My mother and I took a long weekend trip down to the Shenandoah Shakespeare in Staunton, Virginia, in May 2003 to check out their new theater, a replica of the Blackfriars of Jacobean London. Opened on Friday, 21 September 2001, the Blackfriars Playhouse is the only reconstruction of an indoor Renaissance theater in the world. Named for the theater Shakespeare’s King’s Men used in the winter months when the uncovered Globe was unsuitable, Shenandoah Shakespeare’s Blackfriars Playhouse was painstakingly designed and constructed according to the best research available, though there are no known visual representations or construction records of any of the hall theaters popular in the 17th century.
The original Blackfriars Theatres (there were two) were named for the disused Dominican monastery on whose grounds the playhouses were built. The property had become a crown possession after Henry VIII seized church holdings at the beginning of the English reformation. The first Blackfriars Theatre, called a “private” theater, was constructed in 1576 and housed mostly children’s troupes until 1585 when it was shut down. In 1596, James Burbage, impresario of the Lord Chamberlain’s Men (and father of Richard Burbage who would become Shakespeare’s favorite actor), purchased another building on the property and converted it into a theater. The second Blackfriars remained host to boys’ companies, then much in vogue among the Elizabethan glitterati, until 1608, when the fashion had shifted, and James Burbage, who still owned the theater, took control of the Blackfriars for his troupe, now known as the King’s Men. There were seven shareholders in the King’s Men at the time, including Richard Burbage and William Shakespeare. After renovations, the King's Men started performing in Blackfriars in 1609, occupying it for the seven cold months of the year and moving to the open-air Globe, a “public” theater, during the summer. Records indicate that Blackfriars, though much smaller than the Globe, earned a little more than twice the income the more-famous outdoor theater did. Blackfriars closed in 1642 when Cromwell and the Roundhead parliament closed all the theaters and, having fallen into disrepair, was demolished on 6 August 1655. (The rest of the former monastery was destroyed in the Great Fire of 1666. The property now forms part of the Blackfriars district of central London.)
Little is certain about the appearance, either outside or inside, of the private theaters of the 16th and 17th centuries. There are scattered references but no actual records, drawings, or detailed descriptions. Modern renderings of the indoor or hall theaters are based largely on speculation and interpolation. (In contrast, though the original Globe was largely unknown until part of the foundations was uncovered in October 1989, the public, or outdoor, theaters were documented more thoroughly. The many “reproductions” of the Globe before 1989, however, were principally based on combinations of the Theatre and the Swan.) Some things were known, however, or at least commonly accepted, about the design of the hall theaters, enough to devise an approximation of their appearance, some of which beliefs were used in the design of the Staunton Blackfriars Playhouse. For instance, English Renaissance theaters were modeled on period banquet halls where theatrical performances were given. There are also plans for hall theaters, such as one by the great Tudor architect and stage designer Inigo Jones, that were never built. Finally, some assumptions can be made about the configuration of the private theaters from an analysis of Shakespeare’s stage directions.
Let me back up a bit now and summarize the history of the company that built the new Blackfriars Playhouse. In 1988, Dr. Ralph A. Cohen, an English professor and Shakespearean scholar at James Madison University in Harrisonburg, Virginia, and his former student and principal “classroom actor” James Warren (who had just graduated) formed Shenandoah Shakespeare Express (known as SSE), a touring troupe whose mission was to stage the plays of Shakespeare and his Elizabethan contemporaries without all the modern accouterments that had been added over the centuries. As Cohen asserts, “It seemed that the more elaborate the setting, the more the [audience’s] interest dropped.” His research revealed, for instance, that the custom of turning down the house lights was only as old as the middle of the 19th century (with the advent of gaslight) and that other modern theatrical conventions, such as “period” costumes and detailed sets, were not part of the Renaissance theater experience. (We have limited knowledge about what English Renaissance theater performances were actually like.) That first season, SSE toured the Old Dominion with Richard III; the next year, the troupe took Taming of the Shrew to Delaware, Pennsylvania, Vermont, New Hampshire, and New York. In 1992, SSE performed in the Elizabethan theater at the Folger Shakespeare Library in Washington, D.C., and traveled to London and Edinburgh’s Finge Fesitval. So it went until 1999 when the company moved permanently to Staunton, Virginia, and renamed itself Shenandoah Shakespeare (known as S2). That same year, S2 began plans for building its own home theater, a replica of Shakespeare’s Blackfriars, and following that, a Globe reproduction. The concept was modeled on Ashland’s famous and successful Oregon Shakespeare Festival whose draw Staunton hopes to emulate to make the city "a Shakespeare destination." (The company has many programs in addition to its productions, some in collaboration with Mary Baldwin College.) In 2001, as reported, S2 completed the first part of its plan and opened the Blackfriars Playhouse with Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night's Dream and a season including Hamlet, Tom Stoppard’s Rosencrantz & Guildenstern Are Dead, and Ben Jonson’s The Alchemist. In 2005, S2 became the American Shakespeare Center. The resident company of about a dozen members produces four full “seasons” a year, in the summer, fall, winter, and spring, comprised of three to five plays in rep; the company simultaneously sends two touring troupes around the state, the country, and the world.
The little city of Staunton (population about 24,000), the seat of Augusta County, is itself a historic spot. In the heart of the Shenandoah Valley, it’s the home of Mary Baldwin College and the birthplace of Woodrow Wilson, our 28th president. (His home is now the Woodrow Wilson Presidential Library.) Founded in 1747, the historic downtown district is architecturally restricted so that it maintains a largely mid-19th- to early 20th-century look and has been used as a location for several period films. (I will add here that Staunton’s also the original home of Augusta Academy, the institution established in 1749 that eventually became Washington and Lee University, my alma mater.) Staunton (which is pronounced ‘STAN-tun,’ despite its spelling) lies just off I-81 and is a drive of about three hours southwest of Washington or two hours northwest of Richmond. It’s about 375 miles southwest of New York City.
The Blackfriars Playhouse is located at 10 South Market Street, in the historic district (which is only about four blocks long and two or three wide), a half block off East Beverly Street, the town’s main drag. It sits on a small lot next to the renovated Stonewall Jackson Hotel, which first opened in 1924. The 14,500 square-foot playhouse took 13 months to complete at a cost of $3.7 million. (Estimates are that ASC’s Globe recreation will cost $20-30 million when it’s built on a nearby site.) The city of Staunton put up $2 million of the price tag. We know that Tom McLaughlin’s blueprint for the Staunton Blackfriars, which he based principally on the 1616 Inigo Jones plans for an unrealized theater, isn’t actually the historical London Blackfriars. Since there’s no actual record of that theater still extant, McLaughlin took his inspiration from Tudor rooms such as Middle Temple Hall, the Hall at Gray’s Inn, and Westminster Hall. The architect did research at the Folger Shakespeare Library, which contains the largest collection of print Shakespeareana in the world, where he consulted legal and archeological records; he also conferred with experts on Elizabethan theatrical design and construction. (For the outer building, McLaughlin saw MIT’s Baker Dormitory and Sever Hall at Harvard as models.) Even if the details are fudged, however, the overall appearance is convincing.
The playhouse is exactly what it's reported to be as far as I could tell. It looks like a very faithful approximation of a 17th-century hall theater though the exterior is only vaguely Tudor. Architect Tom McLaughlin says the building has an “astylistic and vernacular exterior that fits into the historical and architectural context of Staunton.” ArchitectureWeek asserts that it “pretends to be neither as old as the other buildings in Staunton nor jarringly modern,” which is an accurate characterization. The timbered front alludes to Tudor structures (with a touch of the Alpine chalets of both Switzerland and Colorado--the Washington Post compares it to “a fire station in Telluride”). The building “echoes older buildings” in town without replicating them. The peaked-roof exterior gives off “dark earthy tones” of red-brown brick with dark gray mortar. There is a rounded, windowed corner at the south end of the façade that houses the lobby staircase inside.
Through the double doors of the entrance, under a sort of marquee--reminiscent of the gables of the old inns that predated the public theaters--with tall windows on either side and a long window above, is the modern lobby, mostly undecorated (at least when I was there six years ago). The Washington Post describes the space as “austere and forgettable” so that “walking into the theater itself is the moment of drama.” The lobby, indeed, acts as a sort of portal between the 21st century and the 17th century of the playhouse auditorium and stage. "If Shakespeare walked into the lobby of this theater, he'd freak out," says a member of the company. "Inside, Shakespeare would recognize it immediately."
Patrons enter the auditorium either from the ground-floor lobby or by climbing the stairs in the left corner to the upper lobby and the gallery. Inside, the walls are timbered white plaster and the construction is mostly unpainted and undecorated blond wood with a high-gloss finish. The seating accommodates 300 spectators plus standing room for 20 more. (This is in contrast to the 500-1000 spectators of the original Blackfriars, which wasn’t restricted by fire laws and occupancy regulations. ASC artistic director Jim Warren also observes that Shakespeare’s 17th-century patrons “had skinnier butts.”) The auditorium is 66 feet by 54 feet, lit by electric chandeliers and sconces in the galleries, all crafted from hand-forged iron and designed to resemble the candle-lit counterparts of the 17th century. (There are no windows in the auditorium, though in Renaissance halls there usually were. Since performances were traditionally in daylight, the windows would have provided additional natural illumination, but the Staunton Blackfriars occupies the entire building site and city codes don’t permit windows on shared property lines.)
The auditorium is all post-and-beam construction, almost entirely hand-turned from Virginia white oak by local artisans. The Shenandoah Valley has been producing master woodworkers for centuries and the carpenters “considered the interior to be of the quality of fine furniture,” according to architect McLaughlin, a Richmond resident. “This started out as a job,” explained one of the craftsmen, “but it got to be more than just what we do for living.” Almost echoing McLaughlin’s thought, he added, “This was special.” The private Renaissance theaters were generally painted, gilded, and faux-marbled and were probably further decorated with hangings, but the Staunton Shakespeareans were loath to cover up the natural look of the carving. It's all obviously carefully created and lovingly done.
The three-foot-high thrust stage is 22 feet deep and 30 feet across. At the rear of the platform is the traditional Elizabethan tiring house. (The tiring house façade has been painted faux-marbre since my visit.) The upstage discovery space is flanked by two doors for entrances and exits. Above the curtained opening is a gallery of 8 feet by 30 feet with staircases descending to the stage on both sides. The floor of the platform is equipped with a trapdoor, as befits the Elizabethan reproduction; however, the trap has a motorized lift to hoist the spooky characters and ghosts into view. (The backstage area is also less period-accurate. There are dressing rooms, a green room, a kitchen and eating area, a wardrobe room, sewing tables, and other modern theater accommodations, not to mention elevators for handicap access and heating, cooling, and electrical equipment.) Except for occasional stage properties, no more than a throne, a tomb, or a table, the stage is unadorned for performances; the architectural backdrop of the theater is the only set. Hand props and costumes, which at ASC may be vaguely modern, vagely Renaissance, or sometimes a mix of both with carefully selected “period” elements added, are the only other assistance the actors use to supplement the playwright’s words.
From the start in 1988, the company used "original staging practices,” techniques that align with what we know to be Elizabethan, or what we've guessed they did then. "We've invented a lot of tricks in the theater in the last 400 years," says ASC executive director Cohen. "We want to uncover some of the magic that tends to get masked by all those tricks." This includes “natural” lighting (that is, no spotlights or other modern stage instruments); the lights never go out in the Blackfriars Playhouse. ("Shenandoah Shakespeare--We do it with the lights on!" is their slogan.) The audience and the actors can see one another all the time, and the spectators can see and hear each other. The audience is seated on three sides of the thrust stage, and there are even "Gallants' Stools" on stage for those who wish to approximate that Jacobean experience. The actors often interact with the spectators, eschewing any pretense of a “fourth” wall. Spectators who decide to occupy the Gallants’ Stools on stage are even required to agree to serve as extras. The seating, on benches (though there are cushions and seat backs for rent), is at floor level and in a balcony a storey above. (There are actually two levels of galleries, but the lower one is only a step or two above the auditorium floor.) There are a few “Lord’s Chairs” available for those of us too uncomfortable to sit on the benches.
Casting practices include doubling (and even tripling) so that most actors perform several roles. (Plays are performed in rep so actors play roles in most of the productions of a season.) Unlike the Elizabethan and Jacobean practice, the company casts women, but is committed to gender-switching. Just as the King’s Men cast men and boys as women in Shakespeare’s plays, ASC casts women in men’s roles as well. Music, often composed by company members, is an integral part of ASC productions: all performances are prefaced by music and most include musical interludes or intervals, all of it done live and unamplified. They do have an intermission (filled with skits and entertainments--of a decidedly un-Elizabethan timbre--if spectators wish to stay in their seats), but there are no other gaps in the performance; a scene starts as the previous one is ending--or at least as the actors are exiting. Plays are generally performed within Shakespeare’s mandated "Two hours' traffic of our stage." These fundamental practices impelled the construction of the Blackfriars Playhouse.
[I’ve decided it would be interesting to post my report on the visit I made to Staunton in 2003 to see the Shenandoah Shakespeare, as it was then known, in their new Blackfriars home. Look for that column from my archives in a few days on ROT.]
[This is Part 4, the final installment, of my commentary on Kirk Woodward’s book, The Art of Writing Reviews (http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback-book/the-art-of-writing-reviews/6785272).]
After treating the matter of reviewers closing productions with poor notices, Kirk raises the question of reviewers who know people connected to the production and fear their notices might hurt their friends and acquaintances. It’s hard, perhaps, for reviewers not to become engaged in the social whirl of the arts they cover. That’s probably more true in smaller markets than in large ones like New York or L.A., but there’s a danger here, too. I remember reading an article about New York Times chief reviewer Ben Brantley, who I thought had taken a pretty extreme action to avoid that--he literally absents himself entirely from the New York social scene. According to the report, he lived outside the city (though he may have moved in since then) and apparently doesn’t socialize with anyone connected to theater. (I thought this was extreme not because Brantley avoids the social aspects of the biz—that may be difficult but wise—but because, not living in the city he covers, he loses perspective on the atmosphere—political, communal, economic, cultural—that surrounds and informs the art about which he writes.)
The Times doesn’t permit its theater reviewers to participate in any awards program (editors and other journalists may, and I don’t know if reviewers in other arts are similarly enjoined) because the editors don’t want their reviewers even to appear to have conflicts of interest. A few years ago, Critics Quarterly (the newsletter of ATCA, which Kirk would insist ought to be called Reviewers Quarterly . . . or, maybe, Reviewers Review) did a series of articles, plus letters from members, concerning reviewers who got involved in other aspects of theater such as playwriting or acting. Some members felt this was a good way to learn more about the business, by seeing it from the inside while it was working. Others were vociferous in their opinions that this placed the reviewers in danger of becoming too personally acquainted with the artists they would be called on to criticize. I no longer was trying to act when I was writing reviews, but I still knew actors, directors, designers, and stage managers who were working in New York and there were theater companies run by friends and former colleagues producing plays I might have to review. The situation only arose once or twice, and I raised the potential conflict with my editor, but I was surprised when he said he didn’t really care. (I think the real situation was that he didn’t have that many writers on whom he could call and he couldn’t replace me.) It was very hard to be objective and I had to question myself very carefully when it came to writing about the people I knew, even slightly.
Interestingly, there’s an organization in New York City that was established essentially to address this situation. The Players, on Gramercy Park, was founded by actor Edwin Booth (in his last home, where his room is still preserved as he left it) to allow actors to meet the important citizens of the city on a social basis. He thought that members of his profession ought to know the people who supported the theater and the city’s movers and shakers in all fields, politics, finance, merchandising, letters, and so on, should know the theater artists who were so important to New York’s culture. (Theater was, at the time, the popular entertainment, much as movies and TV are today.) That is, all the professions except one. No reviewers could be members of The Players. Booth didn’t think it would be wise to put actors in the same room with the writers who from time to time may have said uncomplimentary things about them. Now, the all-male membership has been integrated in recent years, but the prohibition against reviewers still holds. (By the way, the organization is called The Players, not the Players Club.)
When he writes about reporting on the play’s plot, Kirk proposes, “We can ask, what happens to the characters? Do they grow, change, move from point A to point N?” This is very close to the question dramaturgs learn to ask when analyzing a script for their artistic directors: Who does the play happen to? It’s a way of determining which character is the focal one (which may not be the same as the lead role or the literary protagonist). It’s an interesting question to ask, even for a reviewer.
When it comes to the perspective of the spectator, Kirk reminds us that “not everyone in the theater sees—or hears—the same show.” It’s a fact of live performances that no two people see the same show and no two performances are the same. No matter where you sit in a movie theater, you see essentially the same movie as everyone else (barring sitting behind a pillar or a very tall person). But with a live performance, especially theater or ballet, there’s an element of Heraclitus’ tenet: “One cannot step twice into the same river, for the water into which you first stepped has flowed on.” The corollary is that no two people can step into the same river because the water where one stepped is not the same as the water where the other did. (Besides, no two people’s experience of that river will be the same, either. That’s true of movies and television, too, of course.) The trade-off is that in live theater, I can choose where I want to look. In film and TV, the camera, under the director’s control, does that for me.
Kirk asserts that theater pros feel “that opening nights are the worst performances” of a play’s run. Openings are still the traditional night for reviewers and the press, despite the scheduling of “critics’ previews.” (No matter when the reviewer sees the show, the notice traditionally appears the day after opening.) I was never a first-nighter, so I had the luxury of seeing the performances after the play opened and settled down, and even now, I generally avoid opening nights. To be frank, openings are more social events than artistic ones and the company’s emotions are high and tight. Friends and family are in the house; agents and managers come to see their clients; the producers, backers, and investors and their invited guests are there for the festivities; non-reviewing press—editors, feature writers, cultural reporters—are covering the “news” event. Everyone backstage is on edge, you can bet. (When I first started to perform, I couldn’t eat before a performance. When I got more used to the experience, that was no longer so—except on opening nights.)
In addition to the emotional tension, there are the various production issues that affect the performance. It’s a truism in theater that no planned rehearsal period is long enough. You always need another week. In many shows, the first time everyone has gone through the entire play with full tech and costumes the way it’s supposed to be seen by the audience is the final dress rehearsal. On opening night, there will be acting and directing problems from both nerves and from not being quite ready yet. In new plays, it’s not unusual for new lines and even new scenes to be inserted within days of opening; new songs can be added to musicals. Because of the labor-intensivity of the rehearsal period plus the union regulations, technical adjustments are often brought in at the last minute: costumes don’t fit quite right yet, set pieces haven’t been tested, lights aren’t focused right. (I once actually went on stage with a set still wet with last-minute, improvised “paint”: pea soup!) No, opening night is not a typical performance. It’s more like the first time a cook makes a new recipe—it’s not really ready for primetime.
Still, I remember an occurrence that remains one of the strangest of which I have ever heard in theater. In 1997, The Scarlet Pimpernel opened at the Minskoff Theatre on 9 November. It received mediocre reviews or worse. New producers stepped in and bought out the old investors, closed the show on 1 October 1998 for retooling, and reopened it on 4 November. Talk about not being ready on opening night!
In debating whether reviews are “art,” Kirk paraphrases Will and Ariel Durant’s definition of art: “significance expressed with feeling through form.” (The quote is from Writing Reviews, not the Durants.) I’d like to add another, very similar definition from Susanne Langer, another philosopher: “Art is the creation of forms symbolic of human feeling.” As you can see, it’s nearly the same language. Let me add here another of Langer’s statements that I have found revealing—because it’s a comment about “beauty” in a context we should consider when viewing many new kinds of art. (This harks back to the remarks Kirk and I made about standards and new art not resembling the old.) Langer writes: “Beauty is not identical with the normal, and certainly not with charm and sense appeal, though all such properties may go to the making of it.”
Beauty, I think Langer’s saying, ain’t always pretty. She also defines beauty as “expressive form,” by which she maintains that it affects its audience in some way. “Beautiful works may contain elements that, taken in isolation, are hideous,” she writes. This interpretation of beauty, which may owe something to Heraclitus’ view that there is beauty in a random collection of unrelated elements, can be seen as an application of Aristotle’s explanation that we get pleasure in drama even from seeing things we’d regard with disgust if encountered in reality because we learn from them, and learning gives us pleasure. Furthermore, Langer admonishes us that we may not recognize as good a work of art that puts us off until “we have grasped its expressiveness.” One friend of Vincent van Gogh’s, for instance, admitted that at first the painter’s art “was so totally different from what I had imagined it would be . . . so rough and unkempt, so harsh and unfinished, that . . . I was unable to think it good or beautiful.” It’s noteworthy that Marshall McLuhan calls “good taste,” often substituted for “beauty” in the judgment of traditionalists, “the first refuge of the noncreative . . . , the anesthetic of the public . . . , the most obvious resource of the insecure.” Richard Kostelanetz, whom I quoted earlier, also submits that “a truly original, truly awakening piece of art will not, at first, be accepted as beautiful.”
In his discussion of “good art” and “great art,” Kirk remarks, “I could write a play that conforms to all Aristotle’s principles and has no value at all—indeed, many have.” First, let me reiterate here, in the words of Susanne Langer, what I said about poor art earlier: “There may be poor art, which is not corrupt, but fails to express what [the artist] knew in too brief an intuition. . . . . The result is a poor and helpless product, sincere enough, but confused and frustrated by recalcitrance of the medium or sheer lack of technical freedom.” Langer takes a harsher line with “bad art,” but making poor art is not a criminal act. Now, I’ll draw a literary parallel between what Kirk wrote about writing a mediocre play that follows all the rules and an old play to which I once introduced Kirk, Plots and Playwrights by Edward Massey.
The plot concerns Caspar Gay, a successful Broadway playwright wandering Greenwich Village looking for “an inspiration” for his next play. He meets young short-story writer Joseph Hastings in front of a boarding house. Gay explains his desperation, and Hastings suggests that there’s a play on every floor of the house and the two writers challenge one another. Hastings composes small dramas based on the intimate, but revealing, stories of the residents of each floor of the house, one scene for each apartment. Gay’s output, on the other hand, is complex and predictable, a contrived melodrama about all the house’s residents in improbable relationships. Hastings reacts in disbelief to Gay’s creation, and the famous playwright responds, “But it will run a year on Broadway.” “My God,” cries the enlightened novelist, “it has.” And that’s what can happen when you merely follow all the rules!
I do want to take small exception to one thing Kirk writes. Actually, I want to expand it a bit. The author notes, correctly, that “some works are simply better than others.” I’d add, “. . . for some people.” As Kirk continues, “Our criteria and judgments about art will always be subjective,” so each of us will see and feel things no one else will, and vice versa. Hence, art I think is great may seem mediocre or even awful to you and art you love may leave me cold. (Furthermore, taste, like the truth, changes over time. But let’s not get into that.) I’ll admit here that I don’t much like Harold Pinter’s plays. I’ll acknowledge that he was probably a genius, but his plays always just confuse me and leave me frustrated. I don’t enjoy those feelings. Obviously, though, mine’s a minority opinion since he won a Nobel in lit in 2005. As my father liked to say, De gustibus non disputandum est: There’s no accounting for taste.
When it comes to defining who’s an artist, Kirk quotes some lines from 8th-century Chinese poet Li Po. Allow me to add another voice, William Shakespeare:
The poet’s eye, in a fine frenzy rolling,
Doth glance from heaven to earth, from earth to heaven;
And, as imagination bodies forth
The forms of things unknown, the poet’s pen
Turns them to shapes, and gives to airy nothing
A local habitation and a name.
Further, Kirk adds that someone who writes, plays, or sings isn’t automatically an artist: an artist needs “to create something that changes the way people feel, hear, and think.” Living Theatre co-founder Julian Beck declared, “An actor who brings back from his adventures a moment of communicable penetration is a hero, the light of our lives.” It is perhaps noteworthy that the people who make commercials don’t call the performers who appear on the screen “artists”: they are simply “the talent.” I guess even the producers of TV commercials don’t figure it takes an artist to sell toilet paper or cars.
When Writing Reviews gets to contemplating how a reviewer actually goes about composing the review, Kirk addresses the question of whether or not to take notes while viewing the performance. (The question is less pertinent for non-performing arts, such as book or art reviewing, for obvious reasons.) His conclusion comes down on both sides of the question: “Take notes when you have to.” I’ve tried both ways, and a third in the middle (taking notes without looking at the pad!), and I end up in Kirk’s corner on this. You have to pay attention to what you’re watching and any distraction lessens your attentiveness. On the other hand, there are details that you recognize as potentially telling, like, say, a line of dialogue or a particularly revealing movement or gesture, and you know you can’t remember them for long without writing it down. Sometimes I’ve been able to keep the thing in mind long enough to jot it down in the lobby at intermission or right after the performance, which kind of splits the difference, but there’s no definitive answer for everyone; some people’s memories are just better than others' and some bits of performance are more memorable than others. You have to go with what works for you under the circumstances.
By the way, in an earlier paragraph, Kirk advises that “it is difficult for anyone . . . to take in an entire show at one sitting.” This is especially so if you’re taking notes while you’re watching. The trade-off is that if you don’t take the notes, you might not remember later what you did manage to “take in.” Going back, as some of the pros Kirk invokes suggest, is a good way to solve this dilemma, but that’s time consuming and, if you’re footing the bill for the extra tix, expensive. It also can get in the way of meeting deadlines. (TV reviewers have a much easier job here: they are usually provided with recordings of the program, several episodes if it’s a series, and can both pause the video to make a note and go back and re-watch parts or all of the show.)
I want to comment on something Kirk wrote near the end of Writing Reviews because I've always remembered it ever since I heard it. (I don't always follow the advice very well, but I do remember it!) In the "Reviewing your review" section, Kirk tells the reader to ask, "Can you say things more directly, cut out useless words, eliminate the unnecessary?" (That’s writing advice, of course, not just review-writing advice.) A teacher of mine used to say, "Kill your babies," meaning be willing to cut the things you like the most when they aren't really helping. Be ruthless, she meant. I often wish I could do that—but I have too much "ruth" I guess. But I hear her say that whenever I edit my work—especially when I come to something I know I should cut . . . but don’t want to.
Finally, one of the last observations of Writing Reviews is the statement that though we may “see a lot of bad art” over our lifetimes, “we’ll also experience things that enrich and possibly change our lives . . . .” Intentionally or otherwise, Kirk’s speaking of all kinds of art, not just theater or the performing arts. I could make a short list of the works of art, performances, texts, and visual art, that have moved me or showed me something so that I’ve never forgotten it or the experience. But I want to close out these comments by quoting an artist who made this point very clearly in his own way. I’ve written about the Inuit artist Pudlo Pudlat before (ROT, 28 September), and I quoted this then: “If an artist draws a subject over and over again in different ways, then he will learn something. The same with someone who looks at drawings—if that person keeps looking at many drawings, then he will learn something from them too.” A wise, wise man.
[This is Part 3 of my commentary on Kirk Woodward’s book, The Art of Writing Reviews (http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback-book/the-art-of-writing-reviews/6785272). There will be four parts in all.]
On a less heated topic than reviewers' personal prejudices, Kirk notes that it’s almost impossible for a spectator to tell who’s responsible for what in a production. That’s true in general--though you can make a pretty good stab at who designed the sets and costumes. Because the program usually tells us. To be serious, though, a wise reviewer will know that the director probably had a great deal to say about the production design--and in some cases, so will the producer. Earlier I mentioned the formation of the American Directors Institute to try to help explain the work of stage directors to the public and even other theater professionals because so few people outside the rehearsals really know what the director does. I was only half joking when I said you could easily tell who designed the sets and so on, but the same is true of the acting. The actors are ultimately responsible for what they do on stage, but they worked with the director (and sometimes even the playwright) while they were developing the work that we end up seeing in performance. Theater is called a “collaborative art.” Nothing happens on the stage during the performance of a play, not even those monodramas I mentioned earlier, that hasn’t been shaped by many hands. I wonder how many people realize, for instance, that the character’s costume can have a tremendous effect on the actor’s work, both physically and psychologically. So can the set design and construction. Lines have been changed because of an actor (especially in TV); whole songs have been added or cut because of an actor’s work. Acting decisions can change because lines have been changed earlier or later in the script. We discuss a play as if the actors made all their own choices in a vacuum, that the designers all worked alone in their studios, and that the director . . . well, who knows what the director did. But it’s not true--it never was and it never will be. That’s precisely why no two productions of the same play are ever the same. (No two performances of the same production are the same, either, but that’s a different phenomenon.) That’s what makes theater such an exciting art form--at least for me. (It’s also why I used to love rehearsing. Performing was a reward, but rehearsing was where all the creativity happened and everyone you worked with was part of it. It was exhilarating.)
Aaron Frankel, the acting teacher whom I’ve mentioned a few times (because he had all these neat little aphorisms that have stuck with me) used to quote Martha Graham: "Don't come on stage to give; come on stage to take!" It sounds selfish and egotistical, but what I understand it to mean, for an actor, is that you take in what the other actors are sending you, you let it inform your performance, and you respond to it. Then the other actors respond to what you send out in turn. The most difficult actors with whom I worked were the ones who came to the theater with their performances all canned and ready. They were all closed off. I couldn’t change their performance no matter what I did on stage with them--they just barreled through with their plan. I’d have no choice but to do the same thing, and then we no longer had a live play but a kind of live-action video game. If we did it well, maybe no one in the audience would notice, but it wasn’t any fun to do.
Even if, as Kirk points out, you see two performances of a production with the same director and different actors, you can’t be sure whose contribution you’re witnessing. Sensitive directors will reconceive a character based on the contributions of an actor and rework the part even as the overall production concept remains essentially the same. Sometimes, the kit-and-kaboodle gets shifted because of the presence of new actors. If you read the re-reviews of continuing shows written when there’s been a cast change, you can sometimes see that old shows can learn new tricks. When Eileen Atkins replaced Cherry Jones as Sister Aloysius in Doubt, reviewers noted how different the play had become as a result of the new approach to the role. No one said that Atkins’s interpretation was better than Jones’s, but the difference was marked. It’s not really part of the same point, but now and then those changes can improve the production. Not too long ago, when the revival of Annie Get Your Gun was running on Broadway, Bernadette Peters (whom I saw do the role pre-Broadway in Washington a few months earlier) actually didn’t get such good notices. (Truth be told, she was a tad old for the part.) But when Reba McEntire replaced Peters, reviewers felt that McEntire suited the part better and the show was better for the change.
Writing Reviews also addresses the issue of “inside information.” Kirk warns that reviewers who put forth that they know things we outsiders don’t are often wrong, to begin with, and even if they’re not, the inside dope doesn’t really have anything to do with the experience at hand, namely the performance. In one example, Kirk writes, “Reviewers often claim to know why an artist did something, when even the artist may have no idea,” and he relates a story about John Lennon playing bass on a Paul McCartney song. Lennon played badly and one reviewer claimed it had been sabotage even though, as Kirk notes, Lennon was “simply a lousy bass player.” This all reminds me of Tom Stoppard’s Arcadia, whose plot centers on research a scholar is doing about Lord Byron. Using the family archives at a country house where Byron had stayed in 1809, the researcher puts together the evidence about what Byron was doing at the house and interprets it to determine a plausible scenario. But Arcadia is divided into two interwoven narratives, the other one being the same house in 1809 and we get to see what actually went on then. It turns out, despite the parallels between the facts in 1809 and the ones revealed in “the present day,” that the researcher has interpreted the evidence completely wrong.
One of Stoppard’s favorite themes is How do we know what we think we know? It is the central theme of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern and part of the point of Jumpers and even Travesties. His characters almost always get the facts right but the conclusions wrong. One of his most fun arguments in Jumpers, in a speech about the existence of God that I used to use for auditions, goes this way:
Cantor’s proof that there is no greatest number ensures that there is no smallest fraction. There is no beginning. But it was precisely this notion of infinite series which in the sixth century BC led the Greek philosopher Zeno to conclude that since an arrow shot towards a target first had to cover half the distance, and then half the remainder, and then half the remainder after that, and so on ad infinitum, the result was, . . . that though an arrow is always approaching its target, it never quite gets there, and Saint Sebastian died of fright. Furthermore, by a similar argument he showed that before reaching the half-way point, the arrow had to reach the quarter-mark, and before that the eighth, and before that the sixteenth, and so on, with the result, remembering Cantor’s proof, that the arrow could not move at all!
An ideal example of perfect logic leading to an impossible conclusion. As reviewers and consumers of reviews, we need to be skeptical of such reasoning and the information on which it’s founded.
As a sort of addendum to this discussion, Kirk makes the point that his admonition about inside information also holds true for determining that “a work of art is a direct reflection of the artist’s life . . . .” Almost all artists use elements of their biography to inform their work, though that doesn’t make every artist’s work “autobiographical.” Some is, to one degree or another: Arthur Miller’s After the Fall is clearly a reflection of his marriage to Marilyn Monroe--though it isn’t an account of that marriage; most of Horton Foote’s characters are based on his family and neighbors from the Texas town where he grew up, but the plays don’t tell the history of his family. Kirk invoked Tennessee Williams as an example, and though Williams used aspects of his life in almost all his writing, especially early in his career, his plays aren’t autobiographies. (Knowing something about Williams’s life can help some in understanding some things about the plays, but enjoying them doesn’t depend on being a Williams expert.) At the end of that discussion, Kirk cautions us not to treat Williams’s plays “as chapters in Williams’ memoirs.” Of course, he’s absolutely correct. The plays (and poems and short stories) are self-contained works of art, no more accounts of the playwright’s life than The Lord of the Rings was an account of Tolkien’s life. But I want to add one remark, only slightly relevant (and perhaps not even that): Williams’s actual Memoirs, his published autobiography, is largely regarded as heavily fictionalized. Williams told so many tales about his background, starting with his name (actually Tom) and the year of his birth (actually 1911, not 1914 as he put out for many years), that I suspect he began to forget what was a yarn and what was true. My point? Not only can’t Williams’s fiction be taken as fact, but even his fact can’t be taken as fact! (I’m just sayin’.)
Kirk also addresses the issue of reviewers asserting that they can somehow glean how other people (including the artists themselves as well as other viewers) feel and what they think. Just recently, for example, in his review of the Brighton Beach Memoirs revival, Ben Brantley committed this fault when he said of one actor that “her performance is so subdued and inward-looking that when [she] finally erupts, you don’t believe it” (I added the italics). How does Brantley know what I will believe if and when I see the play? How does he know what anyone else, even his fellow spectators that night, believes? He can’t. He can only know what he himself believes. He has no business speaking for anyone else!
I took this problem up on ROT as well. What I proposed is that reviewers write in first person so that they are less tempted to make universal statements and maintain the perception that they are writing about themselves and their own impressions. (Brantley could have written, “. . . I don’t believe it.”) The problem is, of course, that editors and publishers seldom allow writers like reviewers to write in first person. Opinion columnists, and I maintain that that’s really what reviewers are, are perfectly free to write that way, but reviewers rarely are. It’s harder to do when you can’t use the grammatical first person, but the alternative approach has to be to make sure the “first-personness” of the review is rhetorically clear. (In which case, Brantley could have written, “. . . it’s hard to believe.”)
In a section about clever remarks, put-downs, and personal insults in reviews, Kirk invokes a famous reviewer “who most consistently writes in terms of insults”; he doesn’t name the writer, but most of us probably know who he is, and since ROT isn’t as vulnerable to retribution, legal or otherwise, I will name him: John Simon. I had a bit of a contretemps in print with Simon back in 1989, precipitated by his review of The Winter’s Tale at the New York Shakespeare Festival. I won’t repeat Simon’s revolting remarks about the actress Alfre Woodard, who played Paulina in the production, but I will characterize them as racist and mean, referring to her hair (which was a wig) and her vocal performance. Simon invoked the vilest racial images to make his points. (Simon also said some very insulting things about Mandy Patinkin, who played Leontes opposite Christopher Reeve’s Polixenes, making reference to some scurrilous Nazi caricatures of Jews.) Almost the entire theater community rose up in protest, with several columnists writing rebukes and well-known theater figures like Colleen Dewhurst, Eli Wallach, and Anne Jackson writing letters. I also wrote a long letter to all the press outlets in New York; it was published in a substantial excerpt in the New York Post (12 April) and in its entirety in the New York Native (22 May), where I published my reviews at the time. I wrote: “Invoking negative racial and ethnic stereotypes to make small points about coiffure or vocal technique . . . is completely outrageous in this supposedly enlightened time. Cruelty of this kind, regardless of the point Mr. Simon may have been trying to make, is inexcusable in our society.”
Simon’s review came out on 3 April. I had also written a review of the play which appeared on the same date but since the Native was a weekly, my deadline was long before I ever saw Simon’s notice. I had liked the production. On 19 June, however, my review of another NYSF production, Cymbeline (part of NYSF’s then-ongoing marathon of all Shakespeare’s plays over about a decade), came out in the Native and unbeknownst to me, the editors had put a banner headline on the front page of the edition saying, “Hey, John Simon: We Loved Cymbeline.” Simon had obviously panned Cymbeline (12 June)--it was a controversial production under the direction of JoAnne Akalaitis--but the banner was clearly more directed at my difference of opinion with Simon over Winter’s Tale. In any case, New York didn’t run my letter and I never heard from Simon in any way. I’m sure I was beneath his notice. (That’s all right. He’s beneath my contempt. One of his earlier reviews soon after I moved to New York City--I forget now which one--so incensed me that I cancelled my subscription to New York and have never gone back to it.)
By the way, in a later section on “The newspaper’s mistakes,” Kirk points out that “reviewers often are not responsible for headlines” and other accompaniments to their columns. That’s true not only of reviewers but almost all journalistic writers; there are editors whose job it is to oversee the composition of headlines and such. (Most of my reviews did appear under headlines of my own devising, however.) I not only had no hand in writing that banner about Cymbeline that baited John Simon, but I didn’t even know about it until the issue came out. Since my deadline was often 10 days before the issue date, I’d written my copy before Simon’s negative review of Cymbeline hit the stands. (As I said, I no longer subscribed to New York magazine and didn’t seek out Simon’s reviews anyway; I wouldn’t have known about his response to the play until someone told me about it.)
Following this discussion in Writing Reviews, Kirk also raises the issue of “color-blind casting,” another problem John Simon has. I raised an objection to his shortsightedness and benighted attitude in the same letter, but a few years later, in 1991, the magazine The World & I, published by the Washington Times (owned by the Moonies), ran an article, “Nontraditional Casting” by David H. Ehrlich, which took the same viewpoint as Simon--that roles should only be cast with actors of the same race specified for the character. (If no race is specified, the role is presumed to have been written for a white actor.) I wrote another long letter to the editor of The World & I, and though they never published it, the author of the article called me. I didn’t want to get into a debate with him, so I just suggested that his editors run my letter and we could have our conversation in print. What the arch-conservative publication didn’t print included this statement:
[W]hat Mr. Ehrlich’s essay, reduced to its most basic terms, really says is that African-American actors (and Hispanic, Asian, disabled and women actors, by extension) are fine, as long as they keep to their places. Let them do August Wilson and Spike Lee, and the occasional Othello (but not Iago); however, they had better stay away from White Plays. If that sounds like saying black people are OK as long as they do not move next door to me and marry my sister, you get full marks.
(The comment above about Othello and Iago was in reference to a production of the Shakespeare tragedy by the Folger Theatre Group, the forerunner of the Shakespeare Theatre Company, which cast Avery Brooks as the Moor and André Braugher as his ancient. Ehrlich had trouble with this pairing.)
In a related section, Kirk inveighs against reviewers who have an obsession with something and “drag it into review after review.” Kirk’s talking about general idées fixes, like Clive Barnes’s reputed preference for anything British, but sometimes they’re more transitory. As I wrote recently in an August posting on ROT:
I remember back in ’98 when Footloose opened on Broadway, Ben Brantley panned the show and ever thereafter, at every opportunity he had in subsequent columns, Brantley ran the play down in the most derogatory terms he could get away with. He seemed obsessed with this play and the low opinion he had of it.
I don’t know what was going through Brantley’s mind at the time, of course, but I kept thinking that he was actually trying to close the show. Despite Brantley’s efforts, however, Footloose (which I didn’t like much myself, though it never offended me) ran for a year-and-a-half and 709 performances. It was nominated for four Tonys and didn’t win any of them, so maybe Brantley could take some pride in that dubious accomplishment.
And speaking about closing shows because of reviews, in a section called “Worrying about effect,” Kirk addresses the matter of how reviewers cope with the sense that they may be influencing people’s futures. I just want to point out that this very question was the subject of my essay "The Power of the Reviewer," which I mentioned above. My conclusion, by the way, was that the power of reviews to close productions was largely an untested assumption and that there were many viable strategies that producers could use to combat mediocre press. (I related one earlier: the hoax David Merrick pulled--he liked to put things over on the press--that may have helped extend the run of the poorly-reviewed Subways Are for Sleeping. But there are more legitimate tactics as well.) And Kirk is right when he reports that some reviewers “deny that they have any economic effect at all.” In a 1969 survey (the last time I looked, there weren’t any newer ones), only two-thirds of reviewers (of all arts, not just theater), said they had an economic impact. On the other hand, another survey found that 60% of spectators questioned said that reviews were of minimal importance to their choices. A 1977 study by More magazine (now defunct) attempted to find a correlation between the quality of the reviews and the length of a play’s run. The results weren’t conclusive, but they found, “When the critics expressed a strong negative [i.e., a pan] or positive [a rave] opinion about a play, there was a marked correlation with the length of run.” (I had some reservations about this study, which I expressed in the essay.)
[Come back in a few days for Part 4 of my commentary on Writing Reviews. There’s still more to say.]
[This is Part 2 of my commentary on Kirk Woodward’s book, The Art of Writing Reviews (http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback-book/the-art-of-writing-reviews/6785272). There will be four parts in all.]
When Kirk sets out that the fundamental duties of reviews are to “experience, describe, and, finally, evaluate” what they see, he praises the reviewers who “start out by genuinely participating, through their imaginations, in the works in front of them.” Every theater pro wants spectators, including reviewers, to get into the world of the play, to enter into the performance so that they have a virtual experience in the theater. We don’t want someone to come to a farce, say, and demand logic and reason or to a 19th-century drama and complain because the characters aren’t behaving according to 21st-century codes. But letting their imaginations take over too completely can be a danger, too. I remember reading a play review by Ben Brantley a number of years ago in which he went to great lengths to specify the aromas he imagined wafting about the stage and he connected those scent images to his own associations. I suppose that’s fine for a spectator’s private experience--you make the associations that have meaning for you--but when the spectator writes about that performance for my consumption, I get the impression that the reviewer was experiencing this play entirely inside his own head, not in a seat at the theater where I might join him. I can’t share the experience he’s having in his imagination. The greater implication of this instance, which confirmed for me a suspicion I’d had about Brantley’s reviews--that he wasn’t seeing the same performances I was--is that it has made me skeptical of all Brantley’s descriptions because I wonder if he’s writing about what he actually saw on stage, or just in his imagination. However engaged in the performance we may get--and engagement is a good thing, even for a reviewer--a part of us has to remain in the real world. (That would be the real world of theater, not all that nonsense going on outside. Heavens! Who’d want that?)
After suggesting that the only way to be sure that “reviewers are genuinely experiencing what they describe” (see above) is to see the play before the notices appear, Kirk observes, “Some kind of artistic Heisenberg principle is at work here: being reviewed changes the nature of the piece itself.” This reminds me of something a director whose work I researched, Leonardo Shapiro, told me in an interview:
What changes the audience the most is the review. The New York audience is much blander and much more sophisticated and much less exciting after the reviews. Before the reviews, they’re really a lot like other audiences; they’re much more alive. . . . It’s amazing. I don’t know how they all get to read the reviews, but the change in the audience is so clear. When the reviewer comes and says it’s funny, the next night they laugh. I swear to you. It’s just like a script.
Throughout Writing Reviews, Kirk names some of the reviewers he admires (and some of those of whom he doesn’t think all that much) and these names come up several times. He spotlights Brooks Atkinson, the chief theater reviewer for the New York Times from the ‘20s through the ‘50s, whom Kirk calls “the Walter Cronkite of reviewing.” Kirk also praises music reviewer Whitney Bartlett of the New Yorker for his writing about jazz. I’d like to add a few less-prominent names to Kirk’s list. I’ve already mentioned Elvis Mitchell, a film reviewer for the New York Times from 1998 to 2004, who always had a surprising turn of phrase or an unexpected expression in his writing that made it interesting to read quite aside from his opinion of the film he was covering. I also used to admire Dennis Cunningham, who reviewed both theater and movies for WCBS-TV in New York from 1978 to 2000, because his theater reviews especially were little arguments for his perspective. By argument, I don’t mean that he got contentious over his opinions, but that he always presented evidence from the performance to illustrate or support his remarks. Another reviewer whose work I have liked is Marcia Siegel, a dance writer. I’m not a follower of dance, but Siegel’s reviews are always very clear, descriptive, and communicative, especially for a non-dance person like me. When I write about theater, I try to follow her example by writing for the reader who may see a play, but doesn’t know anything about the art itself--the uninitiated reader. (Full disclosure: Siegel was on the faculty of NYU’s Department of Performance Studies while I was there and I audited a class from her, Writing about Performance. It has had a profound effect on my theater writing.)
Oh, and that reminds me, speaking of Brooks Atkinson: He was the most important theater writer of his day, and he also had the most unique name among New York newspaper reviewers. (This was, of course, before Manohla Dargis joined the film department of the Times. Or Joe Dziemianowicz came to the Daily News.) Some of you may know the story of the famous 1962 fake-quote ad for Subways Are for Sleeping. For those who missed this wonderful bit of New York theater trivia, Press Agent Harvey Sabinson and Producer David Merrick hired ordinary New Yorkers with the same names as Walter Kerr; Howard Taubman; Richard Watts, Jr.; and the other major New York newspaper reviewers, treated them to the new musical--which had gotten poor notices after opening--and then wined and dined them. Getting the group to say great things about the show, the producer and his press agent wrote a display ad for the papers with appropriate laudatory quotations. Because the ad included photos of the ringers, only the Herald Tribune didn’t spot the gag and ran the ad. The pair had planned such a stunt for years, but could never pull it off because they knew "in all this world there is no other man with [the] name" Brooks Atkinson. They had to wait until Atkinson retired to pull the hoax. (This anecdote has nothing whatsoever to do with the art of writing reviews, but it has something to do with Brooks Atkinson! It was just one of those things the book made me think about when I read it. See what I mean?)
Kirk returns to the problem of reviewers who settle into a “comfort zone” and aren’t receptive to innovations that “may break new ground.” I’ve already noted the objections raised by Michael Kirby, Richard Kostelanetz, and Ross Wetzsteon. To return to Kostelanetz’s analysis, he saw that “the more imposing artists [of the experimental theater] have rejected traditional notions of beauty as too sentimental and quaint, and, in contrast, audiences and critics would sooner acknowledge the familiar than explore works of art they cannot immediately comprehend.” Kostelanetz, a poet who was also a champion of avant-garde art, attributes this inhospitable stance to the fact that the reviewer “feels more comfortable in reading from the past into the present.” One of the harshest critics of establishment reviewers in New York is Elinor Fuchs, herself a genuine theater critic (and sometime reviewer), scholar, teacher, dramaturg, and writer. In a 1989 essay in American Theatre, she remarked, “New York’s critical establishment seems ever more deeply establishmentarian,” privileging the traditional aesthetics of Western culture to the exclusion of anything non-Western or pioneering. Fuchs continued: “But the establishment critics are no laughing matter, for . . . they are literally driving innovative, daring theatre out of New York.” In conclusion, she wrote:
The lack of curiosity, the disrespect, the indifference--all go to show that the critics don’t seem to know whom to cultivate. . . . . Even in its own venues where it has a devoted following, the avant-garde, experimental or progressive wing (as some now call it) of the New York theatre world continues to be attacked by the press with a vigor one would think familiarity must have dulled by now.
“Reviewers sometimes worry that they’ll say that something accidental is important . . . ,” warns Kirk. Actually, I stopped worrying too much about this after I made note of just such an occurrence in a college show I reviewed for that theater criticism class at Rutgers. The production was Godspell and I described how felicitously the “splashing water from [a] spinning sponge echoed the painted spirals of the backdrop” in front of which the actor was singing “Prepare Ye the Way of the Lord.” Now I had said this was “perhaps a happy accident,” but the teacher of the class, Betty Comtois, told me that even if it had been an accident, it was still legitimate grist for the reviewer’s mill. So I always remember that feedback whenever I see something that I suspect might not have been intended by any of the artists. Kirk advises us, “You can only review what’s there,” but the opposite is also true: You get to review anything that’s there. If it happens on stage, it counts! (Reviewers have “prosecutorial discretion,” of course. We don’t have to mention everything that went on.)
Of course, nothing indemnifies us from writing something that’s just plain dumb. We’re all subject to that. I once wrote in a review of a play about Tennessee Williams that the actor playing “Bird,” as the playwright was called, didn’t have a very authentic New Orleans accent. Well, as I realized later (after the pesky review went to press) that Williams wasn’t from New Orleans; he was born in Mississippi and grew up in St. Louis, Missouri. He lived in the Big Easy, whose natives have very distinctive speech, but talked just like the Mississippian he was. Now that mistake is on the record for all to read, if they happen upon the review. (And, no, I’m not going to help you by naming the play or the periodical.)
Kirk also affirms that “a work of art has the right to the presumption that it’s coherent and meaningful.” Yes, it does. Or, as Ralph Waldo Emerson put the proposition in his essay, “Art”: “And so every genuine work of art has as much reason for being as the earth and the sun.” When reviewers pan a particular work of art, that’s their right--in fact, it’s even their duty as reviewers to call it as they see it. (I once heard a TV film reviewer in Washington revise upwards his estimation of a movie he had previously given a poor notice because it proved to be popular. I lost all respect for him after that.) But when they disparage a whole genre or question the very right of the artist to do the work at all, then they are stepping over a line, I think. A mediocre piece of art is not painting a mustache on the Mona Lisa: no one’s destroyed anything. Poor art isn’t a crime against humanity. (See remarks later from art philosopher Susanne Langer.) The reviewers have lost a little time, but they get paid for that. And let’s not forget, too, that even an experiment that fails has value. Just move on.
When it comes to acting, Kirk tells us, “it’s meaningless to talk about a ‘good’ performance” because the term’s so vague. We should judge performances on their appropriateness to the production (not just the play, mind you) because a “’great’ characterization in one production . . . would likely be hopelessly out of place [in] another . . . .” Now, I’m sure Kirk is talking about different productions of the same play--where Miss Smith’s interpretation of Nora in one production of A Doll House is marvelous but if transferred to another Doll House would be unsuitable. But the same comparison is true of the same actor playing different parts in two plays, say in rep. I went to the Shaw Festival a few years ago and saw eight performances over a week in Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ontario. All of the members of the company perform in at least two plays so I saw many actors do two roles in plays that were often quite different in style and genre. Most of the performers were marvelously flexible and handled the shifts with aplomb. (Generally, the acting at the festival was excellent.) One actor, however, had a distinctive stage style that suited one role much better than the other. I won’t report his name here, but he appeared in The Heiress and then in Arms and the Man. I saw The Heiress first and the actor’s mannerisms and behavioral choices (especially his vocal patterns) seemed entirely fake. When I saw him in Arms, he displayed the same traits, but they worked for his character and the Shaw comedy where they hadn’t worked in the melodrama.
Kirk draws attention to the responsibility of the director, an artist whose work is hard to analyze for many spectators who have never acted or directed themselves. (That difficulty was the rationale for the founding of the American Directors Institute, a professional association whose newsletter I edited. ADI, sadly, disbanded after only a few years, but its stated purpose was, in part, to try to elucidate the work of the stage director not only to the theater-going public but also other theater artists.) Anyway, Kirk remarks that there are some directors “who seem to feel that their work is the part and the whole of a production.” I presume he’s referring to the so-called auteur director. (Film is full of that kind of director.) I guess that the models for this kind of director would be Vsevolod Meyerhold and, more recently, Jerzy Grotowski. In fact, Meyerhold, who often called himself the “author of the production,” said that “the art of the director is the art not of an executant, but of an author--so long as one has earned the right.”
When he makes a point about artists making choices, Kirk uses The Glass Menagerie as an example. It’s not strictly relevant to the author’s point, but it’s interesting to note two things about GM. First, Williams originally wrote the script as a screenplay (for Lana Turner) when he worked briefly at MGM. (When the play came out and was a success, MGM tried to claim the rights under the argument that Williams had written it while he was the studio’s employee. Williams’s stalwart, and sometimes quite fierce, agent, Audrey Wood, defeated the effort.) Second, Williams’s original concept for the play was quite Brechtian, with scene titles and other distancing techniques. The director, Joe Dowling, removed all that from the première production in 1947, in the belief that Broadway audiences wouldn’t accept the innovations. (Some recent productions of the play have restored the Brechtian elements, with some success, I believe.) Choices, as we see, are not made in a vacuum, and sometimes they’re made for reasons far from artistic.
And speaking of Tennessee Williams, he made a poignant statement that supports something else Kirk writes in Writing Reviews. Kirk cautions reviewers to resist comparing an artist’s work with what the artist had done earlier. In 1951, after his great successes with Menagerie and Streetcar, Williams had begun to try new things. But the reviewers wouldn’t tolerate the shift, insisting that the playwright stick with what he’d done so successfully in the beginning. Angry over the reviews of The Rose Tattoo, which had just opened, Williams wrote a letter to columnist Max Lerner, complaining about “the most demoralizing problem that the American playwright has to face.” The dramatist continued: “Painters have it better. They are allowed to evolve new methods, new styles, by a reasonable gradual process. They are not abused for turning out creative variations of themes already stated.”
Then Kirk continues by admonishing us, “An artist has no responsibility to improve.” That’s right, of course. Artists aren’t obligated to us or anyone to get better or move up or anything. (In fact, they’re not even obligated to continue. Remember Wit? Margaret Edson wrote this one terrific play, it won a Pulitzer in 1999--and a passel of other awards--and then she went back to teaching kindergarten in Atlanta. She said she had one play she wanted to write, she wrote it, now she’s done.) But this point raises a question. Actually, it begs the question, How do we measure improvement? How do we recognize improvement? Who gets to define improvement? What if Tennessee Williams had gotten to try out his new ideas--as he did eventually with Camino Real? Was his absurdist play an “improvement” on Streetcar or even Rose Tattoo? I don’t know. It’s different, I know that. I think it’s harder to perform successfully. But those aren’t issues of improvement, just of difference. The reviews of Camino Real ranged from confusion to dismissal, and the play languished for years until the rest of the theater in this country caught up with it. (It opened in New York a few years before Beckett’s Waiting for Godot, which had its own problems with audiences and reviewers.) Aside from the question of whether any of that marks “improvement,” there’s also the fact that any artist must often stumble and fall a few times before moving on to new accomplishments. Improvement, even if we could measure it, wouldn’t come in a straight line anyway. (By the way, my answers to those questions above? We can’t. We don’t. No one.)
In this same discussion, Kirk states, “I hate to see the increasing number of competitions--literally--in the arts . . . .” Back in August I posted a piece about the Tony committee’s removal of the press from the Tony voter list. At the top of that column, I wrote, “I reject the whole idea of turning art into a competition . . . .” I’m less upset with the marketing awards and titles like best-sellers, Gold Records, and the Nielson ratings because, first, they’re based on concrete evidence and, second, they don’t pretend to be based on a judgment of excellence but only popularity. (As we all recognize, popularity doesn’t always equate with excellence. Just look at the evidence offered by some TV shows and movies.) But it offends me to see artists and their work placed in competition with one another. Art isn’t a sports contest. Obviously Kirk and I must be in a minority in this opinion because the contests and awards seem to be proliferating. (Especially in the music business--there seems to an award for every perspective or category anyone can devise.)
Writing Reviews also addresses prejudices among reviewers and its author warns that pet peeves are dangerous for a reviewer. He doesn’t say so, but the same is true of prejudices for a kind of work. I love the old-time musicals--Oklahoma!, West Side Story, My Fair Lady, and even some less well-known ones like Donnybrook! and Little Mary Sunshine. See, the problem is that I have no objectivity, no distance from these shows. I started out with them when I was little--my first show on Broadway was Fiorello! when I was 10 (having already seen pre- and post-Broadway tours at the old National Theatre in Washington from an earlier age), and I can’t judge them at all fairly, even in a mediocre production. (A really bad one, I might notice.) Take me to Damn Yankees or Camelot, and I’m just gonna gush, almost no matter what. (On the other hand, I have attention problems with 19th-century melodramas, and I don’t much enjoy monodramas, with exceptions for extraordinary performances like Henry Fonda in Clarence Darrow or Pat Carroll as Gertrude Stein.) The thing is, when I’ve had to review shows with which I know I’ll have trouble, if I couldn’t get out of the assignment, I’ve always tried to admit right up front that I probably wasn’t the best person to assess the performance. Then I tried to confine myself to describing the experience more than evaluating it so I could let the readers make up their own minds about seeing the play.
There’s one subject for any performance--movie, TV show, or play--about which I have so much private baggage that I just stay away: the Holocaust. Kirk confesses to an “antipathy” for violent movies; I can’t watch any Holocaust story (or even look at a collection of Holocaust-related photographs) without getting so angry that I come close to losing control. (On a trip to Israel years ago, I had to leave Yad Vashem because I was beginning to shake with anger.) I don’t like feeling that way--it actually scares me--so I seldom watch that kind of stuff anymore. I certainly could never review a play or movie on the topic because my objectivity about the artwork would be nonexistent. (Interestingly, I didn’t have the same kind of problem with My Name Is Rachel Corrie. I didn’t like that piece because it was bad theater, inherently untheatrical and undramatic.)
[Come back in a few days for Part 3 of my commentary on Writing Reviews. There’s still more to say.]
In June of this year, my friend Kirk Woodward published a book on reviewing. I’ve mentioned Kirk before on several occasions. He’s a playwright, composer, director, teacher, and actor (and, most recently, a “guest blogger” for ROT--see 5 October), and we went to college together back in the middle of the last century. When he announced the release of The Art of Writing Reviews, I approached it with trepidation because . . . What if I didn’t like it? What would I say to him? Or, just as terrifying, What if he dissed everything I had done when I wrote reviews. We’d never talked about this except in passing, so I had no idea what he thought about writing theater reviews (much less any other kind). How would I feel if Kirk’s ideas about writing good reviews were basically the opposite of what I’d been practicing? (As a matter of full disclosure, I don’t consider what I post on ROT to be reviews. Kirk says they come close to “criticism,” but I demur. I call them “play reports” and disobligate myself from all the conventions and restraints of proper reviewing. What I published in the ‘80s and ‘90s were reviews.)
Well, okay, none of that happened. In fact, I couldn’t have agreed more with just about everything my friend--a brilliant analyst and commentator, clearly--said about good review-writing. (Both Kirk and I share the notion that there’s a profound difference between reviewing and criticism and that what we’re talking about here and in Kirk’s book is reviewing. I’ll let you read The Art of Writing Reviews to get a full definition of the distinction.) But I’m not going to write a review of Kirk’s book or even critique it in general terms. What I’m going to do is have a sort of one-sided conversation with him by commenting on some of the things he’s said in Writing Reviews that jogged my mind as I read it. It made me think about all kinds of things. That's a good thing, I think: When I used to teach writing in college, I told my students that writing, especially essay-writing, was a sort of conversation between the writer and the reader(s). It's what an essay is supposed to do: make the reader think, look at something from a fresh angle, ask questions. In an extended version, the "reader" would write another essay in response (the other side of the conversation), then the original writer or another essayist would chime in, and so on. Books sometimes respond to other books, too (though the process is longer). Well, this is a perfect example of that, and this post will be my contribution to the conversation.
First, however, let me include a little about the book itself, to set the scene, so to speak. Here’s what the author, himself, says:
Considering how many reviews are written each day--for newspapers, magazines, broadcast outlets, and, overwhelmingly, for the Internet--there is remarkably little written about the art of writing reviews itself.
This book considers the differences between reviews and criticism, and looks at the fundamental tasks of the reviewer: experiencing, describing, and evaluating. It examines some of the major problems, misconceptions, and bad habits involved in creating reviews, and discusses the structure of the review itself.
Finally, by placing reviewing in a larger context, the book becomes an exploration of the nature of art itself, and of our place in it.
As for anything more, I’ll address that as I come to it in my remarks here. Of course, to get the full impact, I strongly recommend reading the whole book (which is short, “an extended essay,” says Kirk--what I’d call a monograph). It’s chatty and easy to read--no academic language and little theatrical jargon--and only 61 pages long. You can read it in one sitting or, if you’re like me and impelled to make marginal notes and comments, maybe a couple of days’ sessions. You can order it or download it at http://www.lulu.com/content/paperback-book/the-art-of-writing-reviews/6785272; it isn’t available from bookstores, Amazon.com, or BarnesandNoble.com (and I doubt it’s made it into many libraries yet). As Kirk suggests, the book has practical value for anyone who wants to write reviews, is already writing them, or is just interested in reviewing as “a form of writing.” There’s both sound advice and theoretical reflection in Writing Reviews and all of it’s worth reading, even if you end up disagreeing with Kirk and me.
As for my anticipatory trepidations, all I can say is that my first reaction was, Wow, what a good job! I’ve often copped to succumbing to Schadenfreude, taking pleasure in the misfortunes of others. But that’s only for people I don’t like. When a friend does well, I’m thrilled! So, let me take up the conversation in medias res, as the lit folks say, and jump in. I’ll just follow along with Kirk’s structure and sound off along the way, step by step.
At the outset, Kirk remarks that there are no books and few articles on the art of reviewing--“How To’s,” as it were. He’s right, as it happens, but there are lots of courses and academic programs on the subject. Yale even offers a DFA in criticism, I believe. (Jonathan Kalb of the Village Voice is a graduate of the YSD program.) What do they use for texts and reading materials? (In my one “criticism” class at Rutgers, where I got an MFA, we mostly read other reviewers--few works "on" reviewing.) There are a few articles by reviewers on reviewing: an entire issue of Yale/Theatre (the predecessor to Theater), "American Drama Criticism" (vol. 4, # 2, Spring 1973) contains essays by Stanley Kauffmann, Eric Bentley, Robert Brustein, and Martin Gottfried, among others; the September 2001 issue of American Theatre (Vol. 18, # 7) includes eight essays on "Understanding Critics" by reviewers like Frank Rich and Kalb. A more theoretical piece, which proposes a different approach to reviewing than is commonly practiced, is Michael Kirby’s “Criticism: Four Faults” (Drama Review 18.4 [T63 - Dec. 1974]: 59-68). (My own short essay, “On Reviewing,” was posted on ROT on 22 March.) But essentially Kirk’s correct; there’s no Reviewers on Reviewing or Critics on Criticism on the shelves. (I did considerable research some years ago on the subject of theater reviewers and critics for my essay "The Power of the Reviewer: Myth or Fact?" [Theatre History Studies 18 (June 1998): 13-38] and I covered the available literature at the time. There was little 10 years ago, and I don’t think the situation has changed much since.)
One of the first things Kirk says is that writing is a way of figuring out what we think. (He repeats this later, too, near the end of Writing Reviews.) That was another thing I used to tell my students (especially when I assigned a journal as a course requirement). I used to paraphrase Gracie Allen--maybe some of you remember this one: "How do I know what I think until I hear what I say?" I made it about writing instead of talking, but the sentiment's the same. I’ve certainly found this to be true of writing reviews (or, in my case these days, my play reports). When my friends first asked me to write them about what I was seeing here in New York, I discovered that I enjoyed trying to sort out what I saw and what my response was. Trying to describe the performance so that someone who wasn’t there can picture it, which is sort of my special focus, became a way to figure out what I’d experienced . . . and why. Sometimes--even often, I’d say--I didn’t know what I thought of a performance, at least not beyond a vague feeling, until I began writing my report. I knew I had to make the experience clear to people who hadn’t seen it, and that really focused my mind. Since the people I was writing for, before ROT, all knew my e-mail address and could (and often did) write me back with comments and questions, I also anticipated what they’d be thinking while they were reading my description. That was a particularly interesting exercise in writing for an audience: all the recipients were theater people, so they knew a lot on the subject, but one’s a former Brit who lives in Israel and another’s an Indian in Kolkata. I became very conscious of my pop culture references and my diction, especially slang and colloquialisms. So not only did writing help me sort out what I think, but it made me pay attention to how I express the thoughts.
Early in Writing Reviews, Kirk observes that the “blurring of boundaries [between art forms] can confuse a reviewer.” This is the same phenomenon that author Richard Kostelanetz discusses in some detail in The Theatre of Mixed Means (Dial Press, 1968). “Since the critic must now respond to dance, film, theatre, and music all at once,” Kostelanetz writes, “criticism of the new work has been sparse and, when in print, meager in perception.” Reviewers knowledgeable about only one performance genre are “monoliterate,” thinks Kostelanetz, which is the same as what Ross Wetzsteon, the late and esteemed Village Voice reviewer and theater editor, calls “illiterate.” Reviewers, Kostelanetz insists, must be “polyliterate,” and, faced with a theater that incorporates all kinds of new techniques, themes, and ideas, those who aren’t should “be humbled by our perceptual illiteracy.” Reviewing, Wetzsteon lamented in 1989, “has simply not kept pace with the theatre it claims to evaluate.” Not a few critics of newspaper reviewers find this a failing to be heartily deplored.
Kirk goes on to ask if there should even be “landmarks” and “touchstones” in the arts about which reviewers write. “Learning the elements of an art is learning what’s already been done,” writes Kirk. This is one of the “four faults” Michael Kirby recognizes in theatrical reviewing (he called it criticism, as most people do . . . but we won’t): reviewers who make the claim that they’re upholding universal standards perpetuate the cultural status quo by privileging “what has been thought to be ‘good’ and ‘beautiful’ in the past” while “stifling” innovation and experimentation. (If you didn’t know it already, you might guess that Kirby was an avant-garde playwright, among other things.) But whose standards are the ones the reviewers impose on the rest of us? Kirby insists they are the reviewers’ own, and so he calls them “arrogant” and accuses them of “fascism of taste.” We might remember that the very “standards” such reviewers praise and want to entrench were themselves once radical innovations, often condemned when they first appeared on stage or on canvas. (Ibsen’s Realism caused riots when it first appeared in print. But, then, so had Victor Hugo’s Romanticism. Go know!) The truth changes.
I do have one caveat, however. While holding only to old standards may be anti-progressive and destructive, we can’t forget the old just because something new has come along--even something new and great. The new is often built on the old, like ancient cities. Kirk writes, “What [new work] won’t be like . . . is what’s gone before it,” by which he means we can’t predict what’s coming down the road based on what we’ve seen already. Of course, he’s absolutely right. But note one axiom: Imagination is new combinations of things known. (I don’t know who said that. Actually, I do know who said it--an acting teacher of mine named Aaron Frankel--I just don’t know who said it first.) Almost nothing we can conjure up, the most horrible monster or the most fantastic machine, isn’t made up of bits and pieces of things we’ve already experienced. We create the new out of bits of the old. We wipe the slate totally clean at our own peril.
In his discussion of the differences between a critic and a reviewer, Kirk states, “In other words, a reviewer offers product advice, telling you whether you should spend your valuable time and your hard-earned money on a particular event.” That’s the “consumer reporter” mode of reviewing, and it’s one of the ways some reviewers see their function. According to surveys, most reviewers see themselves as journalists, that is reporters writing about a news event. Some see themselves as a kind of artist, a writer of the art of criticism. A few simply deny that they have any more influence than the guy who evaluates blenders and can-openers for Consumer Reports. Obviously, the way you see yourself in the profession makes a difference in how you will approach your craft and execute your responsibilities. Which is better? I don’t know; I guess it depends on what the reader wants from your efforts. I suppose the thumbs up-thumbs down consumer report is easiest. Covering the event of a play performance like a news reporter is harder but there’s less of you invested in the outcome. Reporters, after all, aren’t supposed to get invested in the story. Trying to craft a well-written piece of prose that expresses not just the facts of the event but some of the effect it had on you, some of the atmosphere surrounding the event, some of the . . . well, meaning, I guess--maybe that’s not the hardest approach if you’re a talented writer, but there’s more of your ego invested in the end result. I think that’s hard, but that’s what I’d go with. (Okay, editors and publishers have a say, but let’s pretend they don’t.)
As Kirk points out, things have changed on Broadway with respect to opening-night reviews. The “overnight” copy has gone with the copy boy and the press card in the hatband. Now that out-of-town tryouts are mostly a thing of the past (too expensive and too risky), replaced with previews right here in the Big Apple, reviewers no longer have to come to opening night and then rush off to the typewriter (okay, the wordprocessor--I’m hip!) and bash out their deathless prose for a midnight deadline. Now they all go to previews before the play opens and write up their evaluations with a little leisure. (Second-nighters have it even easier, of course. They have a week or more to write their reviews--but they always did.) Staff is shrinking and space is getting cut, but there’s more time now to do the work. But there’s a trade-off. Even when the producers charge the same for a seat at the preview as they do for post-opening tickets, they’re still previews. You’re watching a dress rehearsal, you understand. The cast is still working, and sometimes things haven’t gelled--might even be changed before opening. Reviewers who see a performance before opening night aren’t seeing the finished product. That’s why, in the old days, they had tryouts outside New York City--to give the actors, the director, and the playwright time to fix things that aren’t right. Costumes and sets have been known to be completely rebuilt overnight. It’s not different just because those preliminary performances are now in a New York theater instead of Philly, Boston, or Baltimo’. Even now that I’m not reviewing for anyone, I still insist on seeing shows after they open unless I can’t help it. I know I’ve seen shows that were different from the ones the reviewers wrote about--and not just because we have eyes and brains that aren’t calibrated the same. (See my remarks later on concerning Heraclitus of Ephasus.) Because they saw a pre-season exhibition game and I saw one after the season started--one that counted. (Kirk has a similar admonition later in the book when he writes about those out-of-town tryouts, which some reviewers attend.)
“Sometimes reviewers write both a daily review and a longer weekend-issue or opinion piece,” notes Kirk. The author suggests that the reviewers who do this use the longer column to expand on the thoughts they expressed more briefly in the shorter, daily review. Yeah, and sometimes they just use the second piece to nail a show they didn’t like one more time, just to be sure we got their point. On Thursday, 3 April 1975, for instance, the late Douglas Watt wrote in the Daily News: “Last night some young hopefuls . . . mangled Ibsen’s ‘Ghosts’ under the auspices of Papp and the New York Shakespeare Festival . . . .” He went on at length in the same vein. But that wasn’t sufficient for Watt, so in the Sunday News on 13 April, he slammed the production again: “[The] week before last down on Lafayette Street at the Public Theater . . . a clutch of seemingly demented actors grabbed hold of Ibsen’s ‘Ghosts’ and flung it around . . . as if it were an idiotic farce.” A year earlier, Watt had done the same thing to the same troupe, writing first on Wednesday, 16 October 1974: “Bertolt Brecht is on us again, this time with a noisy and tiresome 75-minute construction titled ‘The Measures Taken.’” Once not being enough, Watt wrote again on Sunday, 8 December, that the actors “are sadly lacking, for the most part” and that the play “fails to involve the spectator in human terms.” It’s nice Watt, who died on 29 September (at 95), had the extra column inches to twist the knife a little.
Kirk claims that he wrote reviews but had “no skill or experience.” I take exception to that self-characterization. Okay, I understand he’s making a point, and I also understand that he literally had no background in review-writing. But he acknowledges that few newspaper reviewers have specialized training or backgrounds--they get it OTJ. What Kirk had, just as what I had when I did that job, is a pretty good knowledge of theater, especially acting, directing, and playwriting, and some skill as a writer. That's a sufficient background for a reviewer, at least to start with; we can gain more as we see more theater and try to do what Kirk describes in the book. There are reviewers who have not had even those qualification--I daresay there have been newspaper reviewers who never saw a live play before they got the gig, though they probably didn't write for a major daily at that point. There are many I could name who are terrible writers (I never thought, for instance, that Frank Rich, for all his authority as the Times chief reviewer, was a very good writer), even if they did have some experience in theater. (There was a Times film reviewer recently, Elvis Mitchell, who I thought was a terrific writer--but he left the paper after a stay of only six years.)
When I wrote reviews, the only special training I had was one class in "criticism" at Rutgers. I took it merely because we MFA-types were required to take one academic-type (i.e., readin'-'n'-writin') class in our two-year program, and I had the choice in the semester I decided to fulfill the obligation of a theater history class or criticism. (It was “reviewing,” but the department called it “criticism.” As I’ve told Kirk, you just can’t fight city hall on this.) I figured I'd had enough theater history at that point, so the process of elimination led me to the criticism class. That was the extent of my training--and no editors ever asked me about it when they hired me to write. (In one case I got in on the recommendation of a former professor alone; in another, I think I may have sent the editor some samples of my writing, but I may not have done even that.) When I edited Directors Notes, a newsletter for directors and artistic directors, I interviewed with the head of the organization, but he never looked at anything I wrote or examined my academic background, either. I certainly never edited anything, much less had a load of experience writing about theater--this was between reviewing gigs--and I ended up editing two newsletters at the same time! (I was appointed to the vice presidency for communications of LMDA when the post became vacant, and one ex-officio job was to put out the newsletter.) In both the reviewing jobs and the editing jobs, I pretty much flew by the seat of my pants, but I did rely on whatever skill I had picked up by then as a writer and my practical knowledge and experience of theater. I've occasionally looked back at some of my old reviews and I don't think I did half bad.
I think Kirk and I both had the requisite skill and experience to be reviewers. As a matter of fact, if we look into the backgrounds of the famous reviewers he cites, I'll bet we'd find that most, if not almost all, had academic backgrounds that had no bearing on theater or reviewing--if they had an academic background at all, as Kirk mentions. (Shaw, perhaps the best writer among all English-language reviewers, ended his formal education before high school. Frank Rich studied history and lit at Harvard, though he did work at the Crimson; Jonathan Kalb, as I mentioned earlier, has a DFA from the YSD. However, I already said I didn't think Rich was a good writer, and I didn't think he was a very good reviewer; and Kalb is arrogant and pompous in my opinion, so they're not such great examples of the profession, whatever their backgrounds.) I'll just bet that Stanley Kauffmann and Brooks Atkinson and most of the others of that era were newspapermen, reporters, before they got into theater reviewing.
[There’s more to come. The Art of Writing Reviews prompted me to many marginal comments and the next installment will be available in a few days. Tune in again for more theater pith and moment.]