservations for dinner at a First Nations restaurant, so we took a little down time.  We took a taxi to the restaurant, which wasn’t far but we didn’t want to walk the hills or get disoriented as we had begun to do.  The restaurant, Liliget (which means something like “happy eating”), was very interesting.  It’s set up like a native feast house—you sit on the floor, but the tables are set into pits so it’s like sitting at a bench, not Japanese style—and the menu features foods common to the local Indians: elk, buffalo, duck, and lots of seafood (especially salmon, of course).  I’d have liked to try the meat dishes, but they were only on a feast platter, which was huge even for two people, so we had to opt for the seafood dishes.  I had what amounted essentially to an Indian bouillabaisse, but in a tomato-based “broth,” and it was quite good.  Mother had crab cakes—which look a lot like the ones you get here (or, more appropriately, in Maryland), though they’re made from Dungeness crabs instead of blues.  (For some reason, Dungeness crabmeat shreds; it doesn’t come out in nice lumps like blueshell.)  We also had bannock bread, which the natives learned to make from tribes to the east and south.  It was an interesting experience, and a very nice meal.  (I still wish I could have found out what elk tastes like.  Probably like venison, I’d imagine.  We did eventually get to taste reindeer sausage, by the way—after the disappointment at Denali.  It was served at one poolside lunch on the boat and then at the cannery in Ketchikan.  It’s very good—a little spicy, though I don’t know if that’s the meat or the way the sausage is made.  So, as awful as it may sound to some folks, I’ve happily eaten Bambi, Thumper, and now Rudolph!  Ya wanna make somethin’ of it . . .?)

The next morning, Monday, 18 August, we went into Gastown (named for “Gassy” Jack Deighton, a frontier character who built a saloon there to serve the lumbermen, thus starting what would become Vancouver; “Gassy” refers to his tendency to talk a lot and tell tales—no smart-ass remarks, please—it’s a Canuck sobriquet, not what Americans might otherwise think).  This is where most of the galleries that specialize in native art are located, so I wanted to check them out anyway.  It’s not a large district, and the principal street, Water Street, is only a couple of blocks long, so we took a bus over and walked from one end to the other on one side of the street and then crossed over and walked back.  We checked out the named galleries and all the little tchotchke shops in between.  Except one or two of the galleries which featured “real” art (as opposed to folk art or crafts, if you get my distinction; “high” art, I guess it would be called), which had some terrific things at some very high prices, the things in the other named shops (“named” in the sense that they were listed in guidebooks, or advertised in tourist magazines and art brochures like the one we picked up at the art museum) were of the same quality range as the junky shops, and usually had higher prices.  (They did also have a larger selection most of the time, too, and a greater variety of objects—masks, plaques, drums, paddles, figurines, prints, and so on.)  Since by this time, I had pretty much decided what I wanted, and the matter was only of finding the right price, quality, and image, it was relatively easy to sift out what I wanted to consider from anything that I could just dismiss.  Ironically, it was in one of the last stores—one of the junky ones, too—where I found the piece I ended up buying.  (It was even on sale, and then the shopkeeper ate the sales tax to boot.  I’d have taken the piece anyway, but what the hey!) 

(By the way, “Gassy” Jack’s story is somewhat amusing: He came to the area when there wasn’t any town, just a lumber camp.  He convinced the lumbermen to build him a saloon in which to serve them, and they did.  In one day!  Tom Sawyer—or was that Huck?  Don’t remember—didn’t have nothin’ on ol’ Gassy Jack!)

After checking out one or two galleries just as “museums” (we weren’t buying, just looking), especially one that specialized in Inuit art, we headed back to the hotel by bus.  (The Inuit gallery was interesting to me because I had bought an Inuit sculpture in Quebec two years ago, and I had read about Pudlo Pudlat, an Inuit artist on whom I did some research some years ago.  He’s dead now, but he’s fairly well known.  (I published “Pudlo Pudlat, Inuit Artist” on ROT on 28 September 2009.)  I saw some of his stuff on exhibit in Quebec, but I spotted one of his lithographs in this Vancouver gallery.  I’m sure the gallery owner was astounded to hear me drop Pudlo’s name; how many browsers would 1) know the name or 2) spot his work behind the sales counter?  We had a brief exchange about Pudlo’s work.)  We realized we weren’t going to make it to Chinatown if we were going to go out to the Museum of Anthropology, which I insisted on, so we had dim sum for lunch at one of the recommended Chinese restaurants which just happened to be right across the street from the hotel.  We had stopped in at the hotel briefly for a quick refreshening, had our dim sum, and took the bus all the way out to the U.B.C. campus—two busses, actually—to see the Museum of Anthropology collection of native artifacts.

We’d had a little consternation over the Museum of Anthropology after we arrived in Vancouver.  We hadn’t considered that our only full day in town would be Monday, a day many museums are traditionally closed.  It was Sunday evening when we realized this, and we asked the hotel concierge to check if the Museum of Anthropology would be open the next day.  He looked it up in an information booklet the hotel keeps, and reported that the Museum of Anthropology was, indeed, closed on Mondays.  Something told me this wasn’t accurate, and I checked the Fodor’s guidebook for Vancouver I had brought from the library here.  It was a 2003 edition, so it was as accurate as a guidebook could be, and it said very specifically that in the summer season, the Museum of Anthropology is open Mondays.  (It is closed that day after the summer, suggesting that the concierge had looked at the off-season schedule by mistake.)  Of course, one or the other source could have been wrong, but the dichotomy meant that we should check again more carefully.  On our way out to Gastown the next morning, I asked the concierge then on duty—a different guy—to check again, and he called the museum.  It wasn’t open at that hour, but the recording clearly said it was open till 5 every day and later on Thursdays or something.  So after our trip down to Gastown and our dim sum lunch, we took the busses as instructed out to U.B.C., found the museum (which is on the other side of the campus, but a pleasant enough walk—including through a formal rose garden where Mom could stop for a brief rest) at about 3:30.

We spent an hour-and-a-half at the museum looking at the totems, masks, paddles, and other carved, painted native British Columbia artifacts.  (The Museum of Anthropology, which is part of the university’s anthropology department, also has exhibits of artifacts from other cultures from around the world, but our interest was in the local Indian stuff.)  These things were relatively old for the most part, of course, removed from sites where they were deteriorating from exposure to preserve them.  Some of the examples of totems and masks and such on exhibit here were obviously outstanding and special, with particularly expressive or unique features, but it was clear that the techniques of the work, especially the carving (since the painting was necessarily faded on these examples), were the same as the modern works we’d seen all along our trip.  (For more discussion about totems and native carvers, see Part 3 of “The Last Frontier,” 25 April.)  Today’s carvers may be using metal tools and chemical paints (and getting paid cash for the work, perhaps), but they are doing the same work their predecessors were doing a century and more ago (and, I presume, before that as well).  I never saw any evidence that the real artists used power tools (the hacks turning out the souvenir totems and masks might—probably do, I’m sure), so it still takes months and even years to carve a tree trunk.  The modern carvers apparently sketch their plan for the totem, which the oldsters probably didn’t do, but I imagine they planned the totem out beforehand—just in their heads instead of on paper.  (The mask carver on the boat didn’t have a sketch, but he was making small masks.  I’m not sure that’s an indication that for other, larger work he or other mask-makers wouldn’t also sketch out a plan.)  It apparently isn’t an inspiration-of-the-moment kind of art.  (Reminds me of the descriptions of Michelangelo and Diego Rivera doing their frescoes and murals—the “cartoons” they drew before applying paint to the walls.)

After the museum, a very worthwhile trip, and our bus ride back to the hotel—it’s about an hour each way, plus the walk to and from the museum itself—we got ready for our last evening in the Northwest.  We had chosen a seafood restaurant on a pier for dinner, and we caught a cab down even though it really wasn’t very far.  The weather in Vancouver, by the way, had been terrific—warm and sunny, after the rain of the last days in Alaska—and the evening was just right.  The restaurant is a big and bustling place, obviously popular, especially with the 20-something crowd.  We couldn’t get a table when we had really wanted to, so we arrived early in hopes that we might get seated before our reservation.  It didn’t work out that way, but we had planned to have a drink before dinner anyway, so we ordered an appetizer in the “pub” and had our drink and a knosh (fried oysters) while we waited and watched the marina outside.  No hardship, as you can imagine.  When our table was ready, we chose our final meal for the trip—salmon, wouldn’t you know—and ate looking out at part of Vancouver’s harbor and across to nearby mountains.  Not an unpleasant way to end our trip. 

Our flight out on Tuesday, 19 August, was at 11 a.m., a nice hour—not too early and not too late.  Everything went without event, from the check-in through customs and immigration (U.S.) to the change at O’Hare.  In contrast with the miserable trip out, the return was a joy (if flying can ever be a joy these days).  We got into LaGuardia on time and got back to Manhattan and home at about 10:30 or 11 p.m., as I had expected.  I took Thespis, my Jack Russell-mix, out as soon as we got in, and met my young dog-sitter just as she was coming in to retrieve her stuff.  As I said, the tour aspects of the trip left a lot to be desired, but the Alaska parts were good enough to make up for it for the most part.  If we had known better, we’d have been better off making some plans just on our own and cut out HAL altogether for everything except the ship.  But I don’t know how we’d have known that until after we’d made the mistake.  Even the travel agent in Washington Mother used for the flights and the hotel in Vancouver recommended going through HAL because it was easier to coordinate that way, and they had the reputation of being good.  Well, either they never deserved the reputation or they’ve slipped recently.  It all ended very well, however.

This whole saga reminds me of something my dad said after we’d seen the six-hour, two-part Soviet film version of War and Peace way back when.  The next morning he said, “I’m exhausted.  All night long, I kept marching back and forth across Russia!”  Do you feel like you’ve trekked from Anchorage to Vancouver now?  I guess I did go on, didn’t I.

[Well, if I did “go on,” and you’re still here, I guess it wasn’t that taxing, was it?  Rereading this travelogue after 11 years brought a lot of this trip back to me—and I hope you all who read it here had something of the experience.  Because of the hardship of travel nowadays, this trip to Alaska was one of the last long ones I’ve made.  In the old days, my mother and I tried to make one longish voyage a year—Istanbul was the last one we did (reported on ROT on 24 June 2010)—but that’s no longer true.  (On that last trip, when we were making our way out of the airport after the return flight, Mom insisted that it would be the last one she made.  It’s just more work and less fun now.)  In any case, I hope this log of my long-ago trip to “The Last Frontier” entertained you all.]

 

14 November 2009

'The Art of Writing Reviews' by Kirk Woodward, Part 4


[This is Part 4, the final installment, of my commentary on Kirk Woodward’s book, The Art of Writing Reviews (http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback-book/the-art-of-writing-reviews/6785272).]

After treating the matter of reviewers closing productions with poor notices, Kirk raises the question of reviewers who know people connected to the production and fear their notices might hurt their friends and acquaintances. It’s hard, perhaps, for reviewers not to become engaged in the social whirl of the arts they cover. That’s probably more true in smaller markets than in large ones like New York or L.A., but there’s a danger here, too. I remember reading an article about New York Times chief reviewer Ben Brantley, who I thought had taken a pretty extreme action to avoid that--he literally absents himself entirely from the New York social scene. According to the report, he lived outside the city (though he may have moved in since then) and apparently doesn’t socialize with anyone connected to theater. (I thought this was extreme not because Brantley avoids the social aspects of the biz—that may be difficult but wise—but because, not living in the city he covers, he loses perspective on the atmosphere—political, communal, economic, cultural—that surrounds and informs the art about which he writes.)

The Times doesn’t permit its theater reviewers to participate in any awards program (editors and other journalists may, and I don’t know if reviewers in other arts are similarly enjoined) because the editors don’t want their reviewers even to appear to have conflicts of interest. A few years ago, Critics Quarterly (the newsletter of ATCA, which Kirk would insist ought to be called Reviewers Quarterly . . . or, maybe, Reviewers Review) did a series of articles, plus letters from members, concerning reviewers who got involved in other aspects of theater such as playwriting or acting. Some members felt this was a good way to learn more about the business, by seeing it from the inside while it was working. Others were vociferous in their opinions that this placed the reviewers in danger of becoming too personally acquainted with the artists they would be called on to criticize. I no longer was trying to act when I was writing reviews, but I still knew actors, directors, designers, and stage managers who were working in New York and there were theater companies run by friends and former colleagues producing plays I might have to review. The situation only arose once or twice, and I raised the potential conflict with my editor, but I was surprised when he said he didn’t really care. (I think the real situation was that he didn’t have that many writers on whom he could call and he couldn’t replace me.) It was very hard to be objective and I had to question myself very carefully when it came to writing about the people I knew, even slightly.

Interestingly, there’s an organization in New York City that was established essentially to address this situation. The Players, on Gramercy Park, was founded by actor Edwin Booth (in his last home, where his room is still preserved as he left it) to allow actors to meet the important citizens of the city on a social basis. He thought that members of his profession ought to know the people who supported the theater and the city’s movers and shakers in all fields, politics, finance, merchandising, letters, and so on, should know the theater artists who were so important to New York’s culture. (Theater was, at the time, the popular entertainment, much as movies and TV are today.) That is, all the professions except one. No reviewers could be members of The Players. Booth didn’t think it would be wise to put actors in the same room with the writers who from time to time may have said uncomplimentary things about them. Now, the all-male membership has been integrated in recent years, but the prohibition against reviewers still holds. (By the way, the organization is called The Players, not the Players Club.)

When he writes about reporting on the play’s plot, Kirk proposes, “We can ask, what happens to the characters? Do they grow, change, move from point A to point N?” This is very close to the question dramaturgs learn to ask when analyzing a script for their artistic directors: Who does the play happen to? It’s a way of determining which character is the focal one (which may not be the same as the lead role or the literary protagonist). It’s an interesting question to ask, even for a reviewer.

When it comes to the perspective of the spectator, Kirk reminds us that “not everyone in the theater sees—or hears—the same show.” It’s a fact of live performances that no two people see the same show and no two performances are the same. No matter where you sit in a movie theater, you see essentially the same movie as everyone else (barring sitting behind a pillar or a very tall person). But with a live performance, especially theater or ballet, there’s an element of Heraclitus’ tenet: “One cannot step twice into the same river, for the water into which you first stepped has flowed on.” The corollary is that no two people can step into the same river because the water where one stepped is not the same as the water where the other did. (Besides, no two people’s experience of that river will be the same, either. That’s true of movies and television, too, of course.) The trade-off is that in live theater, I can choose where I want to look. In film and TV, the camera, under the director’s control, does that for me.

Kirk asserts that theater pros feel “that opening nights are the worst performances” of a play’s run. Openings are still the traditional night for reviewers and the press, despite the scheduling of “critics’ previews.” (No matter when the reviewer sees the show, the notice traditionally appears the day after opening.) I was never a first-nighter, so I had the luxury of seeing the performances after the play opened and settled down, and even now, I generally avoid opening nights. To be frank, openings are more social events than artistic ones and the company’s emotions are high and tight. Friends and family are in the house; agents and managers come to see their clients; the producers, backers, and investors and their invited guests are there for the festivities; non-reviewing press—editors, feature writers, cultural reporters—are covering the “news” event. Everyone backstage is on edge, you can bet. (When I first started to perform, I couldn’t eat before a performance. When I got more used to the experience, that was no longer so—except on opening nights.)

In addition to the emotional tension, there are the various production issues that affect the performance. It’s a truism in theater that no planned rehearsal period is long enough. You always need another week. In many shows, the first time everyone has gone through the entire play with full tech and costumes the way it’s supposed to be seen by the audience is the final dress rehearsal. On opening night, there will be acting and directing problems from both nerves and from not being quite ready yet. In new plays, it’s not unusual for new lines and even new scenes to be inserted within days of opening; new songs can be added to musicals. Because of the labor-intensivity of the rehearsal period plus the union regulations, technical adjustments are often brought in at the last minute: costumes don’t fit quite right yet, set pieces haven’t been tested, lights aren’t focused right. (I once actually went on stage with a set still wet with last-minute, improvised “paint”: pea soup!) No, opening night is not a typical performance. It’s more like the first time a cook makes a new recipe—it’s not really ready for primetime.

Still, I remember an occurrence that remains one of the strangest of which I have ever heard in theater. In 1997, The Scarlet Pimpernel opened at the Minskoff Theatre on 9 November. It received mediocre reviews or worse. New producers stepped in and bought out the old investors, closed the show on 1 October 1998 for retooling, and reopened it on 4 November. Talk about not being ready on opening night!

In debating whether reviews are “art,” Kirk paraphrases Will and Ariel Durant’s definition of art: “significance expressed with feeling through form.” (The quote is from Writing Reviews, not the Durants.) I’d like to add another, very similar definition from Susanne Langer, another philosopher: “Art is the creation of forms symbolic of human feeling.” As you can see, it’s nearly the same language. Let me add here another of Langer’s statements that I have found revealing—because it’s a comment about “beauty” in a context we should consider when viewing many new kinds of art. (This harks back to the remarks Kirk and I made about standards and new art not resembling the old.) Langer writes: “Beauty is not identical with the normal, and certainly not with charm and sense appeal, though all such properties may go to the making of it.”

Beauty, I think Langer’s saying, ain’t always pretty. She also defines beauty as “expressive form,” by which she maintains that it affects its audience in some way. “Beautiful works may contain elements that, taken in isolation, are hideous,” she writes. This interpretation of beauty, which may owe something to Heraclitus’ view that there is beauty in a random collection of unrelated elements, can be seen as an application of Aristotle’s explanation that we get pleasure in drama even from seeing things we’d regard with disgust if encountered in reality because we learn from them, and learning gives us pleasure. Furthermore, Langer admonishes us that we may not recognize as good a work of art that puts us off until “we have grasped its expressiveness.” One friend of Vincent van Gogh’s, for instance, admitted that at first the painter’s art “was so totally different from what I had imagined it would be . . . so rough and unkempt, so harsh and unfinished, that . . . I was unable to think it good or beautiful.” It’s noteworthy that Marshall McLuhan calls “good taste,” often substituted for “beauty” in the judgment of traditionalists, “the first refuge of the noncreative . . . , the anesthetic of the public . . . , the most obvious resource of the insecure.” Richard Kostelanetz, whom I quoted earlier, also submits that “a truly original, truly awakening piece of art will not, at first, be accepted as beautiful.”

In his discussion of “good art” and “great art,” Kirk remarks, “I could write a play that conforms to all Aristotle’s principles and has no value at all—indeed, many have.” First, let me reiterate here, in the words of Susanne Langer, what I said about poor art earlier: “There may be poor art, which is not corrupt, but fails to express what [the artist] knew in too brief an intuition. . . . . The result is a poor and helpless product, sincere enough, but confused and frustrated by recalcitrance of the medium or sheer lack of technical freedom.” Langer takes a harsher line with “bad art,” but making poor art is not a criminal act. Now, I’ll draw a literary parallel between what Kirk wrote about writing a mediocre play that follows all the rules and an old play to which I once introduced Kirk, Plots and Playwrights by Edward Massey.

The plot concerns Caspar Gay, a successful Broadway playwright wandering Greenwich Village looking for “an inspiration” for his next play. He meets young short-story writer Joseph Hastings in front of a boarding house. Gay explains his desperation, and Hastings suggests that there’s a play on every floor of the house and the two writers challenge one another. Hastings composes small dramas based on the intimate, but revealing, stories of the residents of each floor of the house, one scene for each apartment. Gay’s output, on the other hand, is complex and predictable, a contrived melodrama about all the house’s residents in improbable relationships. Hastings reacts in disbelief to Gay’s creation, and the famous playwright responds, “But it will run a year on Broadway.” “My God,” cries the enlightened novelist, “it has.” And that’s what can happen when you merely follow all the rules!

I do want to take small exception to one thing Kirk writes. Actually, I want to expand it a bit. The author notes, correctly, that “some works are simply better than others.” I’d add, “. . . for some people.” As Kirk continues, “Our criteria and judgments about art will always be subjective,” so each of us will see and feel things no one else will, and vice versa. Hence, art I think is great may seem mediocre or even awful to you and art you love may leave me cold. (Furthermore, taste, like the truth, changes over time. But let’s not get into that.) I’ll admit here that I don’t much like Harold Pinter’s plays. I’ll acknowledge that he was probably a genius, but his plays always just confuse me and leave me frustrated. I don’t enjoy those feelings. Obviously, though, mine’s a minority opinion since he won a Nobel in lit in 2005. As my father liked to say, De gustibus non disputandum est: There’s no accounting for taste.

When it comes to defining who’s an artist, Kirk quotes some lines from 8th-century Chinese poet Li Po. Allow me to add another voice, William Shakespeare:

The poet’s eye, in a fine frenzy rolling,
Doth glance from heaven to earth, from earth to heaven;
And, as imagination bodies forth
The forms of things unknown, the poet’s pen
Turns them to shapes, and gives to airy nothing
A local habitation and a name.

Further, Kirk adds that someone who writes, plays, or sings isn’t automatically an artist: an artist needs “to create something that changes the way people feel, hear, and think.” Living Theatre co-founder Julian Beck declared, “An actor who brings back from his adventures a moment of communicable penetration is a hero, the light of our lives.” It is perhaps noteworthy that the people who make commercials don’t call the performers who appear on the screen “artists”: they are simply “the talent.” I guess even the producers of TV commercials don’t figure it takes an artist to sell toilet paper or cars.

When Writing Reviews gets to contemplating how a reviewer actually goes about composing the review, Kirk addresses the question of whether or not to take notes while viewing the performance. (The question is less pertinent for non-performing arts, such as book or art reviewing, for obvious reasons.) His conclusion comes down on both sides of the question: “Take notes when you have to.” I’ve tried both ways, and a third in the middle (taking notes without looking at the pad!), and I end up in Kirk’s corner on this. You have to pay attention to what you’re watching and any distraction lessens your attentiveness. On the other hand, there are details that you recognize as potentially telling, like, say, a line of dialogue or a particularly revealing movement or gesture, and you know you can’t remember them for long without writing it down. Sometimes I’ve been able to keep the thing in mind long enough to jot it down in the lobby at intermission or right after the performance, which kind of splits the difference, but there’s no definitive answer for everyone; some people’s memories are just better than others' and some bits of performance are more memorable than others. You have to go with what works for you under the circumstances.

By the way, in an earlier paragraph, Kirk advises that “it is difficult for anyone . . . to take in an entire show at one sitting.” This is especially so if you’re taking notes while you’re watching. The trade-off is that if you don’t take the notes, you might not remember later what you did manage to “take in.” Going back, as some of the pros Kirk invokes suggest, is a good way to solve this dilemma, but that’s time consuming and, if you’re footing the bill for the extra tix, expensive. It also can get in the way of meeting deadlines. (TV reviewers have a much easier job here: they are usually provided with recordings of the program, several episodes if it’s a series, and can both pause the video to make a note and go back and re-watch parts or all of the show.)

I want to comment on something Kirk wrote near the end of Writing Reviews because I've always remembered it ever since I heard it. (I don't always follow the advice very well, but I do remember it!) In the "Reviewing your review" section, Kirk tells the reader to ask, "Can you say things more directly, cut out useless words, eliminate the unnecessary?" (That’s writing advice, of course, not just review-writing advice.) A teacher of mine used to say, "Kill your babies," meaning be willing to cut the things you like the most when they aren't really helping. Be ruthless, she meant. I often wish I could do that—but I have too much "ruth" I guess. But I hear her say that whenever I edit my work—especially when I come to something I know I should cut . . . but don’t want to.

Finally, one of the last observations of Writing Reviews is the statement that though we may “see a lot of bad art” over our lifetimes, “we’ll also experience things that enrich and possibly change our lives . . . .” Intentionally or otherwise, Kirk’s speaking of all kinds of art, not just theater or the performing arts. I could make a short list of the works of art, performances, texts, and visual art, that have moved me or showed me something so that I’ve never forgotten it or the experience. But I want to close out these comments by quoting an artist who made this point very clearly in his own way. I’ve written about the Inuit artist Pudlo Pudlat before (ROT, 28 September), and I quoted this then: “If an artist draws a subject over and over again in different ways, then he will learn something. The same with someone who looks at drawings—if that person keeps looking at many drawings, then he will learn something from them too.” A wise, wise man.

28 September 2009

Pudlo Pudlat, Inuit Artist


Some time back, I wrote a profile of experimental stage director Leonardo Shapiro and his theater troupe, The Shaliko Company, for TDR ("Shapiro and Shaliko: Techniques of Testimony," The Drama Review 37.4 [T140 - Winter 1993]: 65-100). I had spent months following Leo around, plowing through his files and records, interviewing him and his colleagues, and attending rehearsals and classes. I had first met Leo when I covered the Theatre of Nations in Baltimore in 1986 and saw his magnificent production of The Yellow House, a play about Vincent van Gogh he’d composed with his company, and I interviewed him as one of the participating artists. After that, I’d kept up on Shaliko’s work so I knew a little about Leo, most pointedly that he took his inspiration from the theories of Bertolt Brecht and Jerzy Grotowski. Later, when I was preparing the TDR article, I asked Leo who his other influences were. At first, he said he didn’t know; he’d never thought about it. Then, a few days later, he handed me a list of names and works of art which he said were the influences or inspirations of his artistic and philosophical life. It was a varied and fascinating list, covering all the arts and some politics, and including some names and works that I found surprising in Leo’s case. I’d at least heard of most of the names on the list, but there were four or five that were unfamiliar to me, and one or two that I couldn’t find when I first looked them up. One of these was an Inuit artist, Pudlo Pudlat, whom Leo admired because of his “courage and openness.”

Some years later, because I found the subject of Leo and his theater work so interesting, and because I had so much unused material left over after the TDR profile, I decided to expand the essay into a book-length examination of Leo’s art. One of my first notions was to research the names and art works on Leo’s list and see what in them might have inspired Leo’s art and ideas and use that as a sort of reflection of Leo’s own work, a commentary, so to speak. When I came to Pudlo--Inuit commonly use only one name and the artist is internationally known this way--I found an engrossing and revealing subject in its own right. I fancy myself a devotee of art, especially modern art, so I pursued the story of Pudlo a little more extensively than other names on Leo’s list. The artist just interested me. Here’s some of what I learned.

First, a number of years after I did this research, I made a visit to Quebec, which is a center of Inuit art. The galleries all over the city show Inuit artists and there’s an Inuit art museum, the Galerie Art Inuit, a few doors up the street from our hotel. I learned some general facts about the whole niche that is Inuit art, which has an interesting, and I suspect unique, history. Since Pudlo’s part of this continuum, let me précis this chronicle before I go into his own story.

If you are my age or older, you are probably more used to speaking of Eskimos, but especially in Canada the more current, and preferred, expression is Inuit. (That’s the plural; the singular is Inuk, which means person). Eskimo, which is still used in Alaska, refers to several native peoples, including the Inuit. The term Eskimo is a foreign word applied to the Inuit and other peoples by outside tribes. Its most likely etymology is a Montagnais word meaning snowshoe-lacer. (The Montagnais are a group inhabiting the north shore of the Gulf of St. Lawrence in Quebec and Labrador.) In Canada, however, the word is believed to be derived from an Algonquin word that means raw meat-eater, and although linguistically this is less likely, the belief is widely held in Canada and the word Eskimo is considered derogatory and racist. In any case, the Canadian government officially recognizes the people of the far north, including Nunavut, as Inuit; the name Eskimo is seldom heard in the country.

The Inuit were a nomadic culture of hunter-gatherers well into the 20th century, following the fish and game of the far north as the ice receded, living in igloos (which means simply house and may be made of ice and snow, according to the image we have, but is also commonly built from stone, sod, mud, skins, or any other convenient material), and moving from spot to spot as the hunting, weather, or terrain necessitated. Traveling by dogsled across land and in umiaks or the smaller kayaks across water, an Inuit family or clan could not really afford to carry much with them that wasn’t of immediate practical value in their harsh life, so decoration was minimal, and artwork, even on practical items, was uncommon. What little there was was carved ivory or bone. A change occurred in about 1945, however, when the Canadian government encouraged Inuit and other native peoples to settle in towns and villages, learn cultivation and other domestic skills, and give up the nomadic way of life they had known for centuries. I won’t get into the socio-political implications of this change (except to suggest that it wasn’t entirely insensitive and cold-hearted as the world around the Inuit had changed and their subsistence existence was becoming untenable), but the sociological effect was profound.

The Canadian government saw that the move to permanent habitation in towns and villages left many Inuit without traditional livelihoods or even pastimes. This was mostly true of the men, as the women were able to transfer their traditional responsibilities of homemaking and child-rearing from the nomadic existence to the permanent one with little significant change (except, of course, that they now got their material needs from stores instead of the wild). The men, on the other hand, were the ones who lost their customary occupations. Looking around for something with which to replace the lost income and work, the government lit on art and established training programs and outlets for whatever the Inuit produced, even supplying them with the materials they needed. In what may be one of the rare examples among artificial cultural redirection, the plan succeeded wildly. I guess the Inuit had a hidden tribal talent for making terrific art, and they started a co-op to market and determine the prices of their work so that they wouldn’t be ripped off by gallery owners and dealers or, in turn, cheat the buying public. (That Inuit art museum in Quebec is run by the co-op, and all the galleries, from the high-end chi-chi ones to the shops in hotels to the tourist dives, all sold the Inuit art at the same range of prices.) Inuit art took off in popularity and desirability in the south. Over time, some artists became recognized and art museums began organizing exhibitions of Inuit works. Collectors, first in Canada then in the United States, began to buy the art. Whole villages lived off the art turned out in their community studios, some making it, some marketing it, some managing the studios; printmaking became a profitable concern. Over 60 years now, Inuit art has become established and while it started as naïve work, it now has a sophistication and dynamic that compares easily with the works of American Indian artists in, say, the Taos art colony area. In both cases, too, the themes and subjects developed from strict focus on traditional culture to an embrace of the whole universe around them--in the case of the Inuit, the Canada of the Europeans and the technology of the middle- and late-20th-century world. Though many Inuit artists work in a naturalistic style, carving animals or scenes common to the Canadian north, many others work in symbolist and abstract styles that draw on indigenous images and refer to the style of Inuit art that developed in the post-WWII years (there not having been a true indigenous precursor). The media used by Inuit artists has expanded as well, from simple carvings to sophisticated soapstone sculpture, painting, drawing, lithography, and all the forms commonly used by Western artists.

Pudlo was born on Baffin Island, Northwest Territories, Canada (now part of Nunavut Province, the Inuit homeland), on 4 February 1916. He straddled the generation that lived an entirely nomadic life and that born in permanent abodes of towns and villages. In 1957, Pudlo suffered a hunting accident which he dismissed as minor until the injury required medical attention a month later and was flown south for treatment. A few days after he returned north to recuperate, he was diagnosed with tuberculosis and went back south again to recover. The injury and the illness forced Pudlo and his wife, Innukjuakju, who had also been ill, to give up their nomadic life and they settled in the village of Kiaktuuq, Cape Dorset, in the spring of 1958 when Pudlo was 42. Cape Dorset was the epicenter of the emerging Inuit art community, established there only a few years earlier. Pudlo met James Archibald Houston, the Canadian southerner who was the prime force in developing Inuit art, and took up art himself. Though he made sculptures, he found carving difficult because of the hunting injury to his arm and by 1959 or ’60, his preferred media became watercolors, oils, and especially drawing and lithography. (Many of Pudlo’s works exist as both a drawing and a subsequent print.) Pudlo saw ten of his first drawings commercially printed in 1961 and he continued to make art for the last 33 years of his life and left an output of over 4,500 drawings and 190 prints in the end. His work is exhibited in galleries and museums around the continent and abroad, including MoMA, and his drawings and prints are still in demand. A few years after that trip to Quebec I was in Vancouver, on the opposite coast of the country, and I recognized several of his prints in the city’s art galleries. (One gallery owner was astonished that I not only knew Pudlo but that I spotted his work almost instantly. Shocked my mother, too! Thank you, Leo.) Pudlo has been the subject of many articles in art magazines and several books, which include reproductions of his drawings and prints. Among his other accomplishments as an artist, one of his drawings, Umingmuk (1970, the image of a huge, shaggy, but rather friendly-looking muskox), was reproduced as a 1972 UNICEF greeting card and in 1978, Aeroplane (1976) was chosen as the design for a Canadian postage stamp. Pudlo died in Cape Dorset on 28 December 1992 at 76.

The artist had a wonderful sense of humor which only expanded as his art became more elaborate, from the simple pencil drawings of his early work to his colorful later sketches drawn with felt-tipped pens. Pudlo not only worked in many forms but he incorporated in his art images of both indigenous subjects such as caribou, fish, hunters, and dog sleds, and modern, technological ones such as helicopters, snowmobiles, power lines, and satellite dishes. He mixed in Christian iconography with Inuit shamanistic symbols. Pudlo also included imaginary images alongside the old and new reality, all to create a portrait of his times and the world he saw around him, metaphorically and actually. In a way, Pudlo the hunter transferred his sharp eye and analytical mind from finding game with gun and dogsled to depicting life with paper and ink. In a broad sense, he was a documentarist. “Artists draw what they think . . . ,” said Pudlo. “That’s how they are. They draw what they think--and what they have seen also. But sometimes they draw something from their imagination, something that doesn’t exist anywhere in the world.”

Although other native artists had begun to incorporate the modern European world in their art, Pudlo was among the earliest who recognized that modern technology had long ago become part of human, even Native American, culture. He treated this encroachment on traditional life as integral to the world of his people, a permanent and everyday element rather than a temporary or unwelcome intrusion. (In contrast, American Indian artists often see Euro-American technology as a dangerous threat to be expunged.) Pudlo’s work is a visual evocation of the nexus between the traditional life of the Inuit and the modern world of Canada and the south. He saw, more clearly perhaps than other native artists, that there were now more snowmobiles than dog teams; more motor boats than umiaks; that Christianity was quickly displacing traditional shamanism; airplanes were commonplace; and telephones, television, and the Internet were bringing the south into the Inuit’s living rooms and keeping far-flung members of the tribe in regular contact with each other and the tribal center. No longer foreign or alien, the planes, helicopters, angels, and churches in Pudlo’s drawings had become part of northern life. It is this openness to the new experience, which he encountered repeatedly whenever he went south, that is fundamental to Pudlo’s art. Over his career, the artist demonstrated an endless inventiveness and versatility both in his techniques and his subjects. Pudlo not only saw that, along with the indigenous images, the formerly foreign objects had long ago become part of the native culture, he knew that by drawing these once-alien images, capturing them in various juxtapositions with traditional ones, such as a miniature airplane tethered to the horns of a gigantic muskox, he gained a measure of control over them. In Leo Shapiro’s words, Pudlo “adapts art to his incomprehensible life.”

That muskox image is in Pudlo’s Winds of Change (1983/1984 drawing; 1985 lithograph) which shows two Inuit and a dog (the indigenous form of transportation) bound together like mountain-climbers on the undulating, knobby back of a muskox, tied to one of the horns, and an airplane attached to the tips of the animal’s horns as if in a giant slingshot. Another plane is buzzing the ox--perhaps one that’s already been launched. It’s a wonderful example of Pudlo’s tendency of juxtaposing the familiar and the exotic--though what he found “familiar” and “exotic” were, of course, the reverse of what we southerners find so. (The juxtaposition still functions, however.)

Aeroplane, the drawing that was reproduced for the stamp, depicts a large, colorfully-decorated prop plane over an arctic mountainscape while seals lie on floes in the blue sea below. "This is like an iceberg or a big hill of snow,” the artist explained; “that is what I was thinking when I was drawing." Four anorak-clad Inuit stare up at the plane. Two huge icebergs rise up to the plane and two more figures stand on them as if to reach the plane. The airplane became a frequent symbol in Pudlo’s later work of the confluence of the old way of life and the new--but it was an object of interest, not of fear. Pudlo’s two worlds meet here, not in a clash of cultures but in an atmosphere of curiosity and wonder. "Whenever there is a plane,” Pudlo said, “we go up to the hills to get a better look at it." Not only did the artist depict modern technology alongside more traditional images in his art, he found it to be a beneficial addition to society. Having been saved from death or permanent handicap by being airlifted to the south for medical treatment on at least two occasions, he saw planes and helicopters as useful inventions. It is interesting to note that Pudlo explored the meaning of modern technology in other ways as well. In New Parts for an Inuk (1981), for instance, he drew an anthropomorphic figure with a light and antenna on its cap and a clock over its heart in a reflection of the artist’s own pacemaker, installed that same year. Some descriptions assert that the figure bears horns, antlers, and hooves (though what these are is more than open to interpretation, I’d say), all of which would be references to the game that Pudlo used to hunt in his nomadic days. While New Parts remains true to Pudlo’s documentary approach, that is, recording the world he saw around him, it is full of visual puns and fantasy, a self-portrait--the Inuk, or man, is Pudlo himself, of course--that shows himself in a highly symbolic and whimsical manner.

His investigation of the convergence of the European and native worlds in Canada is most vividly portrayed in North and South (1974) which shows the “white Arctic camp scene” of the Inuit north on the right and the “blue lakes and lush, green forests” of the European-dominated south on the left, each in a separate field surrounded by a border, but connected by a bridge-like arc. Pudlo asserted that the bridge demonstrates how cultures that were “split off” from one another “before telephones or radio” (i.e., technology), “even though we were part of one piece, Canada, . . . are touching each other--through CBC radio and telephones.” Having himself been saved from possible death from a hunting accident in 1957 by being airlifted to medical care in Western hospitals, Pudlo deemed the airplane and helicopter useful inventions for aiding stranded and isolated people.

One aspect of Pudlo’s art that is distinctive and makes him such a captivating artist (along with his whimsy), is the way one work carries over to the next. Within one drawing, one idea or image might be echoed in another, but each drawing can also be seen as a preparation for another one, with each succeeding work developing or continuing explorations the artist started earlier. He could take an image or idea, either Western or traditional, and experiment with it, looking for a way to depict it accurately. Images or ideas might be repeated differently or Pudlo might experiment with technique or approach, resulting in a series of drawings that explore and develop that new approach. Pudlo didn’t just document what he saw and experienced around him, he examined it, learned from it. He saw art as a kind of investigation, both for the artist and for the spectator: The muskox, for instance, a frequent image in Pudlo’s work (including Umingmuk, the print that UNICEF made into a greeting card in 1972), is not actually indigenous to his native territory in Nunavut: he first saw some being corralled in northern Quebec in 1957, and then he saw a herd from the air while on a flight from the south in 1969. He became fascinated with this strange, new beast. And like the snowmobile, the airplane, or the helicopter, this unfamiliar creature fascinated Pudlo and he attempted to understand it by drawing it. “If an artist draws a subject over and over again in different ways,” Pudlo said, “then he will learn something. The same with someone who looks at drawings--if that person keeps looking at many drawings, then he will learn something from them too.”