Showing posts with label Washington Square Players. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Washington Square Players. Show all posts

24 June 2012

The Washington Square Players: Art for Art’s Sake (Part 2)


[I covered a lot of the background of the formation of the Washington Square Players in part one of this article, outlining the rise of the bohemian scene in 19th- and early-20th-century Greenwich Village and describing the prevailing commercial theater in New York City in the years just before World War I. I’ll start here with a brief discussion of the troupe’s financial organization and move on to my analysis of the artistic aspects of the historic troupe.]

In order to be as independent as possible from the forces of politics, the Washington Square Players proposed to support themselves entirely from ticket sales and, in the first such scheme in the United States, subscriptions. The company started life with but a few hundred dollars in its coffers, contributed mostly by Langner and others of the wealthier supporters, and produced its first bill of one-acts at a cost of $35. In July 1916, Walter Prichard Eaton declared in American Magazine that “The Washington Square Theatre started in poverty, and it is comparatively poor yet—thank heaven. We hope it always will be. Then the workers in it will always be its lovers. We don’t want them to work for nothing; but better for nothing than for great riches.” By 1917, though, WSP was able to pay Theodore Dreiser a $200 advance for The Girl in the Coffin. The production was a huge success—the cast received 18 curtain calls and the audience yelled for the author, though Dreiser had been too shy even to attend the performance—and took in $300 over a six-week run. Low budgets, though a challenge, were seldom a hindrance, however. In fact, they sometimes inspired Lee Simonson to find innovative solutions to design problems using lighting, projections, and formal set pieces. Simonson’s set for Pierre Patelin (1916), one of the first uses in America of “permanent portals and an inner proscenium” enhanced by a backdrop in the “flat colour masses” common to contemporary European posters, illustrated this phenomenon.

Many theatre troupes of the day had clear biases of various kinds: The Neighborhood Playhouse directed its appeal to the East and Central European and Jewish residents of its Lower East Side home, consequently its repertoire was exclusively European; the Provincetown Players were oriented toward American plays and playwrights, and until 1924 produced exclusively contemporary American plays; and the Group Theatre of the 1930s was avidly leftist politically. The Players’ Manifesto, however, placed few restrictions on their repertoire except those of taste. The company’s original announcement succinctly stated that their only criterion would be “sincere, truthful and effective” writing. They hoped to provide a stage for American writers, but they also had a strong interest in European experimental drama which incensed some, including George Cram Cook who felt the Players were not giving native authors enough of a chance. The Provincetown Players, which Cook later founded, focused on the development of playwrights and thus expressly remained a small group, while the Washington Square Players concentrated on the advancement of production quality and so deliberately and rapidly expanded. The Provincetown, according to Lawrence Langner,

was always a more personal expression of the authors behind it than was our group, with the result that it tended to develop its authors rather than its audience . . . . It was frankly experimental as to plays while the Washington Square Players were attempting to present productions which would be in healthy competition with the plays of Broadway. The Washington Square group fought the issue of the art theatre versus the commercial theatre; it sought to produce its plays at the Comedy Theatre [on Broadway] in competition with commercial attractions . . . .

Max Eastman, however, admonished WSP to forget “the box-office and adhere to pure standards of art” by presenting non-commercial plays and plays ignored by the commercial producers. As Hannah White put it, “‘Art for art’s sake’ has been quoted as the slogan of the Washington Square Players.”

In fact, almost from the very beginning WSP bearded the Broadway lion in its own den. Unlike the other art and independent theatres of its time, the Players rented legitimate theatres and actively sought press coverage. Within weeks of that impromptu performance at the Bonis’ bookshop, the Players rented the Bandbox Theatre on East Fifty-seventh Street, assuming the lease of a German composer-impresario who had nearly gone bankrupt presenting his own musical comedies. Goodman, as director of the company, and business manager Langner sent out an announcement to prospective subscribers proclaiming the foundation of “an organization for those who cannot find response to their demands for quality of play and production in the usual New York playhouse.” The first bill of one-acts opened at the Bandbox on 19 February 1915 with four plays: Licensed by Basil Lawrence (Lawrence Langner’s nom-de-plume), Eugenically Speaking by Edward Goodman, Interior by Maurice Maeterlinck, and Another Interior, a satirical take on the symbolic Maeterlinck piece. They played weekends at first, but the demand for their innovative stagings of experimental, new works compelled them to perform four times a week. One critic, describing the fare as “$2 drama for fifty cents,” wrote, “If the Players can keep up their present pace they will make the Bandbox an institution.” By 1917 WSP had moved to the Comedy Theatre on West Thirty-eighth Street in the heart of the Broadway theatre district.

The group’s vaunted non-commercialism and fifty-cent admission charge—eventually raised to a dollar so they could pay their actors “a living wage”—may have attracted the audiences which bought out every performance of their first bill of one-acts, but it was their artistic appeal that filled their subsequent performances and elicited praise from many a jaded theatre critic. Hannah White, in The Independent, gave this appraisal:

Their capital was exactly nothing, their stock in trade boundless enthusiasm, indefatigable energy and a wide variety of talents . . . . They are all young and they are all idealists. They have convictions and they have the courage to carry them out. Their convention is unconventional and their motto is DARE!

If this sounds a bit hyperbolic, it may well be the result of the same numbing boredom on Broadway that spawned the groups themselves. An editor of Theatre Arts magazine remarked that

Their greatest service . . . lies in their proving that even New York has an audience for what is too fresh and sincere for the jaded commercial producer to recognize, and too strange to Broadway custom to find a way through other stage-doors . . . .

And audiences they did have. Other critics concurred with Hannah White’s estimation. Francis Hackett of The New Republic, for example, praised WSP for their “freshness and audacity that is expected to conquer the lethargic,” and “partly allures and partly intimidates the man who wants to see ‘a good play.’”

(Not everyone agreed. Babette Deutsch wrote in Touchstone: “They . . . will sacrifice a play to applause for its setting, and the excellence of a program to retaining their reputation for spicy productions.” In the New York Evening Post, a critic opined that “the appeal is distinctly to the ‘highbrow’ of revolutionary tendencies. That it will ever win an audience outside the spiritual frontiers of Greenwich Village is not probable . . . .”)

But exactly what was WSP producing that caused such reactions among critics and audiences? What were they doing that was so different from the commercial theatre with which they were so blatantly—and so successfully—competing? As already noted, they had no overt political bent, no exclusive American or contemporary orientation, no community loyalty.

Certainly the sets, in the “new stagecraft” developed in Europe by Adolphe Appia and Gordon Craig, “were unusual and arresting.” As Hannah White noted, the Players’ designers Robert Edmond Jones, Rollo Peters, and Lee Simonson created

artistic stage settings, daringly impressionistic . . . . Colors have been used as never before to register ideas. The audience gasps when the curtain goes up, but it applauds, too; and before a word is spoken the atmosphere of the play is established and the imagination of each spectator is in good working order.

Even Babette Deutsch, who generally disparaged the Players’ productions, lauded “their brilliant scenic effects, nearly always simple in line and unique in color arrangement . . . .” Elmer Rice was particularly taken with the work of Robert Edmond Jones, whose designs were “a sensational innovation in a theatre in which scene designing was little more than a branch of stage carpentry. The effect was revolutionary.” Both Jones and Simonson advocated sets that suggested reality without reproducing it, reducing the elements of the design to those that evoked, often through poetry and symbolism, the mood of the production or provided necessary information without eliminating the audience’s imagination. Furthermore, these advocates of the “new stagecraft” saw their art as an integral part of the production, enhancing the interpretation and aiding the dramatic action. The stage set was neither a beautiful picture—a work of art that stands alone—nor simply a background; it was an “environment”: “Players act in a setting,” wrote Jones, “not against it.”

Photographs of Players’ productions and descriptions of designs reveal a number of experimental techniques—though often crude and amateurish in execution, no doubt due to the small budgets. (As we’ve seen, their initial offering cost the Players only $35; some subsequent productions cost as little as $50 to mount.) A number of shows, such as Holland Hudson’s pantomime The Shepherd in the Distance, Maurice Maeterlinck’s Aglavaine and Selyzette and The Death of Tantagiles, and Nicholas Evreinov’s A Merry Death, made extensive use of curtains for walls, an innovation pioneered by Gordon Craig at the turn of the century. Another European practice WSP used was highly patterned wallpaper. Georg Fuchs’s Munich Art Theatre applied Craig’s technique in the early 1900s in “design” drops, as opposed to traditional “sky” drops, before which plays were performed on a shallow stage with a permanent, architectural setting. WSP also used a very shallow stage, but modified the pattern technique by using it as a thematic motif in a brightly colored set of basically realistic, if minimalist, silhouette. In the set of Edward Goodman’s Eugenically Speaking, for instance, a stylized apple motif was repeated in a wall frieze, door panels, a lamp shade, chair backs, and the edges of seats and table tops. Such motif repetition was frequent in Players’ set designs, sometimes showing up in door and window frames or moldings as well as upholstery and other decor elements.

The bright, often unnatural colors were a very common visual element. A vivid example is Lee Simonson’s design for Philip Moeller’s Sisters of Susanna. Actors in costumes of turquoise, emerald, and amethyst moved in an exotic, walled Moorish garden set in which “the walls are orange, almost coral; the lattice in the pavilion is purple and gold; the palms are black against a dense blue sky.” Strangely enough, starkly unrealistic sets alternated on the Players’ stage with essentially realistic and even naturalistic ones. Even these latter, however, were often modified by reducing the stage decoration and furniture to a bare minimum, though what was there was often perfectly realistic. (Necessity being the mother of invention, the lack of detail in these realistic sets may have been as much the result of economics as style.)

A less frequent design element was the influence of contemporary art in the decor. Lawrence Langner’s Another Way Out, designed by Joseph Platt, had a light-colored, stylized bedroom with a dark, abstract design reminiscent of Aubrey Beardsley on three door panels and thematically repeated in the painted sky-light, the bedspread, and a wall hanging. (The photographs examined, in the New York Public Library for the Performing Arts, were black and white. Without a corresponding description of this particular set it’s impossible to determine if the light and dark areas were in fact respectively white and black.)

These scenic innovations, though a curiosity, could hardly have accounted for the immense popularity of the Players’ bills, all of which were sold out in advance. Designer Lee Simonson, himself, acknowledged that he became associated with the Washington Square Players because they “were dedicated not to providing visually beautiful spectacles, but to propagating what seemed to be important ideas in terms of dramatic stories.” So, what were the Players’ audiences flocking to see? What made the company so engagingly different? For one thing, “the plays . . . were vital, full of meaning, or full of racy fun . . . .” Setting aside those that were simply “racy fun,” such as George Jay Smith’s adaptation of Forbidden Fruit, a restoration-style fillip, and Molière’s Sganarelle, as well as the few whose appeal was purely exotic or curious—mostly the pantomimes like the collaborative Another Interior (set inside the human digestive system through which Gastric Juice runs amok), J. Garcia Pimentel and Beatrice de Holthoir’s Yum Chapab (based on a Mayan legend), and the anonymous The Poisoned Flower (a Chinese legend)—even a cursory reading of the group’s plays makes immediately clear what the attraction was. (In November 1916, WSP produced Bushido by Takeda Izumo, but according to various reviews it was the presentation of the theme of loyalty, not the Japanese locale, that attracted audiences and critics. In an unusual move, WSP engaged Japanese dancer Michio Itow to direct the play.) They were human. Not just realistic, in the academic sense of that label, but human—human scale, human emotion, and human problems. Most of the material was serio-comic: the comedies had serious underpinnings, and the dramas did not eschew comic elements. This was certainly a refreshing change from what Elmer Rice called “the stale, predigested fare of the commercial theatre.”

From the beginning, the Washington Square Players selected their scripts by committee, with every member voicing an opinion on the choice and the casting. Following the success of their second bill of one-acts in March 1915, which included Moondown by John Reed and Two Blind Beggars and One Less Blind by Philip Moeller among other new plays, the company was flooded with scripts. With the luxury of such riches from which to choose, anything WSP produced had to be unanimously approved by the committee. Even early submissions by the young Eugene O’Neill, including Bound East for Cardiff, failed the test. In fact, the Washington Square Players did not present its first O’Neill play, In the Zone, until its fourth season in October 1917. They eventually also produced The Rope in their last bill in April 1918. The group also rejected Glaspell and Cook’s satire on Freudianism, Suppressed Desires, when it was first submitted in 1915. Though WSP eventually produced it in January 1918, the committee told Cook in 1915 that the play was “too special” for the company’s audience.

One play in particular, 24-year-old Edward Massey’s Plots and Playwrights, is, itself, a case study of what Walter Prichard Eaton described as the Players’ “scorn for the flabby, purposeless, and false plays then . . . in the theatre and their enthusiasm for what they considered a more honest art.” The conceit of the play, directed by Edward Flammer and designed by Clifford Pember, is laid out in the Epilogue. It concerns Caspar Gay, a successful Broadway playwright wandering West Eleventh Street in Greenwich Village looking for “an inspiration—comedy, tragedy, romance”—for his next play. He meets young short-story writer Joseph Hastings, played by Ralph L. Roeder, in front of Mrs. Purcell’s Lodging House, represented by a painted drop of a brownstone facade. Gay (Ralph Bunker), dressed as a “toff” in silk topper, wing collar, and silk vest, explains his desperation, and Hastings, more modestly attired in a dark overcoat and fedora, suggests that there is material all around them, in each house on the block. As an example, Hastings suggests that there is a play on every floor of the boarding house. But Gay demurs: “These people are nobodies. There is no drama in nobodies.”

The challenge is on; Hastings responds, “I’ll write a play to prove it.” He “ascends the stoop, and rings the bell, and rents a room.”

The rest of the play is divided into two parts. “The facade rises,” recorded the critic for the Dramatic Mirror, “and discloses rooms on three different floors.” In Part I, we see three small dramas in sequence, each using the same basic set, with nearly identical lay-out and props. In Scene I (“The Story on the First Floor”), Mrs. Hammond (Helen Westley) awaits her daughter, Molly, who is returning after having been away a long time. The mother is planning a pleasant dinner at home for them, but the girl (Florence Enright) arrives with Tom Burch (Charles H. Meredith), a vaudeville dancer. Molly has become Tom’s partner and plans to leave immediately to tour with him, and they are going out to celebrate. In the end, Mrs. Hammond is left alone with the dinner for two.

Scene II, “The Story on the Second Floor,” involves three young women. One is Alice Merriam (Katherine Cornell), a bookish art student who does not date; the second is Bessie Dodge (Ruby Cravin), a good-time girl who burns her candle at both ends. The third, Edmé Jackes (Alice Rodier), younger and innocent, has fallen in love with Frank Devoy (Arthur E. Hohl), a young dandy. Both Edmé’s friends try to convince her not to take Frank seriously, each for opposite reasons. In the end, Edmé follows her own inclination.

In “The Story on the Third Floor,” Dick Griffiths, a studious and intelligent young man (Philip Tonge), who wants to go to college, is prevented by his brother, Sidney (Robert Strange), who insists the young man join him in the hat shop he owns. Sidney is adamant, not seeing any value in hifalutin notions like college, and finally cows young Dick with physical threats. The scene ends inconclusively, but without much hope.

In Part II, the two writers meet at a restaurant represented again by a painted drop on which are depicted windows with light streaming down and three of the four tables; only the fourth table with its two chairs is real. Gay agrees that Hastings has written a play, but scoffs, “That sort of thing won’t go on Broadway.” He offers to “turn it into a big Broadway success.” Using the same apartment setting, after the restaurant drop is flown out, Gay rearranges the characters and plots into a melodrama in which two of the boarders collaborated in a theft and are suspected by the police. It is standard, contrived stuff, reminiscent of early Hollywood output, with tearful pleadings by the crooks’ girlfriends, suspected betrayals, various forms of duplicity—and even the improbable complication that Edmé, the girl on the second floor, turns out to be the illegitimate granddaughter of Mrs. Hammond, the mother on the first floor.

An exchange not in the published script, but reported in the New York Times review, shows clearly what WSP was after, and what they were competing against. Hastings reacts in disbelief to Gay’s creation, and Gay responds:

“But,” says the playwright serenely, “it will run a year on Broadway.”
“My God,” cries the enlightened novelist, “it has.”


Hastings’s small, intimate dramas were real and tender, even if their themes were not earth-shaking. They were human themes—filial insensitivity, trusting one’s own judgment, lack of communications between siblings—and charmingly, delicately presented. Gay’s output, on the other hand, is complex, contrived, improbable, and predictable. Hastings’s characters, while not types, were recognizable, people we might know; Gay’s were stock characters out of “ten-twenty-thirty” melodrama. There is little doubt that an audience hungering for “unusual pieces in an unpretentious and yet effective way” would respond positively to offerings such as Hastings’s.

The acting of the production was universally praised, particularly the work of long-time member Westley and newcomer Cornell; however, photographs of the production, though they were probably posed shots, indicate that the acting was not what we would call “realistic” today, but showed elements of the stylized gestures and postures of François Delsarte—the dominant acting style of the day which we recognize as silent-movie acting. (There’s no way to tell how staged the photographs were.) Even so, there were a few examples of remarkably natural behavior among the actors, particularly the three women in Apartment 2. Katherine Cornell is sitting stage right, leaning into a table with her hands clasped on it. She wears a truthful look of sincerity as she addresses Ruby Cravin who stands opposite her (stage left) with her upstage knee resting on a chair and her downstage hand on her hip. Alice Rodier stands upstage center in an attitude of listening, looking at Cornell, her curled hand resting on the table. Everyone looks natural and animate. By contrast, the performances in Part II seemed far more melodramatic and “stagy”—very likely with the objective of depicting the kind of acting, as well as the kind of theatre, prevalent on Broadway. Alice Rodier stands stiffly stage left of the table with a gun pointed at Arthur Hohl (downstage right), her left arm straight down at her side. Hohl is in a lunge, his right leg extended behind him and his right hand in a claw. He is leaning on the table with his left hand, his head thrust toward Rodier, in a very unnatural pose. The World, nonetheless, dubbed Plots and Playwrights “both in the writing and the acting, . . . to be in the Players’ best vein.”

The response would be all the more enthusiastic when the offerings treated topical and controversial themes. In Plots and Playwrights, Hastings’s dramas dealt with universal themes, but other Players’ material used significant contemporary matters as subjects, themes, or plot devices. George Cram Cook and Susan Glaspell’s Suppressed Desires was a comic look at the new—and rampantly indulged—Freudian psychoanalysis. (“You could not go out to buy a bun,” Glaspell once remarked, “without hearing of someone’s complex.”) Theodore Dreiser’s The Girl in the Coffin, inspired by “Big Bill” Hayward of the Industrial Workers of the World (the “Wobblies”), was set in Paterson, New Jersey, during the silkworkers’ strike, a cause célèbre of the labor activists at the time. Ardently pro-striker, it also touched on unwed motherhood and abortion and critiqued the mores of conventional society. Langner’s Licensed, the story of the death of a young man moments before his wedding to his pregnant fiancée, was a plea for birth-control, a new idea being preached openly for the first time by Margaret Sanger, a Village resident. Another Way Out, also by Langner, was based on his observations of the Village free-love cult; and Goodman’s Eugenically Speaking, voicing novel concepts on marriage, could be seen as a farcical comment on the Shavian idea of women’s liberation.

Grander themes with significance far beyond the Village and New York were also attempted on Players’ stages. Hervey White’s Fire and Water, produced in October 1915, concerned the brotherhood of man, “showing how French and German soldiers, between the lines, may be very good friends . . . .” It would be hard to imagine a more controversial idea at that particular time in history. Though America was still officially neutral regarding World War I, few here had any tender feelings for “The Hun.” In Children, by Guy Bolton and Tom Carlton, “a negro [sic] mother shoots her son dead rather than give him up to a lynching party.” It was intended to be a “sympathetic and clear-sighted psychological study of the Negro . . . .” Not only was the presence of black characters, other than servants and Stepin Fetchits, a breach of common practice, but a serious attempt to treat them with depth in terms of white prejudice would certainly have raised many an eyebrow. (If the characters had been performed by black actors, the production would indeed have been startling. There were no photographs of the cast, however, and the only names I recognized in the cast list were regular WSP members such as Ralph Roeder and Robert Strange, suggesting that the actors were white playing in blackface. An integrated company was apparently too far for even the liberal-minded Players to go in 1916.) The play was presented in March 1916—just fifty years after the Civil War, and at the height of Ku Klux Klan terrorism in the South.

Certainly not all of the Players’ efforts were successful critically. In early productions, their acting was “amateur, even at times fumbling,” and later, ambition led them to tackle material beyond their capabilities—mostly the full-length European plays by Chekhov, Ibsen, Maeterlinck, and Shaw. Still, the combination of new scenic art, serious subject matter—both subdued and controversial—and enthusiastic, albeit rough, performance techniques succeeded in making New York theatregoers sit up and take appreciative notice. The New York Tribune summed up the reaction this way:

If the American stage is ever to extend its exhibitions beyond the “tired business man” type of music show and the farces and melodramas which have been such money makers in the last couple of seasons, it will be by reason of the competition of such organizations as the Washington Square Players.

The Washington Square Players dissolved in 1918, primarily because the entry of the United States into World War I diverted the manpower of the company. In 1919, the company was reconstituted as the Theatre Guild by Langner, Moeller, Simonson, Westley, Maurice Wertheim, and Theresa Helburn, but between February 1915 and April 1918, a little over three years, the Players presented 72 plays, including six full-length, most of them new, untried, or overlooked works. They launched or enhanced the careers of young actors like Katherine Cornell, Helen Westley, Rollo Peters, Frank Conroy, and Roland Young, and designer Lee Simonson. But most importantly, WSP showed that sensitive productions of provocative works could attract audiences. Indeed, WSP had started—or at least given impetus to—a theatrical revolution that is still being felt today. Lawrence Langner concluded that

the Washington Square Players and . . . many others paved the way for a new professional theatre which was hospitable to works of art, and . . . were in the van of the revolution which changed the face of the American Theatre . . . .

In contrast with the prevalent competition, WSP was a brisk wind in a desert. “I believe the theatre as a cultural influence,” summed up Eugene O’Neill, “dates from the Washington Square Players in 1914 and the Provincetown Players in 1916. These two groups made it possible to present serious dramas.” The Players, believed O’Neill, helped introduce “culture into the pattern of the stage.” The alternative theatre the Players helped begin may very well have resuscitated a theatre in the throes of asphyxiation.

["The Washington Square Players Art for Art’s Sake” was awarded the 2004 National Amy & Eric Burger Prize for theater writing. A version of this article (with photos and source notes) was published in the 2005 edition of Theatre History Studies. I’ve also delivered a short version of the paper with slides at theater conferences.]

21 June 2012

The Washington Square Players: Art for Art’s Sake (Part 1)


[Though the Washington Square Players isn’t an unknown troupe and its record is documented both in general theater history books and the pages of the press of its day, it’s never achieved the prominence of either its sister theater, the Provincetown Players, or the producing organization that was its successor, the Theatre Guild. The history of WSP has never been compiled into one volume the way Helen Deutsch and Stella Hanau’s The Provincetown: A Story of the Theatre has done for that company or Lawrence Langner’s The Magic Curtain did for the Theatre Guild. A few capsule accounts of the company have appeared lately, such as the brief paragraph in The Cambridge Guide to American Theatre and a few other similar reference works, but in order to get a comprehensive examination (or even a superficial overview) of the Players’ history, readers would have to piece it together themselves from scattered accounts and brief mentions, mostly in biographies and autobiographies of the personalities involved, and articles and reviews in contemporaneous New York City newspapers and, especially, the theater press. Not only are these sources dispersed widely across diverse research categories (and collections), but many of the periodicals, little of whose pertinent coverage is indexed or listed in bibliographies, aren’t commonly available even in large university libraries. My article, posted on ROT in two parts, attempts to draw together these widely-spread and disparate references into a coherent narrative and, by situating this into the political, cultural, and artistic milieu, to look at the history and accomplishments of the Washington Square Players as an outgrowth of its own time and a harbinger of the future.

[In addition, I’ve examined WSP’s history and record with the critical eye of the theater reviewer and the analytical instinct of the dramaturg in an attempt not only to document what the company did, but to understand why they did it and what the impact of their work was on the emerging new American theater. Though a more-or-less comprehensive account of the Washington Square Players’ plays and personalities can be patched together from existing sources, if the reader has access to some of the more esoteric and obscure ones and is willing to dig out the scattered bits and pieces, the analytical and evaluative aspect of this investigation isn’t available anywhere in published form.]

In the years before the First World War, when the century was less than a dozen years old, an upheaval that would have cultural and artistic repercussions across the country was taking place in an obscure corner of New York City. The social, artistic, and political forces came together in what became known as the bohemian life in Greenwich Village. Intellectuals of all stripes came to work or live in this community, recorded lawyer and amateur New York City historian Edmund T. Delaney, its distinct character “somewhat richer than other parts of the city,” and influenced “American literature, art and thinking wholly out of proportion to their numbers.”

The influence, across the gamut of culture and ideas, was made by a motley group including proponents of atheism, socialism, cubism, anarchism, free-thought, free-love, birth-control—“and women who bobbed their hair and smoked cigarettes.” As socialist journalist John Reed described it:

Inglorious Miltons by the score,
And Rodins, one to every floor.
In short, those unknown men of genius
Who dwell in third-floor-rears gangrenous,
Reft of their rightful heritage
By a commercial, soulless age.
Unwept, I might add—and unsung,
Insolent, but entirely young.

To be sure, Villagers included “crackpots or phonies,” but many were sincere artists and thinkers and, according to W. A. Swanberg, biographer of Village resident Theodore Dreiser, “most were conscious rebels . . . [in] revolt against mildewed American concepts and properties . . . .” This side of Village life was summed up by author and radical editor Max Eastman, in the words of his biographer William L. O’Neill, in what he dubbed the Innocent Rebellion:

All that was self-consciously new in American culture—the “new women,” the “new morality,” the “new art”—could be found there. On one level Greenwich Village was becoming a showcase of the cultural revolution, on another it led the movement, serving as headquarters to . . . the Innocent Rebellion.

All this creative activity set the stage for an influx of artists “ready to espouse all the new causes—individual freedom, free love, socialism, avant garde literature and futuristic painting.” Helen Deutsch and Stella Hanau, the historians of the Provincetown Players, pointed out that “with so many arts represented, drama was the natural meeting-ground, the inevitable medium of expression.” Much of what was exciting and new in European culture was allied to the theatre: the new playwriting of the likes of William Butler Yeats, Gabriele D’Annunzio, Harley Granville-Barker, James M. Barrie, George Bernard Shaw, Maurice Maeterlinck, Georges de Porto-Riche, and Paul Claudel; the “new stagecraft” of Adolphe Appia and Gordon Craig; innovative productions by directors like William Poel, André Antoine, Max Reinhardt, Alexander Tairov, Leopold Sulerzhitsky, Aurélien-Marie Lugné-Poë, and Jacques Copeau; and art theatres like Dublin’s Abbey Theatre, the Munich Art Theatre, the Moscow Art Theatre, and Paris’s Théâtre du Vieux-Colombier. Examples of these and other theatre work were known to the artists and intellectuals either from the Europeans’ visits to America or the Americans’ travels abroad. The new theatre art was in the air, but was not much practiced on America’s commercial stages. It would have been a most attractive outlet for the new ideas and artistic endeavors of the Village artists and thinkers.

Indeed, the theatre movement that sprung up in the Village during this time was populated by talented people from varied fields. Few were theatre professionals as the founders of these companies were slow to recruit artists who represented the same stick-in-the-mud attitudes, exemplified by the state of contemporary Broadway theatre, against which the companies were reacting. The professionals also certainly looked down on the amateurs and their impecunious troupes—until the successes started to attract critical acclaim. Then the croakers and doubters clamored to join them.

Among the participants were radical journalist John Reed, short-story writers Alice Brown and Susan Glaspell, lawyers Lawrence Langner (who specialized in patents) and Elmer Reizenstein (later, Elmer Rice), businessman Edward Goodman, poet Edna St. Vincent Millay, novelist Floyd Dell, publishers Charles and Albert Boni, and sundry others. They amalgamated with the few professional actors, scenic artists, and playwrights and began a movement that started or influenced a number of interrelated theatre developments across America: the art theatre, the little theatre, Off-Broadway, and serious American playwriting.

For the moment, however, they were interested only in founding and operating their own theatre groups based on their artistic and social beliefs and a discontent with the available mainstream theatre. The first major group of this movement to establish itself independently in New York was the Washington Square Players, founded in 1914 as “the outgrowth of a little group that used to foregather in Washington Square, radicals, socialists, progressives, artists, writers and plain men and women . . . .” One of their regular gathering places was the Liberal Club at 133 MacDougal Street, “a Meeting Place for Those Interested in New Ideas.” The Club fostered discussion, openness, and “wine-and-talk parties” on Friday nights at a charge of twenty-five cents. Some occasions were far more boisterous, such as when the Club presented one-act plays written and performed by its members. This was the germ of the Washington Square Players.

The story of the founding of the Washington Square Players has variations, depending on who does the telling. Most agree on the significant details, though. As early as 1912 several artistically inclined intellectuals including Philip Moeller, an aspiring writer, and Edward Goodman used to meet at the Ethical Culture Society on Central Park West. The group read plays together on Sunday evenings, concentrating on modern European dramatists like J. M. Barrie and Maurice Maeterlinck and scripts of their own. Now and then, they would give a public performance. When the group advanced to works by August Strindberg and Arthur Schnitzler, the Society’s director commented discreetly, “I think you have outgrown us.” Moeller and Goodman moved their productions to the Socialist Press Club and, joined by Theresa Helburn and patent attorney Langner, also began reading plays by Henrik Ibsen, Anton Chekhov, and George Bernard Shaw at one another’s homes. A dinner at the Socialist Press Club a few years later introduced another stage-struck lawyer, Elmer Reizenstein, to the emergent Washington Square Players. As he recalled:

The dinner was chaired by Edward Goodman, general director of the enterprise. Others who were actively engaged were Lawrence Langner, Philip Moeller and Lee Simonson. It was a co-operative undertaking; actors, directors, scene-builders, stagehands, ushers were all amateurs. The opening performance, at a tiny playhouse in the East Fifties appropriately called the Bandbox, was a significant event in the history of the American theatre. In a sense, it sounded the first note of the movement that was to vitalize the American drama in the 1920s. The plays, while in the main not especially noteworthy, were in refreshing contrast to the stale, predigested fare of the commercial theatre. The whole undertaking was a step toward the establishment of a much-needed adult theatre.

The nascent group also began meeting at the Liberal Club to argue about the hot topics of the day: socialism, anarchism, free love, birth control, and women’s suffrage. Here were also involved Dell, who had been working as a book critic in Chicago; Ida Rauh, a would-be actress and the wife of Max Eastman, editor of the radical periodical The Masses; tyro Broadway actress Helen Westley, and writer George Cram Cook. These frustrated theatre artists put on one-act plays, usually composed, directed, and designed by Dell, who also performed in them.

Next door to the Liberal Club, at 137 MacDougal, was the Washington Square Book Shop run by the Boni brothers—”the exact center of the new bohemia.” Attracting few customers, the shop was a gathering place for radical poets and writers such as Reed, Emma Goldman, Margaret Sanger, and Theodore Dreiser. So that the budding artists could more easily mingle with the revolutionary writers and thinkers, a door was cut into the wall adjoining the Liberal Club. The Bonis encouraged the efforts of their new neighbors, and inevitably the conversation of the assemblage turned to theatre. The Liberal Club crowd had considered forming a performing company and renting a playhouse, but several attempts to find a site both suitable and affordable were unsuccessful. An art dealer on Washington Square had offered them free use of an unused room in his shop, but when he saw the response to the initial prospectus announcing the new company, he decided he had to charge them rent. Seeking further, the group looked at an empty stable at 139 MacDougal Street, but first the fire inspector, then the buildings inspector, and finally the health inspector all demanded alterations of the space and the cost became prohibitive. Ironically, that vacant stable later became the famous Provincetown Playhouse when the Provincetown Players moved from Cape Cod to Manhattan in 1916.

Ida Rauh lamented their lack of accommodation, but Albert Boni protested that a stage was unnecessary for producing a play. A Liberal Club member with some professional theatre experience who happened to be a Harvard schoolmate of Albert Boni’s resolved the matter immediately. Robert Edmond Jones, just returned from a stint in Europe studying stage design with Max Reinhardt, appeared propitiously at the bookstore.

“Do you have to have a stage to put on a play, Bobby?” asked Boni.
“Of course not,” answered Jones. “You can put on a play right here.”

So, they did. One of the store’s two large rooms was appropriated for a make-shift theatre with the frames of the sliding doors dividing them serving as a proscenium. The group selected Lord Dunsany’s The Glittering Gate as their text for two very practical reasons: it had only two speaking parts and the bookshop had several copies on its shelves. Using sheets of wrapping paper, Jones improvised two tall columns and long spears for the silent guards, for which the two tallest men present, stripped to the waist, were drafted. Jones transformed two other participants into boulders by covering their heads with coats and gave them candles to hold—instant footlights. Helen Westley and the others present became the delighted audience, and the play was thus enacted. It was a few months later, after the inspirited participants raised the money to rent a real theatre, that the formal life of the Washington Square Players began.

In 1914, WSP was essentially alone on the New York independent theatre scene; its colleague theatres had not yet established themselves on their own in the city. The Neighborhood Playhouse, begun in 1912 as an adjunct of the Henry Street Settlement on the Lower East Side, did not begin functioning separately until 1915. The Provincetown Players formed their group on Cape Cod in 1915 but did not move to New York to produce until 1916. These three essentially amateur organizations were followed by a number of other efforts, each inspired by the success of its predecessors, and often founded by departing members of one of the previous groups. This explosion began what today is the Off- and Off-Off-Broadway theatre in New York. Across the country, it gave impetus, inspiration—and material—to the newborn “little theatres” which were supplanting the old stock companies of the 1890s and the unsatisfying touring companies controlled by the Shubert Brothers and the Theatrical Syndicate. These regional theatres eventually developed into major theatrical houses such as Washington’s Arena Stage, Chicago’s Goodman Theatre, Minneapolis’s Guthrie Theater and similar companies in other cities.

Aside from this influence outside the mainstream theatre world, the early Village theatres, even with all their amateurish, low-budget, simple production techniques, had a lasting impact on the commercial theatre against which they were a reaction. Their very success in attracting audiences to out-of-the-way locations and out-of-the-ordinary productions frankly frightened the Broadway producers. Eventually, however, it encouraged the commercial theatre to present more daring and significant material. American theatre before World War I was principally a place of entertainment, while the Washington Square Players and its like were places of dramatized ideas.

But why had these groups formed? What made them feel the need to create a new theatre program? Certainly they wanted to try their artistic wings and indulge their political and social views, but why not in the mainstream? History provides the answer to that, and, not surprisingly, it is based on economics. By the late 1890s, according to Walter Prichard Eaton, drama critic and historian of the Theatre Guild, the successor to the Washington Square Players,

the “Theatrical Syndicate” was formed, and set about to gain control of such a chain of theatres as would make booking with them inevitable . . . . The ambitious actor or producer who might wish to experiment or to do some fine thing limited in its appeal, either had to do it as best he could, at his own risk, and often in a poor theatre, or give it up.

A few enterprising producers like Arthur Hopkins did manage to “experiment” to a degree, “but by and large, productions had to conform to mass taste to get a profitable hearing . . . .” Elmer Rice, who as Elmer L. Reizenstein wrote Home of the Free for the Washington Square Players in 1918, evaluated the commercial theatre of the day in his 1963 autobiography:

In spite of the feebleness of many of today’s plays, the general level of writing and production is higher than it was fifty years ago. There were many excellent craftsman, but almost no plays of literary quality. My avidity for playgoing did not blind me to the fatuities of the native drama. My program books crinkle with scornful commentaries on the crude melodramas and mechanical farces that constituted the bulk of theatrical fare.

In the words of commercial producer Hopkins, all Broadway offered was “a ceaseless repetition of a familiar and timeworn formula” that no longer provided any excitement to the audiences.

In illustration of the futility of producing anything subdued, artistic, and delicate on Broadway, Rice relates an anecdote concerning Alice Brown, a New England author whose The Sugar House was performed by the Washington Square Players in 1916. When the Booth Theatre opened on Broadway’s Shubert Alley in 1913, owner Winthrop Ames offered a $10,000 prize for the best play to inaugurate the theatre. Alice Brown’s Children of Earth won the prize, but “the payment of such a sum to an unknown writer aroused expectations that the quiet, sensitive chronicle of New England life did not fulfill. It was soon withdrawn, another ‘proof’ that art in the theatre does not pay.” This was the prevailing trend of the Broadway theatre at the time the Villagers were forming their artistic and social philosophies. Susan Glaspell, who with her husband George Cram Cook was an early member of the Washington Square Players and later founded the Provincetown Players, summed it up for her fellows:

We went to the theater and for the most part wished we had gone somewhere else . . . . Plays . . . were patterned. They might be pretty good within themselves, seldom out to—where it surprised or thrilled your spirit to follow. They didn’t ask much of you, those plays. Having paid for your seat, the thing was all done for you, and your mind came out where it went in, only tireder . . . . What was this “Broadway,” which could make a thing as interesting as life into a thing as dull as a Broadway play?

For the most part, Broadway productions were “dramatized best sellers and vehicles drawn exclusively by stars.” Among the latter were the long-running title-character appearances of Joseph Jefferson in Rip Van Winkle, William Gillette in Sherlock Holmes, and James O’Neill in the famously career-dominating The Count of Monte Cristo. Aside from the “crude melodramas and mechanical farces” described by Elmer Rice, the mainstream product included mediocre romantic comedies and foreign works whose adaptation, in the words of a contemporary critic, “often robbed the play of all its character.” Furthermore, though the commercial producers controlled most of the money in theatre, artists were contemptuous of Broadway because the sets and costumes were old-fashioned. Even the “painstaking dramaturgy” of David Belasco, whose crowning achievement was the construction onstage of an operating replica of Child’s Restaurant, complete with “real flapjacks . . . fried on a real griddle,” for 1912’s Governor’s Lady, was used merely to enhance empty plots. Such elaborate realistic sets, which Robert Edmond Jones disparaged as “interior decorating,” were necessary only because “few of the dramas of our time have been vital enough to be able to dispense with them.” “The proscenium,” lamented Lee Simonson, the Players’ distinguished designer, “was nothing more than an enlarged peep-hole, the current theatre a peep-show.”

With this atmosphere in and around the mainstream theatre just when enthusiastic young people were looking for artistic outlets, it is certainly no wonder that they would be impelled to found their own companies. They needed something more than was available, but, as another critic of the time saw it, “the need is not recognized on Broadway, or if recognized it is not understood . . . . It can only be met by dramatists and actors and managers who of necessity reach that pitch of intensity about the consequential which . . . conceals a truth.”

That truth, according to Lawrence Langner, was “intelligence, and interest in social matters, and a serious critique of life . . . .” In the view of Philip Moeller, they intended “to assert the rights of the human soul. The American [commercial] theatre has no place for the subtler nuances of drama.” WSP expressed a desire, as theatre historian John Gassner saw it, not only “to introduce new styles of dramatic art to the American public . . . [but] to introduce new attitudes and interest in psychological and social truths.” Robert Edmond Jones, who helped inspire the launching of the Washington Square Players, noted that the contemporary theatre was concerned with creating stage “illusion”—remember Belasco’s restaurant set—when what he and his innovators wanted was “allusion.” The one, he knew, was rigid, empty, and fake; the other, fluid, provocative, and stimulating. What was being offered on American stages, Jones held, was not real theatre because it lacked any “dramatic nourishment.” “We are hungry,” he cried, “and we are given a cook-book to eat instead of a meal. We expect to go on a journey, and we have to be satisfied with a map and a time table.”

As was the practice, the Players published a Manifesto to set forth its aims and purposes. Written by founders Langner, Moeller, and Goodman, the statement made plain the following precepts:

The Washington Square Players . . . believe in the future of the theatre in America . . . .


The Washington Square Players believe that a higher standard can be reached only as the outcome of experiment and initiative.

We believe that hard work and perseverance, coupled with ability and the absence of purely commercial considerations, may result in the birth and healthy growth of an artistic theatre in this country.

We have only one policy in regard to the plays which we will produce—they must have artistic merit. Preference will be given to . . . plays . . . which have been ignored by the commercial managers.

Though not organized for purposes of profit, we are not endowed. Money alone has never produced an artistic theatre.

Believing in democracy in the theatre, we have fixed the charge for admission at 50 cents.

(The 50-cent admission was a third of the cost of the best seats in the commercial theater in 1916. Special events, such as an appearance of Vaslav Nijinsky and the Ballet Russe, could cost as much as five dollars. There were seats available for as little as 25 cents, but these would have been in the rear of the balcony or other poor seats; WSP tickets were set at one price for all seats at all times.)

[This is the first part of my analysis of the history and artistry of the Washington Square Players. I’ll pick up part two in a few days, starting with a discussion of its finances and how it managed that element of its work. Please come back to ROT at the start of next week to read how I saw the artistic aspects of the historic company.]