Showing posts with label Pulitzer Prize. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pulitzer Prize. Show all posts

22 December 2019

'The Young Man from Atlanta' (Signature Theatre Company)


I saw the Broadway dĂ©but of The Young Man from Atlanta with Rip Torn and Shirley Knight in March 1997, but when I saw the current revival at the Signature Theatre Company, I found I didn’t remember the play as well as I thought.  For instance, I didn’t remember it as a depressing, disheartening play—that’s not how I think of Horton Foote (1916-2009).  Sentimental, yes, and with a romanticized vision in this rear-view; poignant, perhaps, and even heartbreaking at moments—but not depressing.  I said after the performance that maybe that’s because when I saw it 22 years ago, I wasn’t 72 and most of my family hadn’t died yet.  As things are now, the play kept bringing me waaay down!

(I had other trouble with my memory with regard to the play.  I remembered seeing the Broadway production—I didn’t look it up, though I meant to—but, first, I thought it had been the play’s premiĂšre.  It wasn’t: it premiĂšred at Signature in 1995, then played in regional rep houses before returning for a commercial run in New York City.  Second, I thought I’d seen it in the ’80s, not the late ’90s.  I was off by 10 years or more!)

The world premiĂšre of The Young Man from Atlanta took place from 27 January to 26 February 1995 during the Signature Theatre’s 1994-95 Horton Foote season at the Kampo Cultural Center (31 Bond Street in the East Village).  The production was directed by Peter Masterson with Ralph Waite as Will Kidder and Carlin Glynn as Lily Dale; it won the 1995 Pulitzer Prize for Drama for Foote.

Regional productions were staged by the Huntington Theatre Company in Boston, Massachusetts, from 20 October to 19 November 1995; the Alley Theatre in Houston (where the play was developed and had readings) from 16 February to 16 March 1996; and the Goodman Theatre in Chicago from 27 January to 1 March 1997.  That last staging starred Rip Torn and Shirley Knight as the Kidders, directed by Robert Falls, the Goodman’s artistic director.  It was this cast that came to Broadway later that year.

Though there had been publicized talk of bringing back the cast from the Signature dĂ©but for the Broadway premiĂšre, the producers decided that some changes need to be made to the pay, so a new director and cast were engaged for the New York transfer, and Falls, Torn, Knight, and the Goodman company were selected.  The production ran at the Longacre Theatre from 27 March to 8 June 1997, and though it lasted only 17 previews and 84 regular performances, received 1997 Tony nominations for Best Play, Best Actress In A Play (Knight), and Best Featured Actor In A Play (William Biff McGuire as Pete Davenport), and a 1997 Drama Desk Award nomination for Outstanding Actress In A Play (Knight).

The play text is published by Penguin (1996) in a single edition and in the Northwestern University Press collection Three Plays: Dividing the Estate, The Trip to Bountiful, and The Young Man from Atlanta (2009).  An “acting edition” (1995) of the script is available from the Dramatists Play Service.  There’s no video of Young Man, but an audio recording is available.  The unabridged reading, which stars Shirley Knight and David Selby, was released in 1999 by L.A. Theater Works and can be downloaded from http://www.audible.com or purchased through online or local booksellers. 

The STC revival, the first in New York City since the 1997 Broadway run, began previews in the Irene Diamond Stage, the large, 294-seat proscenium house at the Pershing Square Signature Center on Theatre Row, on 5 November 2019; it opened to the press on 24 November.  Diana, my frequent theater partner, and I caught the 7:30 p.m. performance on Friday, 6 December; the production closed on December 15 (after a week’s extension beyond its originally-scheduled final performance on 8 December).

Directed by Michael Wilson (who previously helmed Foote’s Orphans’ Home Cycle, 2009-10, and The Old Friends, 2013, for STC, as well as Arthur Miller’s Incident at Vichy, 2015; and the Acting Company’s Desire, 2015, at 59E59 and Foote’s The Roads to Home, 2016, at the Cherry Lane—all of which I saw and on which I reported on Rick On Theater) and running two hours and five minutes (with one intermission), the STC version of Young Man has lost one character (Miss Lacey—whose role I don’t even recall!). 

In Young Man, Foote brought back characters who’d been seen in his monumental three-evening, nine-play Orphans’ Home Cycle (see my report on 25 and 28 February 2010).  Will Kidder was in his early 20’s in Lily Dale, and approaching middle age in Cousins.  Lily Dale Kidder was introduced in Roots in a Parched Ground as a 10-year-old, and was portrayed in subsequent life stages in Lily Dale and Cousins.  Her stepfather, 78-year-old Pete Davenport, first appears at age thirty in Roots in a Parched Ground.  According to the playwright, he thought he was done with these characters after Cousins, but in the early 1990s found himself thinking about them again and started work on this play.

In Houston in the spring of 1950, Will Kidder, age 61 (Aiden Quinn, back on stage for the first time after seven seasons on CBS’s Elementary), is in his office at the Sunshine Southern Wholesale Grocery, where he has worked since his early 20’s.  He reveals that he’s been diagnosed with a slight heart condition.  Will and his wife, Lily Dale, have just moved into their new house and, as Will tells Tom Jackson (Dan Bittner), the young man Will hired and trained (as he keeps mentioning), “There’s no finer house in Houston.”  He was poor as a child and made a successful career and now insists on only “the biggest and best.”  He’s sunk $200,000 (equivalent to $2.1 million in 2019) in the new house and has put a down payment on a new car as a gift for Lily Dale. 

Will, then, is shocked when his boss, Ted Cleveland, Jr. (Devon Abner, the only cast member who appeared in the 1995 premiĂšre, playing Tom Jackson), the son of the man Will came to work at Sunshine for, fires him to make room for newer blood.  (If you guess it’s Tom whom Will is pushed aside to make room for, you get a gold star.  Tom, at least, has the consideration to tell Will himself that he’s the one.)  Will announces that he plans to start his own business and contacts local banks to secure loans for the venture; the banks—with whom he’d been doing business for years—aren’t encouraging.

Will talks about his only son, Bill, who had moved to Atlanta.  Bill drowned six months ago at 37, and Will suspects Bill actually committed suicide.  The young man couldn’t swim, yet he walked out into a lake in Florida until the water was over his head.  Lily Dale (Kristine Nielsen), Will’s wife and Bill’s mother, refuses to consider such a possibility, instead believing that his death was an accident.  Bill’s roommate, Randy Carter, the “Young Man from Atlanta” (whom we never see) has come to Houston from Atlanta to try to see Will, who believes that all he wants is money. 

(Is it a coincidence that Tennessee Williams wrote a play in 1937 in which a character commits suicide in a way that’s remarkably similar to Bill Kidder’s death in Foote’s Young Man?  The play is called Escape or, in a 2004 New York staging, Summer at the Lake, and was a precursor to The Glass Menagerie; a review of “Five by Tenn,” a bill of one-acts first staged in 2004 which included Escape, was posted on ROT on 5 March 2011.  The suicide-by-drowning was a reference to the suicide death of Williams’s literary hero, poet Hart Crane.  Both Williams and Crane were gay men.)

Lily Dale’s widowed step-father, 78-year-old Pete Davenport (Stephen Payne), lives with the Kidders and he’s being visited by another young man from Atlanta, his 27-year-old great-nephew Carson (Jonny Orsini), who just happens to have lived in the same boarding house as Randy and Bill (and is now staying at the same Houston YMCA where Randy is staying).   Will asks both Lily Dale and Pete for loans to help him launch his new company, but he learns that Lily Dale had given Randy $35,000 (about $375,000 today)—and Bill had given him $100.000 (over $1 million)—all unbeknownst to Will, and he becomes very angry.  He suffers a heart attack and his doctor is summoned. 

Eventually Will insists to Lily Dale that “there was a Bill I knew and a Bill you knew and that’s the only Bill I care to know about.”  The thrust of Foote’s play is the question, ‘What is truth?’  Is it what Will believes?  What Lily Dale believes?  What Randy says?  What Carson says?  The two young men accuse each other of being notorious liars.  Who was Bill really?  He was unathletic, despite his father’s efforts, and a math whizz who moved away from home and only worked menial jobs.  Who is Randy?  Who is Carson?  (Is he even actually Pete’s great-nephew?)

What was the relationship among the three young men from Atlanta?   There are broad hints—on which no one elaborates—that Bill and Randy, who’s 10 years younger than Bill, were gay and lovers.  A review of the 1995 premiĂšre of Young Man in The New York Times  pointed out: “This being 1950, nobody in the play mentions the word ‘gay,’ or refers even euphemistically to the truth of the relationship between Bill and Randy.”  Was Carson also in love with Bill and jealous of Randy?  We never know, and neither Will nor Lily Dale wants to find out.  As Will tells his wife, he refuses to meet with Randy because “there are things I’d have to ask him and I don’t want to know the answers.”

Threaded throughout the play is Lily Dale’s nearly obsessive quest to confirm the rumors she’d heard of a “Disappointment Club” in Houston during the war.  According to Lily Dale, the club was a conspiracy by Houston’s African-American domestic workers to disappoint their white employers by not showing up on the first day of work.  The rumors say that the clubs were started by none other than Eleanor Roosevelt because she hated Texas.  The apocryphal Disappointment Club is a metaphor for Foote’s theme.  As the New York Times’ Ben Branltey put it, there is a Disappointment Club “though not the kind that Lily Dale imagines.  Everyone in Foote’s plays is a dues-paying member of such a club.  Life according to Foote . . . has a way of letting down and stranding people, and it makes no exceptions.”

The performances in Signature’s revival of The Young Man from Atlanta were all right, but not as good as most I see at Signature.  The only actor whose name I knew (or whom I recognized) was Aiden Quinn, who played Will, and he had line problems.  He even went up in the first scene and his partner had to bail him out!  Later, he bobbled a couple of lines.

Other members of the cast either seemed under-energized—Jonny Orsini even seemed to be playing at his character (Carson), rather than “playing” him (if that makes sense).  Some of the others were the opposite (such as Kristine Nielsen as Lily Dale)—chewing scenery.  The steadiest performances came from Stephen Payne, whose Pete Davenport managed to be both level-headed and reasonable while still suggesting his powers of discernment might be slipping; Harriett D. Foy as Clara, the Kidders supportive and indulgent housekeeper and cook and Lily Dale’s confidante; and Pat Bowie’s Etta Doris, an ancient and sweet-souled former household employee who drops by for a visit.

Director Michael Wilson isn’t a novice, and he’s done some nice Horton Footes before, including at the Signature where I enjoyed the work immensely—especially the monumental Orphans’ Home Cycle (the three-part, nine-play series of one-acts that told the story of Foote’s father’s family that impressed me a whole lot) and The Good Friends.  This production seemed slipshod.  The general softness of the character portrayals, either vague or noncommittal, has to be the responsibility of the director.  The whole production seemed to need tightening and tuning and Wilson seems not to have effected any.

I have to say that this lack of oversight extended to the scenic design of Jeff Cowie, too.  The first scene takes place in the office of Will Kidder, and it’s represented by some stand-alone furniture pieces and a large billboard for the Sunshine Southern Wholesale Grocery.  There are no walls, doors, or windows—and that’s fine.  But then the rest of the play is set in the living room of the Kidders elaborate new house. 

Now, Cowie’s living room set design is also workable—but his imaginary layout of the rest of the house is confounding.  Any time someone leaves the living room, I wondered where the hell he or she was going.  Where’s the front door?  The kitchen?  The Kidders’ bedroom?  It took me a couple of departures to realize that there’s a large interior courtyard outside the upstage wall—suggesting that the house is a sort of square donut.  What’s the point in devising a set plan that confuses the spectator?  It doesn’t help the plot to do that?  So why?  Just because you think it’s clever?

(I was not the only observer who was bothered by this.  Samuel L. Leiter of Theatre’s Leiter Side wrote:

Jeff Cowie’s set . . . provides an architecturally odd impression of the Kidders’ new home.  It’s placed against neutral black curtains at either side, with a substantial window in the upstage wall, beneath which runs a slightly raised platform, with doors up several steps at either side.

Characters enter and leave via the sides, as well as through the [two upstage] doors, even going out one door and entering through the other despite being separated by an exterior yard seen through the window.  At one point we even see two characters walking across the yard as they go from one room to another.  Whatever the explanation for this arrangement, it’s definitely distracting.)

Van Broughton Ramsey’s costumes and David Lander’s lighting are both effective without being assertive.  Dialect coach Shane Ann Younts did a good job keeping everyone sounding as if they come  from the same places—the Houstonians with their Texas twangs and the Atlantans with their Georgia drawls.  (Nielsen is outstanding in creating a vocal characterization—not just an accent, but a whole persona through her voice.  Lily Dale constantly calls Will “Daddy”—which is a little creepy, but that’s Foote’s doing—and Nielsen conjures up a whole world when she speaks that one word!)

As ROTters know by now, there are no longer the stats I used to cite from the website Show-Score, so I’ll get right down to the critical response to STC’s revival of The Young Man from Atlanta.  I’ve selected 15 published reviews from both the print and on-line press coverage. 

Only two dailies reviewed the production, the Times and the Wall Street Journal.  WSJ’s Terry Teachout described the STC production as “as good as it can possibly be” and asserted that it “makes clear the play’s surpassing excellence.”  Teachout characterized the play as “a study in disappointment,” noting all the tribulations that beset Will Kidder (who could be president of Foote’s Disappointment Club) at the height of America’s post-war prosperity.  The WSJ reviewer stated that theatergoers would “not [be] wrong to think” that Foote had written a well-made play, but pointed out that the playwright’s “interest, rather, is in people like Will.” 

The review-writer explained that “the whole point of Mr. Foote’s story is in the telling.  He is, like Thornton Wilder before him, a playwright who believes devoutly in the significance of “the smallest events in our daily life.”  Director Wilson “creates the uncanny illusion that we are not seeing a play performed but watching life unfold before our eyes,” for which Teachout also credited the cast and design team “who make every moment in ‘The Young Man From Atlanta’ seem natural and believable.”  He singled out Aiden Quinn whose performance “is so true to life as to make disbelief impossible:  You’ve known him, and even if you haven’t, you’ll still feel as if you have.”

In the New York Times, Ben Brantley dubbed the production “an affectionate, slow and steady revival” of Foote’s play and calls the playwright “one of the theater’s great chroniclers of dispossession and denial.”  Brantley asserted, “By rights, [Foote’s] worldview should be deeply depressing.  But the work of Foote is usually as funny as it [is] sad.”  (Somehow, I didn’t find Young Man so.  I found it aligned more with Brantley’s next statement.)  “Superficially, his sturdily built, naturalistic plays are soothingly old fashioned,” the Timesman noted. “Yet the perspective that infuses them is as bleak as anything from those greatest of theatrical modernists, Beckett and Chekhov.”  (A somewhat hyperbolic comparison, I think.) 

Brantley made an analogy many of his colleagues also made: “As embodied with affecting understatement by Quinn, this Will emerges as a spiritual cousin to Willy Loman” of Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman.  (Like Brantley’s comparisons of Foote to Beckett and Chekhov, this match-up is a little overstated as Will Kidder lacks the depth and poetry of Loman.)  In the first half of the play, Brantley reported, “the show is engaging but not enthralling” as Wilson has his cast “bank their fires”; then “the reticence pays off” in the second half. 

Joe Westerfield labeled STC’s Young Man “a touching and funny revival” in Newsweek, giving the lie to the bromide “The truth will set you free.”  Westfield made another comparison with a world-class writer: the Kidders, he said, “are in such denial about so many things that with more of a taste for rotgut whiskey or morphine, they could easily fit into one of Eugene O’Neill’s later plays.”  (He also makes the connection between Will Kidder and Willy Loman.)  The Newsweek writer found, “The ensemble cast is uniformly excellent” and singled out Quinn (who “has morphed from a romantic lead into a solid character actor”) and Nielsen (who “show[s] a tender, vulnerable side to a character who could, in lesser hands seem just vapid” and “is also funny.”  Westerfield concluded by reporting that “Young Man From Atlanta shows Foote at the top of his game.”

“Even the most fervent Horton Foote fan might be hard-pressed to explain the appeal, much less the Pulitzer Prize, of The Young Man From Atlanta,” contemplated Time Out New York’s Melissa Rose Bernardo in the opening of her notice.  “The playwright was renowned for his delicate, layered storytelling, but this 1995 drama lays it on thick.”  Bernardo characterized the STC revival as “an often shaky piece” and noted that actor Stephen Payne as Pete Davenport “looks uncomfortable in even his best moments.”  Director Wilson “at least gives this head-scratcher of a play a handsome production at the Signature, with a couple of inspired touches.” 

Constance Rodgers wrote on New York Theatre Guide that Signature’s Young Man from Atlanta “is lovingly brought to life again” and “immerses us in the quietly desperate lives of Will and Lily Dale Kidder” “with respectful humor” by Wilson’s directing.  “[I]ngeniously written,” Young Man “is old fashioned in style and characterization and that is perfect.”  Quinn and Nielsen “are touching and hilarious” and the STC revival makes a “wonderful evening of old fashioned theater that does not feel old fashioned, just honest and funny.”

On Theatre’s Leiter Side, after a long preamble, Samuel L. Leiter complains that “it’s hard to see from this production [of The Young Man from Atlanta] what might have inspired its receipt of a Pulitzer Prize.”  Leiter went on to explain, “Enjoyable as some of it is, the writing is unmistakably old-fashioned, melodramatic, even, dependent on lengthy, over-obvious exposition, and burdened by an unsatisfying, almost perfunctory resolution.”  The TLS blogger added that “the production often suffers from overacting” and, as I pointed out earlier, Leiter found that the “scene design . . . serves more to confuse than to illuminate the topography of the dramatic locale.” 

Leiter felt that “the play fails to coalesce convincingly” and while the “secondary roles are all decently played,” Quinn “is uneven, ranging from superficially anguished to artificially blustery” and Nielsen “has fewer convincing moments, being unable to meld her familiar flibbertigibbet mannerisms with a realistic portrait of Lily Dale that goes beyond making her a perpetual airhead”; Payne as Pete “is simply colorless.”  Leiter ends by lamenting, “Given the Signature’s devotion to Horton Foote . . . it’s disappointing to see a less-than-superior production of his sole Pulitzer-winning work.” 

“Questions of mortality and regret hover over this sturdy revival” of The Young Man from Atlanta, wrote Zachary Stewart on TheaterMania.  “For all its flaws,” continued Stewart, “it still presents a compelling portrait of the willful ignorance that is a prerequisite for the American dream.”  With a cast the TM reviewer lauded, Stewart reported, “Michael Wilson directs a solid production undergirded by smart design.”  Despite this, however, Young Man “feels like a low-stakes affair.” 

Theater News Online isn’t a site I usually consult, but I spotted that its review of The Young Man from Atlanta was by a sort of old friend from whom I haven’t heard in quite a while: Joe Dziemianowicz, who used to review for the New York Daily News (which seems to have ceased covering theater).  So I decided to include Dziemianowicz’s short notice in my round-up.  He characterized STC’s Young Man as “a starry but unpersuasive revival” as it “leaves you wanting—and wondering.”  Dziemianowicz asserted that “the saga clunks along more than it clicks,” adding that “Foote’s folksy plainspokenness tolls, and the quietly eloquent grace notes that tug you in are scarce.”  He blames Wilson’s “stiff and at times unwieldy staging.”  The TNO reviewer summed up his opinion by observing, “Amid confessions and accusations out of left field, the play finally gets traction as Will and Lily Dale must make concessions and confront hard realities.”  In the end, he concluded that “one grows weary waiting for the late-blooming ‘Young Man’ to grow up into something satisfying.”

On CurtainUp, Deirdre Donovan warned that Wilson’s Young Man “might not be a mood-elevator,” but Quinn “imbues his character with a Texan-size ego and the vulnerability of an aging man who has lost his only son” and Nielsen “is fine as the spoiled wife, mother, and lapsed artist . . . who’s struggling to survive an unspeakable tragedy.”  Cowie’s set with Lander’s lighting “mirrors the dreams and disappointments of the Kidders” while Ramsey’s “costumes bring out the personality of each character.”  The production “can make you marvel at the resilience of the human spirit,” concluded Donovan, as it “illuminates the inner turmoil of a middle-class American family.”

Darryl Reilly of TheaterScene.net labeled Young Man a “wrenching . . . family secrets drama” and described the STC staging as “a tender revival.”  Reilly also invoked Death of a Salesman, but asserted “with his idiosyncratic and powerful command of dramatic writing [Foote] creates a distinctive narrative.”  The TS.net reviewer reported that “Wilson’s staging utilizes the accomplished technical elements to optimum effect” and scene designer Cowie’s “inspired efforts are integral to the production’s success.”  Reilley also lauded Lander’s “shadowy lighting,” John Gromada’s “jaunty and moody” original music and his “deft” sound design, and costume designer Ramsey’s “varied creations.”  He concluded, “Horton Foote and The Young Man from Atlanta’s stature is affirmed by this luminous incarnation.”

Fern Siegel on TheaterScene.com (not the same as the site above) explained that in The Young Man from Atlanta “Foote explores the dark side of the American Dream, as well as the lies we tell ourselves in order to survive.”  Siegel reported that “Quinn plays Will . . . with brutal honesty” but “Nielsen . . . utilizes the same facial tics in all her roles to indicate disbelief or confusion.  It may be humorous the first time, but it wears thin.”  The TS.com reviewer added, “The ensemble cast is sound, and Michael Wilson’s direction is smooth.”  She feels that  “Foote is a subtle, understated playwright not known for his poetic dialogue,” concluding, however, that “he is adept at capturing ordinary people facing difficult moments with authenticity.”

On Theater Pizzazz, Carol Rocamora labeled Young Man a “deeply moving play about loss” that “provides joys and sorrows that remind us, again, of Chekhov’s plays, with their continuity of location and thematic content.”  It is a “gentle, heartwarming, heartbreaking play,” she said, which Wilson has directed with “sure and steady hands.”

“‘The Young Man from Atlanta’ . . . is the wrong play by Horton Foote to revive,” declared Jonathan Mandell in the very first sentence of his New York Theater review.  He found it “dated, and overrated” and filled with many “scenes that feel slow-moving and tangential.”  Mandell’s major complaint about Young Man is that not only are the characters keeping any mention of homosexuality off the stage, but so does Foote, who even employs “a hoary plot line for a drama that was first produced some 30 years after Stonewall”: the suicide of a closeted gay man.  For the New York Theater reviewer, this made The Young Man from Atlanta less worthy of revival than many other Foote plays. 

On New York Stage Review, Jesse Oxfeld started off making a similar complaint: Bill Kidder was gay, a “thing never said, and barely even hinted at,” and the review-writer found “in 2019, . . . that feels awfully old-fashioned.”  Oxfeld believes that the story Foote should be telling is the one about Will Kidder and his reversal of fortune and how he contends with that.  Instead, the play’s

hung up on the question of Bill’s death, whether we should believe the stories told by his unseen roommate, that young man . . ., or whether we should instead believe the distant relative who shows up from [Atlanta], claiming that the roommate’s stories are all lies.  And that’s much less interesting, because we’re not really invested in any of those young men, who all seem to be ciphers.

(I would point out to Oxfeld that it’s not Randy, the roommate, and Carson, the Atlanta relative, in whom we’re supposed to be “invested.”  It’s Will and Lily Dale.  It’s not the story-tellers who are our—and I believe Foote’s—focus, but the way the competing stories affect the listeners and how they respond.  After that, the success of the play becomes a question of how well Foote and Wilson accomplish that drama.)

Oxfeld reported that Wilson “presents a solid, straightforward production” and that the “performances are equally solid and straightforward.”  He praised Ramsey’s costumes (“appropriately, straightforwardly, midcentury Texan”) and Cowie’s set (“elegant, high-1950s”).  The NYSR writer noted in the end, “We never really learn what happened between the younger men, who is lying and who is telling the truth,” and remarked, “That may be how things were in Houston in the 1950s.  But on stage today, it doesn’t make for much drama.”

Despite a “uniformly strong” cast, James Wilson of Talkin’ Broadway felt, “The Young Man from Atlanta feels somewhat mechanical.”  Wilson found, “The exposition is a bit heavy handed, and the appearance of particular characters (including a former maid, portrayed by the excellent Pat Bowie, as well as the arrival of an acquaintance of Bill and Randy) rings as rather too coincidental.”  The TB reviewer thought the production is “up to Signature's usual high standards,” remarking that “Jeff Cowie’s set design is appropriately sterile and museum-like (but with a central courtyard, it is somewhat confusing in the layout of the off-stage rooms).  Van Broughton Ramsey’s costumes are period and class specific, and David Lander’s sunny lighting contrasts with the dark truths the characters wish to keep hidden.”  Wilson praised all the cast members and concluded that The Young Man from Atlanta  “may not pack the wallop it did twenty-five years ago, but [it] offers a potent view of the United States on the cusp of social and political change.”

Because of the unstated (yet central) theme of homosexuality in America in the middle of the last century, I want to present one additional review, one that comes from a gay perspective.  In Cultural Weekly, a free on-line platform for independent voices, David Sheward, the former executive editor and theater critic for Back Stage, the theater trade paper, observed that Young Man “reflects the attitude towards gays of the era of its setting (Houston in 1950).”  Sheward pointed out, “The queer figures are not even on stage, one of them has committed suicide, and they are only important in how they affect straight people.”  Sheward laid out the details of this unspoken theme:

The main struggle is that of bragging businessman Will Kidder (bluff but vulnerable Aidan Quinn) and his flighty, sweet wife Lily Dale (simultaneously tragic and comic Kristin Nielsen).  Several months after the mysterious death of their only son Bill, they are confronted by the unwelcome visit of the title character, Randy, Bill’s much younger roommate.  Will does not want to see Randy, but Lily Dale craves his company as a reminder of her child.  While the word gay, queer or homosexual is never even spoken and Randy remains offstage, it’s clear he and Bill were in a relationship and neither parent can face the truth.  This unmentionable secret is but one of many problems confronting the Kidders.

The CW writer reported, “The play has some clunky structural problems. The first scene is all exposition,” he complained, and Carson’s arrival and the fact that he conveniently lived in the same boarding house as Bill and Randy, seems contrived.  But “the production overcomes the script’s flaws,” Sheward acknowledged.  “Young Man honestly examines American middle-class mor[e]s of equating wealth with happiness and unflinchingly rips away the prosperous facade of the couple’s elegant existence as they must confront economic and emotional reality.”  Wilson “delivers a heartfelt, straightforward staging,” asserted Sheward, “with an impeccable and moving cast capturing the quiet desperation of Foote’s lonely family, detached from their gay son.” 

02 September 2011

Competitive Art


I’ve hinted in the past that I don’t think much of awards and prizes in the arts, including the Tonys, the Oscars, the Emmys, and even the Pulitzers—as well as the scores of other awards for music, writing, dance, or aesthetic basket-weaving (see “Tony Committee to Theater Journalists: ‘Yer Out!’” ROT, 17 August 2009). 

I’ve never articulated my reasons for this disdain except privately to a couple of friends, especially around award times when the big galas are on TV and everyone else I know is watching them. I’ve decided it’s time to try to explain my position. Let’s see if I can.

First of all, let me clear up one confusion that’s come up a few times when the Tonys or the Oscars come on TV and friends ask if I’ll be watching and I tell them I won’t be. “Oh, yes,” some of them reply, “you don’t approve of them.” 

Well, yes—as you’ll see, I hope—but that’s not really why I don’t watch the shows. The very simple reason for that is that I find them awful and boring as TV fare. They’re overlong, the speeches and appearances are dull, the humility is mostly artificial, and I’ve seldom seen most of the performances being “honored.” 

That leaves only the entertainment the award show’s producers have interspersed in the parched desert that fills the rest of the hours, the patter of the host and the presenters and the scenes and musical numbers from the nominated productions. As for the former, the attempted levity of the MC’s and their cohorts . . . well, it’s seldom all that good: most of it’s inside jokes and industry banter—and occasionally the host really lays an egg. 

(I made the mistake of making an exception to my own practice several years ago to watch the Academy Awards the night Dave Letterman hosted in 1995. I’m a fan and I wanted to see what he’d do with the gig. Man, was that a bad call. Even he acknowledges he was lousy. And does anyone remember Rob Lowe’s auspicious appearance in ’89. Can you say “Snow White”?) 

So it’s not because I disapprove that I don’t watch the award shows—it’s simply because I don’t like them. (If I thought the broadcasts were any good, I might be conflicted about watching them because of the way I feel about performance awards, but as it is, that’s irrelevant.)

Second, I should admit to being something of a hypocrite when it comes to art awards. I do disparage them and on the few occasions when I’ve been eligible to participate (I can vote for the SAG Awards and I’ve been qualified to vote for the Regional Tony and some ATCA playwriting awards in the past), I haven’t done so because I don’t like the idea of awards in artistic fields. 

(In the interest of full disclosure, I should also acknowledge that for several years, my late father was a voter on the Helen Hayes Awards panel in Washington, D.C., and I never remonstrated with him.) Yet I cite the awards when I write about actors, directors, or productions that have won or been nominated for them. I even made an argument opposing the Tony committee’s elimination of theater journalists from the voter list for that theater award (in the 2009 ROT article I referenced earlier).

The problem seems to be that though I don’t put store in such awards, I know that other people do, so when I name an artist or an artwork, I mention awards they’ve won, but I feel awkward doing that. Still, I do it.

Finally, I make distinctions among awards, and that may be a little hypocritical, too. For instance, I don’t object to recognition for sales or popularity, like best-seller designations because that’s based on book sales and not a judgment of quality. It’s also theoretically objective—one book sells more than another. I have the same feeling about gold and platinum records in the music business—again, because it’s based on sales. 

I think the People’s Choice Awards are silly, but I don’t really object to them because they’re based on a straightforward popularity contest, not a presumptive quality evaluation. I also don’t have the same problem with halls of fame as I do with awards for superiority. (I have also been eligible to vote for candidates for the Theatre Hall of Fame, though I don’t—but that’s because I just don’t feel qualified to judge.) 

Halls of fame seem different to me because they honor artists for a lifetime or career of contributions to their fields, which seems like a sufficiently substantial basis for some kind of judgment. Also, voting one artist into a hall of fame one year doesn’t preclude that another artist who’d been passed over won’t be honored in another year; if someone doesn’t get an Oscar for a particular performance or a Pulitzer for a specific book or play, it’s finite—that work won’t get a second consideration.

Okay, let’s get to the heart of my problem—and I admit it’s my problem and I’m in a minority here. I object to awards in the arts for two main reasons: they’re a terribly subjective call and I feel they demean the arts they purport to celebrate. Here’s what I mean:

I guess the subjectivity issue is straightforward. If a runner beats everyone else’s times, he’s the champ, right? That’s clear. It’s objectively measured. If a soccer team scores more goals than its opponent, it wins the match. No question, right? If a tennis player accumulates more victories than any other on the tour, she’s number one in the sport. That’s self-evident. 

But how do you really adjudge one performance better than another or one movie or play better than the next? It’s a personal and individual response. I’m sure many of the Oscar or Tony judges can come up with justifications, citing all kinds of film-study or performance-study explanations for why they decided the way they did, but many others will just tell you they like one better than the others—and I submit that all arts-awards judges really go with a gut feeling. 

(I’m not going to get into the potential for professional politics in these contexts. It makes the whole process way too complicated even to discuss cogently.) 

I can’t even imagine what someone’s criteria would be for making such a judgment. Look what some people use for their evaluative basis: I took a group of high school theater students to a play competition one year. (It was part of my job and I wasn’t about to impose my private objections on the students for whom participation was a valued tradition.) 

One entrant was a student-directed staging of a Chekhov one-act. The production didn’t win its category and after the awards were announced, the judges held a critique for the participants. I was appalled when one judge objected to a line in the text that included a phrase which the judge felt sounded too contemporary. 

First of all, the student director, a senior who was a serious theater student, hadn’t translated the script; she was using a published English rendition, so she wasn’t responsible for the text. Second, I had brought along a Russian edition of the play (just to share with the director), and I found that the original words were exactly the same as the English. The translation wasn’t even inaccurate! 

I was aghast: this was what the judge found to object to in the production? (I did point this out, but the prizes had already been awarded. I also wrote to the competition’s organizers, but nothing came of that, either.)

Now, granted, this was a high school theater competition, but I have no doubt that the big-league judges engage in identical inanities. We all know that after an awards ceremony, or even after the announcement of the nominees for an award, there’s a lot of moaning and groaning about what got left out, overlooked, or misjudged. No arts award goes without some second-guessing or caviling among the disappointed. 

Of course, it’s subjective. Art is subjective. If there were ever such a thing as objective art, it would almost certainly be boring. Art succeeds because it is personal: it comes from a personal place in the artist and it speaks to something personal in the consumer. 

Susanne Langer, the art philosopher (see “Susanne Langer: Art, Beauty, & Theater,” parts 1 & 2, ROT, 4 & 8 January 2010), wrote succinctly, “Art is the creation of forms symbolic of human feeling.” Feeling, by definition, is subjective; you can’t rationalize feeling. Art, said Langer, “clarifies and organizes intuition” and therefore “elicits no conscious intellectual work (reasoning).” Art functions outside of reason: it’s not irrational, but arational.

Just to be sure we understand this idea, and its application to art competitions, Langer got specific:

Works of art are not usually comparable. Only prize-juries have to evaluate them with reference to some standard, which is inevitably arbitrary and in many cases inapplicable. A competent jury does not even define a standard. If it consists of people who have developed their powers of perception by long conversance with the order of art . . . in which their judgments are to be made, intuition will guide the verdict. There will be disagreements—not because good and bad works cannot be distinguished, but because among successful ones there is no sure principle of selection. Personal or social factors usually tip the balances; ‘ratings’ are trivial.

“Personal or social factors” are in evidence all the time. We can see in any given awards competition how sentiment for or against an artist affects the vote. We hear people say, “It’s her turn” or “He lost last year so he’ll probably get it this year in compensation.” 

If an artist has offended the community (or, more directly, “the academy”), the work might be overlooked not for its lack of quality, but because the voters were miffed. Industry bias, such as the film academy’s putative leaning toward box-office hits rather than innovative, difficult work or its apparent preference for dramas over comedies are part of the equation. (The drama Pulitzer has only been awarded to eight musical plays in the nine decades since the prize was inaugurated—a period that spans the golden age of the American musical theater.) 

Politics can also come into play, both the internal or artistic kind and the actual kind. Say, if it were possible, a dramatist composed the best play ever written—but its theme was pro-Nazi. You know it would never win any award. (Hell, it probably wouldn’t even get staged!)

A work of art, by Langer’s estimation (and mine), can’t be judged in comparison with another with any claim to legitimacy. Furthermore, we know from experience that even individual taste changes over time. A work of art you liked ten years ago might seem silly and superficial today. Collective taste changes, too. 

Consider the well-known case of Vincent van Gogh, today acknowledged as one of the greatest painters of all time, who sold only one painting in his lifetime—and that was to his brother! Actors as respected as Richard Burton, Peter O’Toole, Maureen O’Hara, and Gena Rowlands have never won Oscars; Charlie Chaplin, Alfred Hitchcock, Robert Altman, and Sidney Lumet have never won for directing some of our best movies; dramatists Lillian Hellman, S. N. Behrman, and Philip Barry never won Pulitzers (neither did novelists F. Scott Fitzgerald or Truman Capote). 

Now look at a list of past Oscar-, Tony-, or Pulitzer-winning movies, books, and plays. How many are almost an embarrassment by today’s standards? If we had it to do over again, we might select a different work to recognize. (And then, we might change our opinions again ten years from now.) On this basis, people declare one work or one artist the best of the year? It doesn’t work for me.

The assertion that such competitions demean the art itself is a little harder to put into words. It’s a pretty subjective statement itself, isn’t it? Okay, I’m writing about my own opinions here, not some universal sense I think is shared by a large majority, so subjectivity is the matrix in which I’m operating. 

I object, even resent, art being turned into a competitive effort like sports or hot-dog eating. Now, I don’t think artists, particularly playwrights, consciously compete with their peers for awards and prizes—they’re too busy making art. (I have no doubt that there are producers, both in Hollywood and on Broadway, who have one eye on Oscars and Tonys when they set out to put together a production—and there may be an actor or two who see statuettes in their futures when they read scripts.) 

I subscribe to Ralph Waldo Emerson’s sentiment, expressed in his essay “Art,” that “every genuine work of art has as much reason for being as the earth and the sun.” A work of art, whether it’s a painting, a poem, or a performance, should be its own justification, its own raison d’ĂȘtre; it shouldn’t depend on some outside recognition for validation.

As Langer said, art’s function is to raise feelings in the spectator—that should be the only evaluation needed. Either the art affects me, makes me feel something that wasn’t there before or understand something in a new way, or it doesn’t. If it’s a great work of art, it will have that effect on more people who experience it (each in his or her own way, of course), and it will continue to have an effect—though the effect may shift—over time. 

That’s what defines a classic artwork, like Hamlet, the Mona Lisa, Oliver Twist, or Citizen Kane. Shakespeare, Da Vinci, and Dickens all created quite nicely, thank you, without prizes and awards. (So did Welles, really, though he was working in the era of the Oscar, New York Film Critics Award, DGA Award, WGA Award, and Golden Globes. He was passed over for most of his work anyway.) 

Of course a work’s reception is important to an artist; despite what some artists say, few really create just for themselves. And I also recognize that grants and commissions, which go back to the days of Shakespeare, Michelangelo, and Da Vinci, are significant in an artist’s creative life—and they are a form of competition, I acknowledge. My argument is fraught with contradictions, I know. But singling out one work for recognition the way an award does, or one artist, as even the famous MacArthur genius grants do, disturbs me.

I know that some competition is always going to be part of the arts, just as it is in all human endeavors. We are a competitive species. There are limited resources and venues, so artists will always have to vie for access. Someone’s going to get the commission or the exhibit and someone else isn’t. And I’m sure that in some cases, whoever controls the desired asset deliberately sets the assignment up as a competition, but even that’s not quite the same as turning the creation of art into a race for recognition the way a prize does. 

It just seems unseemly to me. Artists should be concerned with the best work they can do, comparing their new work with their past accomplishments if they have to try to better something; they shouldn’t feel they have to outdo other artists. Yes, consumers and critics will inevitably compare one artist and one artwork with another—but the artists shouldn’t have to do that.

I think it’s also an element of my distaste for art awards and prizes that there are so many of them. The music business, for instance, seems to have awards for every song and musician the industry can define—which may explain why the Grammys have recently consolidated several categories. 

(Musicians in the fields that were eliminated are complaining about the action, perhaps because it’s gotten so that all artists feel that they deserve some kind of award of their very own.) 

It’s getting to be like some children’s activities where every participant gets recognition so no one feels left out. Is that what we’ve developed: a culture where artists are childish and infantile? If I don’t get a prize, I’ll hold my breath until I turn blue?

Some of the organizations which give out the awards seem gratuitous as well. The so-called Foreign Press Association, who presents the Golden Globes, doesn’t have any function except giving out the award, I don’t believe. And essentially, the award itself seems to be little more than an excuse to stage a TV extravaganza. 

On top of all the different Grammys, for example, what’s the need for the MTV Video Music Awards as well? Since MTV’s a cable TV network (which, umm, airs music videos!), I’m left to assume that its purpose is to, first, promote the network and, second, justify a big broadcast they hope will draw substantial ratings. (Do we need awards for advertisements or porn? Really?)

That most of the big awards are more about selling tickets, records, or books (or, in the case of TV, more ads) was, I think, exposed when the Tonys eliminated reviewers from the voting pool. (Journalists haven’t been part of the voting pools for most of the other major performance awards—though I’m not certain about the Grammys.) 

Of all the interested parties, the journalists were the least invested in the outcome: they didn’t stand to make more money or get better jobs if a show they liked won an award. Everyone else, all industry insiders, has skin in the game, to a greater or lesser degree (even if it’s only to scuttle a rival’s prestige), but the journalists also had an occasional tendency to vote for artier little plays that caught their fancies instead of the big commercial hits the producers want to promote for long Broadway runs and later lucrative tours. 

In other words, the reviewers voted for the art while the others are focused on the commerce. Now the award won’t stand in the way of recognizing the money-making crowd-pleaser rather than the innovator that might attract a smaller audience.

I have no idea if any of the award shows actually does draw a large audience, but that seems to me to be their major rationale—especially when they get more and more elaborate each year or make rules aimed at selecting more popular nominees. Doesn’t that give the game away? Particularly when it turns out that those additional crowd-pleasers aren’t really expected to win anything. 

In marketing, those are called loss leaders—and their sole use is to sell other stuff. That seems to be the intention: marketing, sales, promotion—not honoring artistic achievement. In fact, as far as I can see, even the major awards like the Oscars and the Tonys have only one benefit: they sell tickets. I suppose artists who win one get to feel good about their work, but beyond that, they’re an advertising gimmick to help put asses in seats. That may be the art of the deal, but it’s not art.