10 July 2018

Gres Gallery, Part 2


[Welcome to the second part of “Gres Gallery,” my account of the history of the small modern-art gallery in Washington, D.C., of which my parents were part-owners in the late 1950s and early 1960s.  (I strongly recommend that ROTters who haven’t read Part 1, posted on 7 July, go back and catch up before proceeding to Part 2 below.)  The account picks up right where I left off at the end of the first half, beginning here with the start of 1959, the middle of Gres Gallery’s first season under the new ownership that included my folks.  You’ll see that things heated up a little for the gallery almost right away because of international politics and world affairs.]

Gres’s first show of 1959, Matta, opened on 22 January as an effective celebration of Gres’s reincorporation under its new directorship and with its new group of shareholders.  The Washington Post’s Leslie Judd Portner declared the first show of the new year “an excellent selection of Matta’s work over the years, showing not only the continuing development of this extraordinary painter but also each period at its best.”  The show of Roberto Matta’s surrealistic paintings ran until 18 February, but on 16 February Washington held its first Jazz Jubilee, the patrons for which were First Lady Mamie Eisenhower and the wives of several other high-ranking federal officials.  The musical fête was held at Washington’s Sheraton-Park Hotel, the largest hotel in the Nation’s Capital, and was accompanied around town by various other cultural events tied to the theme of jazz music one way or another—a lecture, a memorabilia exhibition, and Gres Gallery’s Rhythm in Form and Music, an exhibit of African sculpture and woodcarving from 12 to 31 March (including a week’s extension). 

The art show was “accompanied by taped music of African rhythms and modern jazz counterparts . . . .”  The exhibit “attempts to show the close interrelation between music and visual art . . . .”  The director of the Library of Congress’s Music Division, Harold Spivacke, selected the recordings and Post art critic Leslie Judd Ahlander (formerly Portner; the review-writer married the Swedish cultural attaché, Björn Ahlander, in January) assured readers, “The impact of sight and sound will be an unforgettable experience.”  (I don’t remember this exhibit at all, and I don’t remember hearing either of my parents talk about it in later years even though after returning to Washington in the late ’60s, my dad went to work as the volunteer director of development for the private Museum of African Art, the predecessor to the Smithsonian’s National Museum of African Art on the Mall; see my post on 19 January 2015.  I’ve always thought that MAA was our introduction to the art of Africa, but it turns out that Gres Gallery mounted this show eight years earlier.)

From 8 February through 8 March, meanwhile, the Baltimore Museum mounted a show of paintings from the Gres, a selection of contemporary works.  Such an invitation to a private gallery rather than another museum or an individual is “a rare honor,” said Perry.  The Gres artists on loan were Botero, Bermudez, Marie Tuiccillo Kelly, and Anna Walinska, as well as Wilfredo Lam, a Cuban-born painter and sculptor who lived and worked in Paris, and British painter William Scott.  The Baltimore reviewer, however, wasn’t quite so impressed.  Of the Gres exhibit, the Sun’s art critic, Kenneth B. Sawyer, complained that “the work included, with one significant exception, seems thin indeed . . . .”  The exception was Scott, “regarded by some as England’s best younger painter,” who “dominates the exhibition.”  All the others, Sawyer dismisses pretty thoroughly, concluding “that  the company offers him little competition . . . .”  (“The Latin Americans, Botero, Lam, and Bermudez[,] suffer from the current European debility of manner,” he proclaimed.)  Sawyer led off by cautioning that “the Gres has provided its quotient of excitement,” but “I, among others, would have been quick to praise brave efforts had I but been convinced of their staying power.”  (Such a loan occurred again in January 1960 when the 20th Century Gallery in Williamsburg, Virginia, an affiliate of Richmond’s Virginia Museum of Art, borrowed the works of a group of contemporary artists from Gres.)

Also in February of 1959, Gres Gallery got itself somewhat embroiled in a small political controversy.  The backstory was the Cuban Revolution that had just ended.  On 1 January, Fidel Castro’s  Marxist revolutionary 26th of July Movement ousted right-wing dictator Fulgencio Batista from the island nation’s presidency and established a socialist state.  Members of the old regime were jailed, fled, or sought asylum in countries like the U.S. or Spain (which was still governed at the time by its own totalitarian dictator, Generalissimo Francisco Franco) and members of the new order came out of hiding to assume public profiles. 

(I have particular reason to recall this development, even though I had only just passed my 12th birthday, because I had a classmate—this would be 6th grade—who was the son of the Cuban ambassador under Batista,  Nicolás Arroyo y Márquez.  When Castro overthrew his father’s government, he disappeared from school, obviously in hiding with his family.  They were holed up in a hotel, it turns out.  Some weeks later, his father had gotten political asylum in the United States and my classmate returned to school.  All the boys in his grade were pulled aside and the Middle School principal, Frank Barger, explained the situation to us and then asked us to keep an eye on the boy when we were on the playground at recess or athletic field for gym and report any strangers we saw hanging around.  Of course, he had a security guard—we were used to this because I went to school with then-Vice President Richard Nixon’s daughters, so there were Secret Servicemen around all the time—but we were supposed to be another set of watchful eyes.  Nothing ever happened, and the ambassador’s son didn’t stay at school after that year ended.)

After Castro’s victory, President Dwight Eisenhower tried to keep relations with the new Cuban government normal and Castro visited the United States on 15-26 April 1959, meeting with Vice President Nixon.  But relations quickly soured as Castro moved swiftly into the camp of the Soviet Union under Nikita Khrushchev.  By the time President John F. Kennedy took office on 20 January 1961, the U.S. had broken diplomatic ties with Cuba (3 January 1961) and relations with the island reached a nadir on 17 April 1961 when U.S.-backed Cuban exiles invaded Cuba at the Bay of Pigs.  But in February 1959, relations between the two countries were stiff and wary, but not yet inimical.

On 19 February, Gres opened an exhibit of the paintings of Luis Martínez Pedro, a Cuban artist and Castro supporter; the show ran through 11 March.  The 20 February issue of the Washington Post carried two articles on the exhibit, one in the front news section entitled “Cuban Revolt Depicted In Paintings Shown Here” and the other, in the “women’s” section, provocatively headlined “Like Artist Exhibiting Them: Paintings Are Pro-Castro.”  (There was also  a regular review from Leslie Judd Ahlander on 22 February in which she described the paintings as “cleancut and intellectual.”)  In the first article, the unidentified journalist declared in his opening sentence: “Cuba’s victorious ‘26th of July’ movement, which culminated in the overthrow of the Batista regime, is the theme of a series of abstract paintings on display at the Gres Art Gallery . . . .”  The reporter described the paintings of Martínez Pedro, “one of Cuba’s outstanding artists,” as “stark and severe geometrical compositions in black, red and gray, the colors of Fidel Castro.”  This was the artist’s first exhibition for his work as during the final years of the Batista regime, he and his fellow artists and intellectuals didn’t create any work, he explained, in order to show their opposition to the dictator.  Martínez Pedro stated “with enthusiasm”: “Cuba is now a new world.  It is a renaissance.  Cuba under Castro is returning to itself.”

In the second article, reporter Frances Rowan quoted Martínez Pedro at the opening of the Gres show: “Before there was no such thing as freedom.  You couldn’t open your mouth.  Now, everything is wonderful.  Castro loves Cuba above everything.”  Rowan asserted, “The spirit of the Cuban revolution is evident in several of the artist’s paintings with the revolutionary colors of red, white and black predominating” and reported that Martínez Pedro predicted, “United States-Cuban relations will be as ‘good as ever,’” while decrying the U.S. government’s silence on “what was going on” under Batista.  The artist reiterated, “I painted these behind closed doors.”  Attending the opening, featuring 18 oil painting and five wood constructions, were Castro’s new Chargé d’Affairs in Washington, Dr. Emilio Prando, and the director of the Cuban Bank for Industrial Agricultural Development, “another Castro man.”  (The article also noted that my parents would be giving a cocktail party for Martínez Pedro that afternoon while another Gres couple would be hosting the painter at a dinner party.  Chances are, I was on the periphery of that cocktail party doing my usual butler-waiter routine!)

(What’s missing here, and could be significant, is coverage by the Evening Star, Washington’s long-ago afternoon paper.  It was a politically more conservative paper than the Post, but it’s not digitized—I don’t even think there’s an index—so I’d have to sit in the library for days combing through microfilms.  The New York Public Library holds the Star and one day, I may do that just to see what it reveals, especially about this “commie art”!)

Having acquired the rest of its two-story building on Northwest 20th Street, the Gres Gallery expanded its exhibit space over the summer of 1959. (The gallery was closed except by appointment in June, July, and August.)  On 12 October, Gres opened a second-floor gallery for work priced at $200 or less.  Using the summer hiatus to renovate the new space, a garden exhibition area for sculpture was in the works as well.  In conjunction with an exhibit at the Corcoran Gallery of Art of French paintings, Fifteen Painters from Paris (10 October-8 November), Gres’s first show in the new gallery was a collection of small oil paintings, etchings, lithographs, and drawings by some of the same artists showing at the Corcoran (Jean René Bazaine, Jean Dubuffet, Bernard Dufour, Hans Hartung, Paul Kallos, Andre Lanskoy, Charles Lapicque, Serge Poliakoff, Pierre Soulages, Nicolas de Staël, Tal Coat [aka: Pierre Jacob], Raoul Ubac, Victor Vasarely, Maria Helena Vieira da Silva, Wols [aka: Wolfgang Schulze]).

From 28 October through 18 November, Gres mounted a particularly interesting show.  The artist was Italian Franco Assetto (who went professionally by only his last name).  It’s really not accurate to call his work at this time “paintings” because his pigment wasn’t paint; it wasn’t even the new acrylic paint that would become widespread in the ’60s.  It was a chemical compound called aluminum gel; the coloration was caused by different chemicals added to the gel.  Having started out as a pharmaceutical chemist, Assetto developed the gel through extensive research.  He made it by whipping aluminum salts together with a coagulant, “like making mayonnaise,” he said.  (I never checked this out, but I’ve always suspected that this was either the same basic chemical compound or some variation of the chemical process that’s used to make artificial gems.  An artificial ruby, say, is differentiated from an artificial emerald by the impurities introduced into the aluminum compound.) 

The aluminum gel creates such a durable paint-like medium that the artwork is impervious to both weather—some Assetto pieces are made free-standing for display outdoors like sculptures—and assaults by a hammer.  As a Post reporter put it, “If Assetto the artist had his way, all his paintings would bear the sign: ‘Please do touch.’”  The artist himself proclaimed, “I want none of those ‘Please do not touch’ signs.  If one likes something, one should be able to touch it.  It’s part of loving.”  In all other respects, the art is essentially three-dimensional Abstract Expressionism.  (The artist worked in other styles and with other media at different points in his career.)  The pigments, explained Leslie Judd Ahlander, the Post art review-writer, were “troweled on with a plasterer’s tool in high relief which catches the light . . . .”  (I have a large canvas, 40½″ x 29″, called Ossidiana VI, a dark terracotta background with conjoined-twin swoops of rust in the lower half, from this show, the artist’s first one-man exhibit.  I’ve never tested it with a hammer, though.) 

On 23 May, the gallery opened an exhibit of Young British Painters, a circulating project of the Smithsonian Institution Traveling Exhibition Service.  (This was the first time that the Smithsonian sent an exhibit to a commercial gallery for sale to the public.)  What was remarkable about this show wasn’t so much the artists or the art on display, but one group that came to see it.  In the week that the show opened, Kenneth M. Scollon, art teacher at Eastern Junior High School (now Eastern Middle School) in Silver Spring, Montgomery County, Maryland, brought his 9th-grade art students to view the contemporary works.  Having visited the National Gallery of Art and the Phillips Collection to see Impressionist art, Washington’s Union Station to see how modern architecture had adapted the design of an ancient Roman bath, and the National Cathedral to study Gothic architecture, the teacher thought the members of his survey course on the history of painting, sculpture, and architecture “were ready for these extreme cases” of contemporary art. 

Scollon had prepared his students for this stage by tracing aspects of abstraction through the various periods of art they’d seen in their previous tours.  How well had he made out?  One student confessed, “It’s a little confusing, but if you attend and look at it . . . .”  (He still declared, “I think that’s cool.”)  Another young art critic wondered, “I’d like to know what they’re trying to get across.  I guess if you know more about it, it helps.”  A third 9th-grader offered, “That one over there with the bright colors says, ‘Look at me.’”  (The artists in the group show, running through 11 June, were William Scott, Sandra Blow, Louis Le Brocquy, Bryan Wynter, Donald Hamilton Fraser, Robyn Denny, and Peter Lanyon.  Leslie Judd Ahlander said they “subscribe to the international trends in art today that are making one country out of the artistic world.  More intellectual and cool than American abstract expressionist counterparts, they nevertheless are concerned with the same problems and solutions that engross artists all over the world.”)

On 15 October, Gres opened a group show of Six Painters of Japan, representing artists all working in modern Western styles (called Yōga) rather than the traditional Nihonga, or “Japanese-style painting.”  Among these artists was Yayoi Kusama who became something of a cultural and social phenomenon both in this country, where she lived and worked from December 1957 until 1973, and in Japan.  (She had a solo show at Gres from 19 April to 14 May 1960.  I’ve blogged on her before on 18 May 2017)  The other five painters in the group show were Minoru Kawabata, Kenzo Okada, Toshinobu Onosato, Takeo Yamaguchi, and Yukiko Katsura,  The work of all six is what would be labeled “avant-garde” and “at first glance,” observed Washington Post  reporter William McPherson, “appear to have little relationship with the Japanese tradition.”  Painter Katsura pointed out, “I see space all around me, but the space inside me—that is Japanese.  That space we all paint.”  McPherson went on to explain: “Minoru Kawabata’s paintings show the influence of Japanese calligraphy, Toshinobu Onosato’s resemble the textiles of his district,” Kiryu in Gunma Prefecture, a silk textile center. 

These artists weren’t unknown in the West, despite the non-traditional nature of their work.  Several, like Okada, had an international renown; Yamaguchi won the third Guggenheim International Award in 1958.  Others, like Onosato, had a reputation in Japan but hadn’t exhibited in the U.S.  In any case, the Western-style art these painters created was less well known here than the more traditional work of their countrymen, even though there were a few avid American collectors.  Gres’s Six Painters was, by this measure, a stroke of acumen that attracted considerable attention around Washington and the American art world.  Leslie Judd Ahlander pronounced Six Painters of Japan, which was scheduled to close on 17 December but was extended to the 23rd to accommodate the addition of the pieces by Yamaguchi which had been delayed in transit from Japan, “a fine show and not to be missed.”  (I have always thought that this exhibit went in toto to New York for mounting at MoMA, but I can’t find any confirmation of that.  Like the exhibit of Contemporary Polish Paintings in 1961, discussed below, the art of several of the painters Gres displayed were later shown at MoMA, but my recollection was that the entire show was borrowed.  Either that memory is wrong, or I just haven’t found the confirmation yet.)

Skipping briefly ahead in time a few months to Gres’s opener for the 1960-61 season, the gallery exhibited the paintings of Aleksander Kobzdej, a Polish artist of Abstract work (although he didn’t like the label) from 26 September to 5 October 1960.  The one-man show, Kobzdej’s first in the U.S., I believe (Abstract art, indeed any modern work, was not officially sanctioned in Poland or anywhere in the Soviet Bloc where the only recognized style was Socialist Realism), even though the artist had a long list of international exhibits in his résumé, including the Venice and São Paulo Biennials (and won a prize in the 1959 Brazil show).  Aside from Kobzdej’s art (one of which, Biblique, also entitled Biblical, is in my parents’ collection, purchased from this Gres exhibit), however, what’s significant in terms of Gres’s history is that Aleksander Kobzdej of Poland was a precursor to one of Gres’s most significant events, a break-through in not only the District of Columbia, but the art scene of the United States. 

Over the summer of 1960, Beati Perry made an art tour of Europe, focusing on Poland—where, as I suggested earlier, contemporary work like that of Aleksander Kobzdej (his last name is pronounced KOBZ-day) wasn’t exhibited to the public in Poland; it wasn’t even officially recognized.  She collected the work of several Polish painters and Gres followed the fall Kobzdej one-man show with a spring group show, Contemporary Polish Painters which turned out to be quite a coup.  Perry spent June in Warsaw, known as the Paris of the East, making the rounds of the galleries and artists’ studios, personally selecting several dozen paintings representing “the diversity of interest and exploration taking place in Poland today” to bring home to Washington.  (As it happens, New York’s Museum of Modern Art was also thinking along the same lines and there was something of a competition for who would put the United States’ initial show of Polish contemporary art together first.  The small, private Gres Gallery turned out to be swifter and more maneuverable than the large institutional establishment with a board of directors and copious curators and advisers.) 

This was after Poland’s communist leader, Władysław Gomułka, initiated the Polish October, also known as Gomulka’s Thaw, in 1956—with Moscow’s tacit agreement, of course, unlike the ill-fated Prague Spring in 1968 (or the disastrous Hungarian Revolution in ’56)—and began a liberalization policy in the Soviet satellite that, though it only lasted until the end of the year, left an aftermath of a somewhat freer society that affected the arts in particular (note, for example, the blossoming of Polish cinema in the early 1960s).  Artists like Kobzdej and Wojciech Fangor had taken advantage of the liberalization to paint in a non-representative style that, reporter Stephen S. Rosenfeld of the Washington Post quipped, was “as far from the official Soviet ‘socialist realism’ as Picasso is from ‘The Happy Milkmaid.’”  While Perry was in Warsaw, the Polish government decreed that museums could not buy any more art—but it was unclear if that order also applied to commercial galleries like Gres. 

In any case, Perry returned to the Capital with 50 works representing 10 painters and two sculptors; among the artists on exhibit at Gres that spring were Kobzdej, Fangor, Marian Bogusz, and Rajmund Ziemski, all painters, and sculptor Alina Szapocznikow.  Contemporary Polish Paintings opened at Gres Gallery on 11 April 1961 and ran until 13 May (extended from the 6th) and the Post dubbed it “a very important first in this country.”  (Fifteen Polish Painters at MoMA ran from 1 August until 1 October with some pieces borrowed from Gres.)  The Gres Gallery show (as was the MoMA exhibit as well) was only semi-officially recognized by the People’s Republic of Poland.  The artists themselves were not allowed to come to the States to attend the exhibit and the Polish ambassador didn’t come to the opening; the embassy sent some mid-level official, however, so it wasn’t entirely ignored.  (For a later show that featured Kobzdej, Gres Artists at the Carnegie International Exhibit, the Polish embassy’s First Secretary and an attaché attended the preview.  My parents finally managed to meet Kobzdej in Germany when we were living there.  It took two attempts to make contact because, as was common, his schedule kept being changed by his government minders.  Biblique, which appeared with the artist in a photo accompanying one of the Post articles on this event, was one of the works of art that my folks took with them to Germany.)

Aside from the remarkable Contemporary Polish Paintings, there followed a number of interesting shows after Aleksander Kobzdej of Poland (26 September-5 October 1960), Six Painters of Japan (15 October-23 December 1960), and the second Botero show (18 October-12 November 1960), including Karel Appel of Holland (16 January-11 February 1961), a one-man show of paintings and gouaches by the 1960 Guggenheim International Award-winning artist; a second Antoni Tàpies exhibit (16 March-13 April 1961), where the art “kept conversation going the rest of the evening,” reported the Post’s Marie McNair, and the artist became “the most talked about young man in art circles in Washington”;  Architects’ Choice (16 May-10 June 1961), a show of paintings and sculptures selected by eight District architects, a concept that Leslie Judd Ahlander dubbed “a new idea in exhibitions”; Group Show: Selections for Young Collectors (July through September 1961), “a group show of artists regularly shown here in a potpourri of names and techniques . . . for young collectors . . . with one gallery devoted to works under $100”; and the mounting of Gres Artists at the Carnegie (26 September-6 November 1961), a preview of the work of the 10 artists Gres sent to the Pittsburgh exhibit (27 October 1961-7 January 1962) that Ahlander called “one of the three most important exhibitions in the world” (with the Venice and São Paulo Biennials).  Only one artist from Washington had ever been invited to the Carnegie International until 1961, when four, including one frequenter of Gres (José Bermudez), were included.  (The other three D.C. artists were handled by the Jefferson Place: Kenneth Noland, Howard Mehring, and William Calfee)  The Post art journalist asserted this was “an extraordinary tribute not only to the quality of local artists but also to the devoted spadework done by” Gres and the Jefferson Place Galleries.

Then on 24 October 1961, Gres opened a show of unique (for its day) art “that is making tongues wag all over Washington.”  The artist was Reva Urban, an American painter, and her art was “literally bursting out of the rectangle of the canvas,” said Post art critic Ahlander.  Reva, as she later chose to call herself, was born in Brooklyn (Coney Island), then spent most of her childhood in Pasadena, California.  In 1941, at the age of 16, she came back to New York City and obtained a scholarship to the Art Students League; she began exhibiting in the U.S. and abroad in 1958.  She eventually represented the United States in international art festivals and her work has become part of the collections of such institutions as MoMA, the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum and the Chicago Art Institute, among others.  In the ’50s and ’60s, Reva’s paintings were essentially Abstract Expressionism.

In 1959, Reva, feeling cramped by the rigid confines of the framed canvas, began adding “appendages” to her paintings.  “I felt my paintings were being stopped—choked by the straight edge of the rectangular canvas,” she said in an interview.  As Post reporter Luther P. Jackson explained it:

At the height of her frustration, Mrs. Urban spotted a lumberyard near her studio . . . .  Her original inspiration was to enlarge her canvas by nailing a strip of wood to it.

In the course of her carpentry, however, Mrs. Urban picked up a scrap of wood formed like one of her brush strokes that had been stopped at canvas’ edge.  She carefully nailed the scrap to the canvas, giving birth to the “appendage” as an art technique—or as she put it, “a bursting form of sensuous energy.[”]

“I was free after years and years of butting against those darn hard edges,” exulted the artist.  “I was like a kid finding a new world, thinking about all of the new possibilities of life.”  Leslie Judd Ahlander characterized the works at Gres as having “tremendous power and vitality,” not dissimilar from the description of the curator of MoMA’s department of painting and sculpture exhibitions, Peter Selz, who said, Reva’s art is “a highly original statement of astounding force.”  Ahlander observed:

Although artists in past years have tried to extend the boundaries of their work of art either by painting the frames as part of the composition, or by continuing the composition on around the sides of the canvas instead of framing it, or by panting larger and larger in a continuum without beginning or end, Reva Urban has actually added painted wood extensions onto her canvases to carry certain bush strokes  beyond the rectangle into space.

The critic had some technical objections to the accomplishment of the “appendages” that limited their effectiveness, but in the end, she acknowledged that “this is not to say that the device is not an excellent and valid one—it performs a very real and vital function in extending these powerful and challenging works.”  (It might be no surprise, given these particular encomia, that Reva was a staunch feminist even before the modern women’s movement began later in the decade.)

I don’t remember the Reva show, but that was most likely because I started boarding school the previous September and was still at school in New Jersey at the time.  The next revelation I found in my research was even more surprising because it contradicts my understanding of subsequent years.  The Washington Post  reported on 26 November that Washington’s Gres Gallery had opened a branch in Chicago at 49 E. Oak Street (and later at 156 E. Ontario Street).  The two Gres Galleries, the announcement said, would be working together closely and exchanging exhibits.  The new gallery opened on 22 November 1961 with an exhibit of Gres Artists Selected for the Pittsburgh International Exhibition of Contemporary Painting and Sculpture, including pieces by Kusama.  Now, I knew about the existence of the Chicago Gres and it was obvious that the Midwestern counterpart had been interested in some of the same artists since when I looked up one or another artist’s name (for example, Fernando Botero and Yayoi Kusama), I sometimes found that they’d exhibited at both the Washington Gres and the Chicago Gres—but I’d always believed they were separate businesses.  Apparently, I was mistaken about this.  (The Gres Gallery, Chicago, lasted a few years beyond the closing of Gres Gallery, Washington, closing around June 1964.)

My misapprehension about the relationship between the Washington and Chicago Greses was confirmed by a remark by Beati Perry reported by the Post on 20 January 1962.  What came next only put a specific date on an event that I, of course, knew about when it happened: On 4 March, the Post reported that Gres had announced that it would close on 17 March, at the end of its last show.  (The final exhibit was presumably the group show entitled Midwinter Gallery Exhibition, the last show on the Post’s “Monthly Art Calendar” [4 February—Gres wasn’t listed on 4 March or thereafter], originally scheduled between 16 January and 10 February, but probably extended until the closing.)  The Post called the Gres’s closing “a real loss for Washington.”  The Post writer I believe was Leslie Judd Ahlander described the “four stimulating, pioneering years” as ones during which “many new artists were introduced to this city in exhibitions that were as provocative as they were sometimes controversial.”  “Gres Gallery Closes After 4 Stimulating Years” lists in extensive detail all the events that Ahlander felt were significant to the art scene of the Nation’s Capital, but her summary was:

Artists of international reputation were brought here, young painters and sculptors discovered and many others given the opportunity of exhibiting in an encouraging and dynamic atmosphere.

The Gallery’s record during its short tenure was impressive.

. . . .

Under the direction of Beatrice Perry, the Gres Gallery did much to bring the best contemporary international art to Washington.

Gres  Gallery was only the second gallery in the U.S. to mount a solo show of Fernando Botero’s work, the first U.S. gallery to exhibit abstract paintings from Poland, and the first to show modern Western-style art from Japan.  Among the solo U.S. débuts Gres presented were Jack Youngerman, José Luis Cuevas, Assetto, Antoni Tàpies, Jorge Oteiza, Rudolf Hoflehner, and Henri Michaux; Gres also mounted the first shows of Matta and Larry Rivers in the U.S. outside New York.   Museums like MoMA and the Baltimore Museum of Art, among others, borrowed exhibits or artworks and sometimes even bought pieces from the gallery. 

The paper didn’t provide an explanation for why such a successful art dealership would fold so suddenly after so short a span (more like 4½ years).  There was no hint that finances were a problem or that the stewardship of the art business had faltered.  The truth is that too many of the group, the so-called Gres Corp., many of whom were Foreign Service Officers or international businessmen, were leaving the District at the same time—including Beati Perry, who, with her husband, Hart, returned to New York City for his business.  My own parents went to Germany in the fall of 1962 (my dad had joined USIA the year before). 

I don’t know why the Threadgills didn’t sell the gallery like the Greses had in 1958, but they didn’t.  The shareholders were paid back in part in unsold stock—that is, art.  Some of the works in my parents’ collection, which began at Gres, originated from that in-kind pay-out—and some of the Gres art has ended up in my own small collection. 

This whole venture (around 3½ years from Dad’s impulse purchase to closure), “helping out” in the gallery and meeting the artists at the vernissages, are some of the most vivid and cherished memories of my childhood.  It was an art education for my whole family and an adventure for me, and it had repercussions well beyond the demise of Gres Gallery to the ends of my parents’ lives.  I’ve decided that our involvement in Gres Gallery was the third greatest influence in my life after my teen years living in Germany and Switzerland and my army tour in West Berlin.  I’ve also seen that it’s the longest-lasting direct influence: my interest in art, especially modern Western art, continues unabated today.  The other experiences were probably more formative, however—I learned a lot about myself, especially from the military service, and perspectives that continue to inform my view of the world.

[That brings this tale of Gres Gallery to an end.  It was a wild ride for one pre-adolescent boy and obviously it still resonates for me.  I don’t expect that anyone reading this account will experience the same feelings I had—and continue to have—with respect to Gres, but I hope you glean a little of what it meant to me then (and means to me now).  Nearly no one connected with the gallery is still alive except a few like me who were children at the time. 

[I seem to be the only person to have attempted to put together a historical narrative of the gallery—and I know there’s material I haven’t uncovered yet that would expand the scope of this article.  For one thing, as I mention above, I didn’t go through the coverage of the Washington Evening Star, which I suspect would add some differing perspectives to the narrative.  I once checked the Art & Architecture Collection of the New York Public Library, looking for something specific connected with Gres, and I found very little there.  I haven’t checked the Smithsonian Institution’s Archives of American Art in Washington; I don’t know if there’s any information in those files, but I’d hope so.  (There is a New York Research Center for the AAA, but I don’t know if it would have any files on a Washington facility; I must inquire.)

[I said at the end of Part 1 that I was thinking about appending a list of the names mentioned in this article and, perhaps, a chronology of Gres Gallery exhibits, but the lists are very long, even just the artists whose names I mentioned here, so I’m considering making an appendix which I’ll post separately this week.  I’ll see if that’s feasible.]

07 July 2018

Gres Gallery, Part 1


[In my post “Washington Art Matters” (5 September 2013), I confessed that I’d considered writing about the Washington, D.C., art gallery of which my parents were part-owners in the 1950s and ’60s, Gres Gallery, but didn’t find enough background information.  Well, since then, I’ve come across a cache of material and I’m going to give it a try.

[Frequent readers of Rick On Theater will know by now that my family’s involvement with Gres Gallery when I was between 11 and 15 was a seminal experience for me and I’ve mentioned it many times on ROT.  (It was particularly important in my blog about my parents’ art collection, “A Passion For Art,” 21 November 2017.)  It’s always been a passing mention for the most part, however, and I now want to try to fill in some of the details of the gallery’s history—especially since it preexists the Internet by so much that there’s virtually (pardon the use of the term) no footprint on the Web at all.  Let’s see what I can come up with.  ~Rick]

Gres Gallery was originally founded by John and Tana Gres at 1744 Columbia Road, N.W., in Washington’s small Lanier Heights neighborhood (within the now-trendy Adams-Morgan area).  It opened on 19 September 1957 with a show of the Colombian sculptor Édgar Negret and painter Jack Youngerman.  

Tana de Gámez was a Spanish-born actress, radio announcer, novelist, and artists’ agent who was raised in Havana before emigrating to the United States and becoming a U.S. citizen in 1941.  (Mrs. Gres’s name is Tana, not Tanya as I wrote it in other posts because that’s was how it was spelled in my only source at the time, Washington Art Matters: Art Life in the Capital 1940-1990, the book that was the inspiration for the art show of the same title on which I wrote the report noted above.  She’s also not from South America as the book asserts.)  

One of Ms. de Gámez’s jobs after moving to New York City in 1936 was as a translator during World War II for the Voice of America, the U.S. government radio (and now TV) broadcaster that sends news and positive political propaganda around the world   Also working in the Spanish-language section was John Gres, a Cuban-born announcer and narrator, who would become de Gámez’s husband and her partner in Gres Gallery.  Tana Gres ran the gallery, which moved to 1729 20th Street, N.W., off Connecticut Avenue at R Street near Dupont Circle, in April 1958.  The new gallery space opened with a one-man show of Ecuadoran painter Manuel Rendon.

The authors of Washington Art Matters (Washington Arts Museum, 2013), Jean Lawlor Cohen, Benjamin Forgey, Sidney Lawrence, and Elizabeth Tebow, characterized the Gres at its inception this way:

What most artists wanted even then was gallery representation, an agent who not only provided space for shows but also promoted sales and kept the books.  Fortunately, the still-active commercial pioneers . . . were joined by a number of new galleries . . . .

One of the most ambitious was north of Dupont Circle,  the Gres Gallery . . . .

Tana Gres steered her gallery to noticeable success in the flourishing art scene of post-World War II Washington.  As I explained in “A Passion for Art,” the Nation’s Capital has a vibrant art community with many excellent museums, working artists, art schools and university departments, collectors, and commercial galleries, and Gres Gallery took its place among the best of the exhibit spaces, closing its first season in June 1958 with Past and Future (4 June-31 July), a show of some of the most successful artists from the previous year and showcasing new artists who’d be spotlighted in the coming season, prompting Washington Post art reviewer Leslie Judd Portner to declare the foregoing months “an unusually successful first season for this up-and-coming gallery.” 

Having “established something of a record for success” in its first 11 months, the Gres faced an existential challenge in August 1958.  Tana Gres was forced to retire from managing the gallery because of a serious heart condition.  The Martha Jackson Gallery, an important New York gallery of the day, and some prominent art collectors from Boston and New York City optioned to buy Gres Gallery and absorb 84% of its stock—if the remaining 16% were picked up by local Washington investors at $3500 per share (over $35,000 today).  Tana and John Gres would move to New York City where  Tana Gres would serve as a representative of the gallery.  Martha Jackson’s offer would expire at the end of September if no local support for the endeavor materialized.  That gave interested Washingtonians a month-and-a-half to pull something together if they wanted to save the “dynamic” little gallery (as the Post dubbed it) in order to “help” the Capital “hold [its] position” as an “important,” “emerging” art center.

On 14 September, the newspaper announced that Dr. and Mrs. Francis Threadgill had bought the gallery.  Threadgill was a prominent D.C. surgeon and his wife, the former Olga Briceño of Venezuela, was a novelist and newspaperwoman.  Olga Threadgill was a long-time friend of Tana Gres—two accomplished writers, they met in New York during the war—and, like Tana Gres, had ties to Latin American artists, making it a good bet that Gres Gallery would continue its strong focus on Spanish, South and Central American, Mexican, and Caribbean art.  The new owners announced that they would fulfill the plans for the 1958-59 season that Tana Gres had made, including an opening show at the end of September featuring the paintings of Abstract Expressionist Norman Carton, a native Pennsylvanian who worked in New York.  (The gallery would reincorporate under its new ownership in January 1959.)

The 25 September Washington Post reported that the new manager of the Gres would be Beatrice Perry, former director of the Sculptors Studio in Washington’s newly hip and upscale Georgetown.  Perry, the wife of Hart Perry, an international corporate executive and U.S. government official, was trained as an artist at the Chicago Art Institute and studied sculpture with Austrian-born Franz Plunder in New York and Americans William Calfee and James Caudle in Washington.  It was with this management set-up that my parents and about nine other local investors joined.  (It was the wives, like my mother—I often tagged along—who were the active participants.  Known as the Gres Corporation, they included Mrs. Robert Cabot, Mrs. Saxton Bradford, Stuart Davidson, Mrs. Samuel Efron, Mrs. Richard McKinley, Mrs. Sidney Rolfe, Mrs. Cord Meyer, Mrs. Robert Anderson, and Mrs. Lucille McGinnis.  Hope Efron and her husband Sam, an international lawyer, were good friends of my parents as far back as I can remember—their son Eric and I went to high school together for a while and then were neighbors in New York City when I moved here after my army service—and Davidson, an investment banker, was the group’s sole bachelor; he later went on to found Clyde’s Restaurants in the Capital area.)   

I’ve recounted this story a few times: My father came home one day in September 1958 and announced, “Guess what I just did!”  Obviously, we didn’t have any idea, so my dad explained he’d bought a share of an art gallery, and Mom asked, “What  kind of art gallery?”  “Modern art,” Dad said, to which Mom replied, “But we don’t know anything about modern art!”  Well, we were about to learn, and it was the beginning of a family adventure that would have repercussions beyond the life of Gres Gallery.

Under the new management, Gres Gallery opened for the 1958-59 season on 30 September with an exhibit of the paintings of Norman Carton (one of whose works, Intermezzo, my parents bought for me as a 14th birthday gift and which remains one of my most treasured pieces of art) and the abstract sculptures of Jorge Oteiza, a Spanish Basque artist.  The Washington Post celebrated the survival by the “newest and most provocative of the modern art centers here” of the near-crisis of Tana Gres’s sudden retirement.

Not that all ran smoothly right out of the gate.  The new Gres Gallery’s first show was almost scuttled before it even opened.  About two weeks before the 30 September opening of the Carton-Oteiza exhibit, four pieces of Oteiza’s sculptures—Empty Suspension, Dynamic Conjunction, Slow Forms Before Closing Space, and Metaphysical Box No. 1—were being held by the Baltimore office of the U.S. Customs Service.  The issue was one of duties.  And the official Customs definition of “sculpture.”  (Yes, there was one, based on a Supreme Court decision—from 40-45 years earlier.  Ummm . . . that would make it from 1913-1918.  What do you think?  Had art changed much in almost half a century?)   

The Spanish sculptor’s work is not just abstract, but, as Beati Perry acknowledged, is constructed of iron or aluminum pieces cut into shapes by machines and then bolted or welded together.  Therein lay the problem: the Customs rule for duty-free fine art rather than “new decorative art pieces” on which a 19% tariff was levied was that fine art must be “representations of natural objects or objects in nature,” according to J. Ross Prevost, U.S. Customs appraiser for the port of Baltimore.  He explained: “Modern art sculptures have metaphysical or abstract subjects . . . .   They don’t represent nature.”  Perry, who blamed the legal criteria and not the Customs Service, proclaimed: “It’s the unworkable law.  What was sculpture in the Renaissance isn’t enough for today.” 

(The law governing whether a piece of sculpture is art or “manufactured” or “fabricated” metal was under review by the Customs Service and a bill was introduced in the 84th Congress in 1957 to change the applicable law to reflect new criteria for modern sculpture “so there would be no question about admitting abstract art into the country duty-free.”  The bill failed to pass, leaving the definition of art the same as it had been for nearly half a century for customs purposes.  There was a second criterion in question as well, however.  The customs definition of fine art included that it must be made by hand or cast from hand-made molds, and Oteiza’s sculptures were largely machine-made.  A lawyer with customs experience explained that this regulation was in force to prevent machine-duplicated reproductions from flooding into the country duty-free in the guise of original works of art.)

When someone observed that Dynamic Conjunction looked like a pair of manacles, Prevost responded, “That’s close, but I just couldn’t say what it is.”  When the artist filled out the customs declarations for the sculptures, he described them as “iron, in crates.”  Therefore someone wondered why they couldn’t come into the country as scrap metal, which carried a 10% duty.  Perry pointed out that might be illegal, and would probably be dishonest: to pay the duty on the value of the metal in the sculptures and then turn around and sell them for thousands of dollars as art.  All a Customs official would say was, “They’re not scrap metal.”

Perry made her argument for the duty-free admissibility of the sculptures in the form of a very interesting analogy—the likes of which government bureaucrats are probably not likely to hear often:

If an artist created a machine-made iron sculpture of his concept of God, it could not be established whether it was like God or not.

Customs officials, if they refused duty-free status for the object, would be in a position of ruling that man could see God and so represent Him.

The case for metaphysical thought is similar.  No one can see them, but they can be represented as man attempting to relate himself spiritually to the universe.

Four days before the Gres exhibit was to open, the gallery “ransomed” the four artworks for $400, a 10% tariff, leaving the question of whether they’re art or not for a later debate.  It was a temporary solution, arranged with Olga Threadgill, new co-owner of the gallery, relying on the government agency to repay the money if it decided to deem the sculptures art—and collecting the full 19% tariff if they didn’t.  Perry reported that she heard the decision “will be a test case.”  On 30 September, the day of the exhibit’s opening at Gres, the U.S. Customs Service ruled that the four Oteiza metal constructions, which the artist labeled “theological boxes,” were, indeed, art objects and, consequently, could be brought into the country duty-free.  The decision allowed for the duty-free entry of sculptures that represent “other than natural objects.”  The Baltimore Sun offered the opinion that “The Customs Bureau edged into the slippery transcendental realm” when it decided Oteiza’s works were art.  Customs appraiser Prevost dubbed the decision “epoch-making.”  Celebrating the decision with champagne with her Gres colleagues, Perry said they’d now be requesting a refund of the $400 “ransom” paid to secure the release of the sculptures for the exhibit. 

Dynamic Conjunction is a sweeping assemblage of dark, curving iron bars, thin and flat and bending into each other, 13⅜ inches high.  Perry interpreted the works as expressions of “spiritually habitable space as a sort of metaphysical installation for man.”  She added: “The sculpture is intended to show man’s relation to the universe.”  According to Perry, the pieces “evolved from metaphysical discussions between the sculptor and the Dutch painter, Piet Mondrian.”  Dynamic Conjunction and Empty Suspension were prize-winners, awarded the First International Sculpture Prize in the international competition at the São Paulo Biennial in Brazil in 1957. 

So ended the preamble, and nearly the death-knell, of the new Gres Gallery’s first show.  Not the sort of notoriety the gallery might have wanted, but it worked out satisfactorily for the gallery and may have even helped prevent a similar occurrence for another exhibitor down the line by being a catalyst for changing the regulations governing importing modern sculptures into the United States.  Norman Carton and Jorge Oteiza ran at Gres until 28 October.  Post art critic Leslie Judd Portner praised the two artists: Carton for bringing “a strong sense of structure and cohesion to his canvases” on which “[p]aint is piled . . . with brush and palette knife until in some instances it stands an inch away from the surface of the canvas”; and Oteiza as a “nice contrast to Carton” who “employs an art of reticent angular geometries . . . .” 

(Accompanying a Washington Post article on the conclusion of the Customs Affair and reporting the opening of the Carton-Oteiza show was a photograph, probably staged, of Olga Threadgill and Beati Perry hanging a painting in the gallery.  The photo is captioned “An Art Itself,” referring to the “proper” hanging of a framed canvas, and shows Perry on a tall step ladder as Threadgill hands a painting up to her as she stands to Perry’s left.  I mention this illustration because I was present for many of these picture-hanging sessions.  I would accompany my mother to the gallery and while the adults were working on arranging the art—I’d have been too small to be much help with this—I’d be sitting at a folding table stuffing envelopes with the announcement of the opening or a schedule of upcoming shows.  I got pretty good at folding flyers and fitting them neatly into envelopes!)

At the same time as the run-up to the first show at the Gres under its new ownership and management, and even during the brouhaha of the Customs quarantine of the Oteiza sculptures, a different sort of attention was being focused on Gres Gallery, a much happier kind. 

On 5 October 1958, the Washington Post announced its fourth annual Christmas Painting Project, a contest for professional and amateur artists, high school and college students, and the general public.  $100 U.S. Savings Bonds were the prize for six winners—one each for a high-schooler and a college artist from public, private, and parochial schools in the District; the Virginia counties of Arlington, Fairfax, Alexandria, and Falls Church; and the Maryland counties of Montgomery and Prince Georges, and four for submissions from the public—for a Christmas-themed painting in any of a number of media.  The six winning submissions would be published in the paper in full color.  

After a preliminary jury of Post staffers made judgments on the basis of “suitability of technique and subject”—there were some criteria—“for color reproduction,” a final round of judging would be conducted on 3 December by a distinguished panel of three local art professionals.  Among these was Gres Gallery’s executive director, Beatrice Perry.  (The other two panelists were Franz Bader of the District’s Franz Bader Gallery and [Hereward] Lester Cooke of the National Gallery of Art staff.)  Perry’s name and position appeared in further announcements and display ads for the painting project that ran until the deadline (26 November), keeping the gallery’s presence before the Post’s readership for several weeks.   

On 21 October, the Post published a letter from the chairman of the Department of Art at the District’s American University complaining about Leslie Judd Portner’s coverage of Gres Gallery.  Ben L. Summerford (known, for some reason, as “Joe”), a painter himself, wrote, “Will Leslie Judd Portner’s crusade in behalf of the Gres Gallery never end?”  Calling for “an uncommitted critic” whose focus is “serious criticism and not social news, whose writing can be respected for an unbiased evaluation of art exhibited here . . . .”  While Summerford acknowledged that “Mrs. Portner at times has been such a critic,” he lamented her “lapses such as have occurred in the past six or eight weeks in which her obvious favoritism seriously prejudices her judgment in other areas.” 

Summerford’s principal problem with Portner’s criticism was that he counted her among those in the District who “have ignored serious art done in the city, and in many cases given preference to mediocre work done elsewhere.”  The critic critic labeled this tendency “a regrettable aspect of our provincialism” and admonished the paper and Portner that if they “are concerned about art in Washington, they could do much to afford the climate in which it could exist.”  

(In the 1950s, the Nation’s Capital was still suffering from an inferiority complex regarding its indigenous culture—what Summerford called our “provincialism”—competing in the minds of Washingtonians, especially native-born residents, non-transients, and those not serving in the federal government, with New York City, a scant 250 miles north and a short hop by train or plane.  I discuss this in “Washington Art Matters” and reference a review of that show, ironically at American University where Summerford taught, by John Anderson in the Washington City Paper in which he also wrote of this phenomenon, asserting, “Washington Art Matters ostensibly intends to illuminate the importance of Washington’s art scene, but it’s awfully hung up on Manhattan—a common and ultimately counterproductive affliction in this town.”)

It might be worth noting here that Summerford was one of the artists who founded the Jefferson Place Gallery, a cooperative that was Gres’s principal competition—and neighbor in the Dupont Circle area of D.C.—in 1957.  Washington Art Matters observed of the friendly rivalry that Gres

created a social scene—with Larry Rivers, for example, playing jazz piano into the night.  Alice Denney [director of the Jefferson Place Gallery] remembers that gallery goers would arrive at her less-endowed operation the Jefferson Place Gallery trailing balloon bouquets from the Gres’s more elaborate openings.

Jefferson Place, located south of Dupont Circle at 1216 Connecticut Avenue near 18th Street, N.W.—four minutes south of Gres—focused on local artists, especially the Washington Color School (see my post, “The Washington School of Color,” on 21 September 2014).  Beati Perry didn’t want Gres to become known as a Washington gallery so she eschewed local artists.  As a consequence, several artists like Kenneth Noland and Morris Louis—and, you can imagine, Ben Summerford and his Jefferson Place  colleagues who were largely a group of American University artists—never showed at the gallery.   According to Washington Art Matters, Gres had already “created excitement among collectors who until then bought only in New York and Chicago.”

By 27 October, several other readers had chimed in on Summerford’s point.  Richard E. Trees of Washington wrote in “to second Mr. Summerford’s criticism of” Portner, but his issue wasn’t with the coverage of Gres.  (Trees complained about the Post critic’s assessment of an unnamed artist from an unidentified exhibit.  He took issue with what he saw as “almost . . . criticizing the artist[‘s] personality and ignoring his art.”)  On the other hand, Washingtonian Penelope J. Wright replied to Summerford: “Despite recent criticism of Mrs. Portner’s evaluation of the present exhibition at the Gres Gallery [the Carton-Oteiza show], I hope that The Post will continue to give so competent a critic as Mrs. Portner a free voice.”

A third letter-writer, Manuel Baker, took up Summerford’s objection to Portner’s putative bias for outside artists over local ones.  The director of Washington’s I.F.A. Galleries (the initials stood for “International Fine Arts,” but no one called it that) declared, “I wish to register a sharp protest against the unwarranted criticism leveled against Leslie Judd Portner . . . by Ben Summerford.”  Listing Summerford’s complaints, Baker wrote, ”As the director of a gallery which has been exhibiting the work of both local and out-of-town artists for the past eight years, I find all these criticisms invalid.”  The letter-writer went on to praise Portner for her support of “a progressive gallery” whose “demise would have dealt a severe blow to the entire art community . . . .”  He asserted, “Mrs. Portner should be applauded and not criticized for her efforts, which played no small part in saving the gallery” (when Tana Gres had to retire precipitously).  Noting that the Post art reviewer had been covering local artists extensively  and that those outside artists she’d reviewed were “artists who have achieved substantial recognition,” Baker’s conclusion was:  “To deprive Washingtonians of the pleasure of seeing and reading about their work would be the height of ‘provincialism.’”

In preparing this article, I perused all of Portner’s reviews of Gres Gallery’s shows, and I can report that, while she praised the exhibits and the art on display, she was no less effusive about the shows at other galleries—including the Jefferson Place.  Most of the notices Portner published on Gres shows were part of omnibus columns covering several art shows in town, so she wasn’t spotlighting Gres to the exclusion of other local outlets.  In addition, if she seemed enthusiastic about this new gallery, perhaps it was because it was a new gallery in a town just coming into its own culturally and every new outlet—gallery, museum, theater, ballet troupe, orchestra—was an exciting and significant arrival on the scene.  Also, as Manuel Baker observed, the Gres almost died aborning, after a remarkably successful nine-month gestation period.  I’m biased, of course, and I was very young and impressionable when Gres was operating, but it was a pretty remarkable place.  It was the art world counterpart to the Little Engine That Could.  Portner, I think, can be excused for her apparent enthusiasm.  It wasn’t bias, but a response to something obviously special. 

According to a report in the Post at the time of Tana Gres’s departure in August, the gallery, “self-sustaining since the third month of its existence,” “has established something of a record for success” by grossing $10,420 from art sales (the equivalent of about $90,450 today) in its eleven months of operation.  Works had been purchased by the Phillips Collection in Washington, the Baltimore Museum of Art, the Brooklyn Museum, the San Francisco Museum of Art (now the S.F. Museum of Modern Art), the Yale University Art Gallery, the Museum of Modern Art in Caracas, and the Frankfurter Kunstkabenett.  Galleries such as the Martha Jackson, Betty Parsons, and Parma in New York also bought art from Gres and other galleries and museums brought Gres artists to New York to exhibit.  Artists of note—“who have achieved substantial recognition,” as Manuel Baker of I.F.A. put it—who exhibited at Gres included José Luis Cuevas, Mexican painter and sculptor; Colombian sculptor Édgar Negret; New York painter Anna Walinska; tapestry-maker Marie Tuiccillo Kelly from Pittsburgh; and a group of the most important German artists of the first half of the 20th century such as Kurt Schwitters, Georg Grosz, Wassily Kandinsky, and Paul Klee.  Ambassadors from the artists’ home countries usually attended the openings and sometimes gave embassy receptions in honor of the artist and her or his work in the exhibit. 

This all sounds like success to me—the kind that appropriately gets press coverage.  But Portner herself reported in December some other marks of Gres’s status.  Noting that when she started reporting on the District’s art scene in 1950, there was only one “professional art gallery” among a handful of tea rooms, antique shops, and movie houses that sold “art” on the side.  Now Gres is among the five that then existed in Washington.  (The other four were the Jefferson Place, the  Obelisk, the Art Rental, and the Hiratsuka Nippon Galleries.)  The Post journalist observed after only one year in the business, an “indication of its standards is that the Carnegie International Exhibition, currently in Pittsburgh, is exhibiting 11 of its regular artists.”  She added that among the 11 was Antoni Tàpies, Spanish painter and sculptor who was scheduled to have his first U.S. one-man show at the Gres in March 1959, and who won the Grand Prize at the Carnegie.  The other 10 artists at the Carnegie from Gres Gallery were José Bermudez, a Cuban-born American known for drawings, sculptures, and watercolors; Luis Martínez Pedro, Cuban painter; Manuel Rendón, Ecuadorian painter; Matta (aka: Roberto Matta), painter from Chile; Mexican painter José Luis Cuevas; sculptor Jorge Oteiza from Spain, New York painter Norman Carton, born in Pennsylvania; New York-based sculptor Louise Nevelson, born in the Ukraine; New York-based artist in prints, paint, and sculpture Jack Youngerman, born in Missouri; and Édgar Negret, Colombian sculptor.  Portner concluded, “This is quite some recognition for a brand-new gallery.”

Paralleling Portner’s assessment of Gres’s success, Baltimore Sun art critic Kenneth B. Sawyer, writing about two years later, lamented the dearth of contemporary American coverage in the Capital’s art museums, “something of a scandal to the vast foreign element that peopled the embassies of the city.”  But he added, “Recently, things have been looking up,” reporting that new galleries have opened and filled the vacuum.  Naming several District galleries, Sawyer declared that “the best of them is the Gres.”  He called it “an ambitious gallery” whose “aims are international in scope and contemporary in direction.”  Under Perry’s management, he found, “it has provided some of the brightest moments of art that Washington has known in recent years.”  A few months later, the Sun art reviewer concluded, “The Gres will continue its policy of exhibitions by contemporary European, Oriental and American artists in the vanguard of current thought.”  Given that a little over a year earlier, Sawyer had expressed doubt about Gres’s “staying power,” this sounds to me like high praise for the gallery’s importance in the Capital area’s art scene.

If someone wants to fault Gres for not showing Washington artists, that’s a fair criticism.  I like the work of Morris Louis, Kenneth Noland, Lou Stovall, Lila Asher (a childhood friend of my late mother’s), and Sam Gilliam.  (There are posts on many of these artists on Rick On Theater: “Morris Louis,” 15 February 2010; “Lila Oliver Asher,” 26 September 2014; “Picasso, Bearden, Gilliam, and Gauguin,” 26 June 2011.  There’s extensive mention of Noland in “Washington School of Color,” referenced above, as well as some passing references in “Picasso, Bearden, Gilliam, and Gauguin.”)  I now think Beati was wrong to reject them back then—but it was her choice and I don’t think those artists suffered professionally for Gres’s rebuff.  (My mother told me a few years ago that both Louis and Noland approached Beati for shows at Gres and were turned down.  I wonder if Summerford made the same application.)

For the most part, things went swimmingly for Gres Gallery and its new owners, managers, and shareholders after the Customs Affair and the Critical Cavil.  (It was all very exciting to 11-going-on-12 me, of course.)  On 29 October 1958, Gres opened its first Fernando Botero show with Ambassador José Gutiérrez Gómez of Colombia officiating.  (The show, which Portner dubbed one of “the two most interesting shows in town this week,” paired the emerging Colombian painter with the much-more-established  Louise Nevelson, the mid-career American sculptor known for her monochromatic, abstract shadow-box constructions.  It closed on 25 November.)  The diplomat had given a reception at the embassy the day before in honor of the painter who was arguably the most famous—or would become so—of all the artists Gres showed.

Gres  was only the second gallery in the U.S. to mount a solo Botero show; the first was at the Pan-American Union (now the Organization of American States, or OAS) from 17 April to 15 May 1957.  Between 18 October and 12 November 1960, Gres held its second one-man show of the paintings of the Colombian’s art; it’s my recollection that MoMA bought the artist’s Mona Lisa Aged 12 from this Gres exhibit.    (Also from Gres’s second Botero exhibit, my mother, brother, and I bought the artist’s Boy with Guitar, sometimes called Boy with Mandolin, as a 42nd-birthday gift for my father.  Of course, my brother, then 11¾, and I, a month shy of 14, didn’t really contribute any cash to the purchase—we didn’t really have any—but Mom paid in the low three figures for the 3¼′ x 4¼′ painting which 58 years later is assessed at 1000 times as much!)

On 30 November 1958, the gallery opened Collages by Robert Keyser.  I don’t recognize the name, and his work doesn’t look familiar to me now, but the timing’s right for this to have been the source of a short-lived but significant influence on me.  Here’s the story (which I’ve told before in an abbreviated version):

It was the practice for Gres openings that the vernissages, the receptions for the artist or artists on the eve of the exhibit, rotated among the shareholders and were held at their homes.  The artists, if they were in town for the opening, were usually there as well, and this was part of what made our experience with the gallery so impressive: I not only saw a lot of new art “up close and personal” (remember, I was often at the gallery when the shows were hung), but I got to meet the artists—real, honest-to-God, professional artists!  (Since Keyser came from New York for the opening, he’d have been at the party, assuming I’ve got the right show.)

Pieces of the art to be shown were bought to the homes and displayed along the walls or propped up on mantels so the guests could get a preview of the show—an enticement, I guess you’d say.  My parents hosted many of these over the 3½ years we were involved with Gres, and I usually attended; I was often the greeter, “butler,” and cocktail waiter when my folks entertained.  One of the art parties my parents held was for a collagist—almost certainly Keyser, given the date and how soon after we got involved with Gres this happened—and I was helping when we laid out the art in prep for the reception. 

I was intrigued by the collages we were placing around our living room; Keyser’s work was described as composed of “many kinds and colors of paper . . ., including graph paper, wall paper samples and even old wrapping paper.”  I’m not sure I’d ever seen a collage—or knew what one was—before this introduction.  When the guests had started to arrive, and I was taking coats and drink requests, one man, someone my parents knew as I recall, was looking at a piece on the mantel.  I don’t remember if the man said anything, but I piped up: “I can do that!”  The man instantly took up my boast and said that if I made a collage, he’d buy it from me.  The challenge was on!

I immediately went upstairs to my room and, not having any other supplies at hand (or really knowing of any other suitable material—besides, Keyser worked in paper), I took some colored construction paper and started cutting and pasting.  It was an abstract assemblage, just shapes and colors without any intended meaning or message (what I now know as the foundation of the Washington Color School’s artistic principle).  Maybe 45 minutes or an hour later, I brought my creation downstairs and presented it proudly to the man who’d challenged me.  He lived up to his promise, too, and asked me what I thought the collage was worth.  What did I know?  I figured the materials were worth maybe 50 cents and, not adding anything for my time or labor—not even considering artistic inspiration—that’s what I quoted him.  He paid up (about $4.50 in 2018 bucks), and I was a successful artists (I’d never have known the designation ‘collagist’ at that time)—I’d sold something I created!

But the story had repercussions:

I went on to make construction-paper collages to give to friends and family instead of greeting cards.  One of my creations was sitting on a table in the apartment of my “Aunt” Viv, my mom’s best friend, when she was entertaining a local Society Lady.  The Society Lady spotted the collage as she was leaving and asked Aunt Viv what it was.  “Oh,” joked Vivian, who had a puckish sense of humor, “that’s an original Richard K*****.”  “Yes, I’ve heard of him,” responded the Society Lady, not knowing, of course, that I was all of 13 or 14 at the time.  Having committed herself, Aunt Viv couldn’t admit now that she’d been kidding the Society Lady—who took herself very seriously—so Viv just let the woman believe I was a famous artist of whom she might have heard.

End of story . . . not.

The anecdote, both parts, made the rounds in my family—my mother continued to tell it decades later—and eventually it reached the ears of my Uncle Herb from Massachusetts.  He and my Aunt Mac were in New York City a few years later, shopping in a gallery on Madison Avenue.  While Mac was browsing, Herb, who had a peeve about pretensions and phoniness, cooled his heels until a saleswoman asked if he needed help.  “Yes,” he replied, in all apparent seriousness (but with a secret glint in his eye), “I’m looking for some original Richard K*****s.”  After leafing through the shop’s collection of art and prints, the assistant told him, “I’m sorry, we don’t happen to have any at the moment, but we’re expecting some in shortly.  Shall I let you know when they come in?”  Needless to say, Uncle Herb—Mom used to call him a pixie—said she should.

I never did become a famous artist, by the way.

It’s one thing for an ambassador or chief of mission to make an appearance at a gallery opening, like Ambassador Gutiérrez Gómez of Colombia at the opening of the Botero show or the Chilean Chargé d’Affairs at the preview of the Matta exhibit.  That’s all about the official representative of a nation making a public fuss over a prominent son or daughter of the home country.  It’s like sending the Veep to the funeral of a foreign head of state—it’s part of someone’s official duties.  But it’s another matter when diplomatic officials from countries unrelated to the artist show up at an exhibit opening or other event.  Then it’s about the prestige of being seen at the gallery, spotlighting the venue rather than the artist.  In the case of Collages by Robert Keyser at Gres Gallery, the Washington Post reported that representatives of the British and French embassies attended the opening; so did the Turkish Press Attaché—even though Keyser was a New Yorker.  (Though meeting artists was a new and exciting experience for me at this time in my life, I went to school with the kids of senior diplomats, so it was no big deal for blasé li’l me; I used to go to the home of the Indian ambassador to play!  A few years after this, my dad would be an attaché himself.) 

[There’s more of this story to come and I hope that you’ll return on 10 July for the second part of “Gres Gallery.”  This has been a very personal and emotional visit for me, going back to a part of my life that I regard with great affection and a feeling of magic.  I hope some of that comes through to you readers.  At the same time, I want to record, in as complete an account as I can, the history of Gres Gallery, including some of my private recollections and some of the personal responses I had to this remarkable experience.  I’ve had to skip over a number of exhibits and leave out more than a few of the artists that Gres showed; I selected the ones I thought told something unique or important about the gallery. 

[I’m contemplating appending a list of the names mentioned in this article after Part 2—perhaps just the artists’ names, with their dates and the kind of art they made.  Maybe what I’ll do, if I go ahead with that plan, is to compile a list of Gres’s exhibits in chronological order and add it to the bottom of “Gres Gallery, Part 2.”]

02 July 2018

Science, Curiosity, and God


[I've watched the PBS NewsHour, as it’s now called, pretty much every night since it was the McNeil/Lehrer Report.  In the last several years, the program’s introduced two regular features that are essentially oral essays by guest contributors.  They’re generally opinion pieces on subjects of particular interest to the essayist, but they cover a wide range of topics and presentation styles.  Recently there have been several of these segments that especially caught my attention, and two of them, one from “Brief but Spectacular” and one from “In My Humble Opinion,” seemed somewhat related.  So I’ve decided to post them together and let them play off one another for the benefit of readers of Rick On Theater.  ~Rick]

“WHY NEIL DEGRASSE TYSON WANTS TO FIX THE ADULT CURIOSITY PROBLEM”
by Niel deGrasse Tyson

[This essay, part of NewsHour’s “Brief but Spectacular” feature, was originally aired on Thursday, 24 May 2018.]

Neil deGrasse Tyson says he is like a “smorgasbord of science food” – he’s recognized hundreds of times every day and people are always hungry for more knowledge. DeGrasse Tyson, who spends much of his professional life encouraging science literacy in adults, gives his Brief but Spectacular take on bringing the universe down to Earth.

Judy Woodruff:  Finally, we turn to another installment of our weekly “Brief but Spectacular” series. Tonight, author and astrophysicist, Neil DeGrasse Tyson.

For more than two decades, he has served as director of the Hayden Planetarium in his home town of New York City. Tyson’s latest book, “Astrophysics for People in a Hurry,” is available now.

Neil DeGrasse Tyson:  What I think actually happened, was that the universe chose me. I know that’s not a very scientific sentence, but that’s what it felt like. The universe said, come, Neil, join us. And yes, I never looked back, back at earth. I kept looking up.

I was star struck at age nine. A visit to my local planetarium. Having been born in the Bronx, I thought I knew how many stars there were in the night sky, about a dozen.

Then you go into the dome of the planetarium and then thousands of stars come out. I just thought it was a hoax.

By age 11, I had an answer to that annoying question adults always ask children, what do you want to be when you grow up? I said, astrophysicist.

That usually just shut them up right there. Nobody knew anybody who was an astrophysicist and then I’d get back to the telescope.

So, deniers are people who wish the world were a way that does not agree with the operations of nature.

Believe what you want. I’m not going to even stop you. I would just hope you don’t rise to power over legislation and laws that then affect other people who do understand how science works. That’s dangerous.

Skepticisms is I will only believe what you believe what you tell me in proportion to the weight of the evidence you present. If you start speaking in ways where no known law of physics supports it, then I’m going to be all over you with my skepticism.

I’m recognized basically several hundred times a day. I wish I could put on a mustache and not be noticed but, of course, I have a mustache. They don’t care about me, tell me about that black hole you mentioned a program I saw the other day. Or, will we ever travel through space?

It’s like, I’m just this, this smorgasbord of science food and I got them hungry from something I did before and they’re still hungry and they want more. Most of my professional effort is trying to get adults scientifically literate. I think kids are born curious and if you fix the adult problem, the kids problem gets fixed overnight.

Part of my confidence is I see this generation who’s been born since 1995, teens, low 20s. That generation has only ever known the Internet as a source of access to knowledge. I have very high hope and expectations for what world they will create when they actually assume the mantles of power.

It’s the gap between when they do and what’s going on now that concerns me. It’s the adults that may have once been curious and forgot or there’s a flame that has been tamped down and you want to fan that flame and reawaken a sense of wonder about this world that we so often take for granted.

When I see eyes light up because that moment was reached, I’m done.

I’m Neil DeGrasse Tyson, your personal astrophysicist, and this is my “Brief But Spectacular” take on bringing the universe down to earth.

*  *  *  *
“A SCIENTIST STARES INTO INFINITY AND FINDS SPACE FOR SPIRITUALITY”
by Alan Lightman

[This comment from “In My Humble Opinion,” essays by thinkers, writers and artists, was broadcast on PBS NewsHour on 4 June 2018.]

Amna Nawaz:  One conflict in the ongoing culture wars seems to suggest that science and religion cannot coexist peacefully.

Alan Lightman is a distinguished physicist and a novelist who teaches at MIT. Tonight, he shares his Humble Opinion on how to make space for both facts and spirituality.

Alan Lightman:  I have worked as a physicist for many years. And I have always held a purely scientific view of the world.

And by that, I mean that the universe is made of matter and nothing more, that the universe is governed by a small number of laws, and that everything in the world eventually disintegrates and passes away.

And then, one summer night, I was out in the ocean in a small boat. It was a dark, clear night, and the sky vibrated with stars. I laid down in the boat and looked up. After a few minutes, I found myself falling into infinity.

I lost all track of myself, and the vast expanse of time extending from the far distant past to the far distant future seemed compressed to a dot. I felt connected to something eternal and ethereal, something beyond the material world.

In recent years, some scientists have attempted to use scientific arguments to question the existence of God. I think these people are missing the point. God, as conceived by most religions, lies outside time and space. You can’t use scientific arguments to either disprove or prove God.

And for the same reason, you can’t use scientific arguments to analyze or understand the feeling I had that summer night when I lay down in the boat and looked up and felt part of something far larger than myself.

I’m still a scientist. I still believe that the world is made of atoms and molecules and nothing more. But I also believe in the power and validity of the spiritual experience.

Is it possible to be committed to both without feeling a contradiction? I think so. We understand that everything in the physical world is material, fated to pass away. Yet we also long for the permanent, some grand and eternal unity.

We’re idealists and we’re realists. We’re dreamers and we’re builders. We experience and we do experiments. We long for certainties, and yet we ourselves are full of the ambiguities of the Mona Lisa and the I Ching.

We ourselves are part of the yin-yang of the world.

27 June 2018

Dispatches from Israel 15

by Helen Kaye

[My generous Tel Aviv friend Helen Kaye has sent me another pair of her Jerusalem Post reviews from earlier this month.  In this instance, both plays are by Israeli dramatists, Hillel Mittelpunkt (b. 1949) and Hanoch Levin (1943-99); coincidentally, both writers are also native Tel Avivians (though, of course, Levin was born in Mandatory Palestine).  Mittelpunkt’s The Others is a new drama, while Levin’s The Child Dreams (also known as The Dreaming Child) premièred in 1993.  I’ll let Helen tell you more.]

The Others
Written & directed by Hillel Mittelpunkt
Cameri Theater, Tel Aviv; 4 June 2018

A Mittelpunkt play is always an Event, but this is the first Mittelpunkt play I’ve seen that doesn’t seem to be sure of itself, trying to paper over the cracks with a lot of posturing and shouting. Like some of his other plays, (Track to Damascus – 2010, Then, Prague – ’13) Others is set in the Palestine of the British Mandate, here a few months short of its end, a period that Mittelpunkt has described as “a fertile cushion for ‘big’ dramas” because of the various and competing forces in Jewish society at the time.

We are in Ida’s (Irit Kaplan) shabby, beachside boarding house – a metaphor for transience – where jobless jazz musician Amiram (Avishai Meridor) is playing the piano prior to an audition that may or may not provide him with employment. Another resident is Thea (Kineret Limoni) who very often entertains British soldiers in her room. Then there’s the silent Mr. Mayer (Itzhak Heskia), a Survivor, dumped by the Jewish Agency whom a relative is supposed to, but never does, pick up.

Then one morning Dassi (Neta Garty) arrives. Her very presence is heinous. She is an outcast, disowned by her family, her name on a Jewish blacklist of ‘traitors’. Her crime? She fell in love with, and married, a British soldier, bore his child, and went to live in the UK. She is here, ostensibly, for her sister Gila’s (Joy Rieger) wedding, but that plan goes awry due to her father, Marshak (Dudu Niv) and despite her sympathetic Aunt Riva (Esti Kosovitsky). From there it’s basically downhill until the (more or less) deus ex machina ending.

I suspect that what Mittlepunkt is trying to say with his cast of solitary and diverse characters is that we are all Others to somebody, especially here, especially then, and even more especially now when, if we cannot see and respect the Other – whoever he or she may be – destruction may be the consequence.

Or as Ida says “you see how the best ideas lead to the worst deeds? There’s no ideal in the world that justifies murdering a 17 year old.”

The characters themselves are mostly believable. It’s some of what they do and how they act that seems contrived, even forced sometimes as in the case of Marshak, presumably feeling guilty over his lucrative World War II dealings with the British, whom Dudu Niv uncomfortably plays as a bullying, raving male harridan. Esti Kosovitsky’s Riva, Dassi’s only link to Eretz Israel, radiates sympathy, but that seems to be her sole function while the purpose of Amiram, whom Meridor plays with a nice mix of anxiety and nonchalance, indicates that he’s carrying a large torch for Dassi, and that’s it. The Gila character also serves, more or less, only as a conduit but Rieger does the best she can with her.

As Dassi, the charming Neta Garti anticipates too much, her body and voice often signaling what’s going to happen before it does, which is unfortunate. We get to know only that she considers herself a victim, that she lies a lot, that she’s manipulative, which is why what she finally does cannot ring true.

Others truly springs fully to life first in Limoni’s unabashed yet, still innocent (despite her profession), Thea, then in Itzhak Heskia’s quivering, slowly-getting-less-terrified, silent-but-speaking-volumes Mayer, and finally and most wonderfully in Irit Kaplan’s energetic, no-nonsense, utterly decent Ida whose for-the-record barkings actually fool nobody. It’s she who gives The Others heft.

*  *  *  *
The Child Dreams
By Hanoch Levin
Directed by Omri Nitzan
Cameri/Habima Theaters, Tel Aviv; 14 June 18

Is there more perfect tranquility than the sight of a quietly sleeping child, the eyelashes gently feathering pink cheeks, the small, even breaths as the little chest rises and falls?

“Let time stop now at the peak of happiness because better than this it cannot be,” says the Mother (Ola Schur-Selektar) as she looks at her son (Naama Chetrit) asleep in his little white bed, and at his Father (Ben Yosipovich) across the bed while Yosef Bardanashvili’s starry (for the moment) music reinforces the idyll.

Then Hell breaks forth. Literally. From a gaping blood-red maw suddenly come tumbling refugees, desperate, clutching their suitcases, and a violinist, dying of a gunshot wound to the belly, still unable to believe that he should be targeted.

This juxtaposition drives Omri Nitzan’s beyond superb production of The Child Dreams, each nostalgic, indifferent, tender, brutal, white-hot and unrelentingly poetic moment perfectly tempered for maximum impact.

Polina Adamov’s set is brutalist, á la 1950s Soviet architecture, the stage being on two levels which a curve (to tumble on, the curve that life throws, the curvature of the uncaring earth – you pick the metaphor) connects. The bed on which we first see the Child becomes a boat, becomes an island, becomes limbo. The colors of Adamov’s costumes are drab, washed out, save for the gold mesh and bright yellow dresses, respectively, of The Woman Born for Love and the Governor’s Wife (Ruth Asarsai). The Dead Children wear white underwear (underwear is a Nitzan trademark signaling vulnerability and often guilelessness).

On the surface Child deals with the fortunes of a group of refugees who attempts to find shelter after being driven from their homes. It is the Child, wrested from peace and innocence, hounded inexorably towards death, who drives the narrative. For parents, for us all, the death of a child represents an ultimate awfulness. But Levin doesn't do surface; The Child Dreams is universal; it is at once a searing indictment of man's ghastly inhumanity to man and an anthem to mercy, even hope.

The 20th was a seminal century, encompassing the glorious – the discovery of antibiotics, man on the moon, and the gruesome – two horrendous world wars, MAD [mutually assured destruction], Josef Stalin and Adolf Hitler, monsters masquerading as humans, and then, around the time that Child premiered we had the Balkan wars, the seemingly endless civil wars in Africa that are still ongoing, and the refugees that inevitably result from conflict.

Which makes the revival of Child almost mandatory because, at the moment, there are some 21 million refugees in the world, more than at any time since World War II. We have some of them and we treat them about as well as the Governor (Alexander Krul/Shahar Raz) – he has an electric bullhorn in place of a head – treats the refugees that attempt to land on his Island. Child is a morality play but there’s no God present.

The 20 member cast plays many roles and every actor gives of his utmost and with utmost effect. Most outstanding are Schur-Selektar whose Mother dredges up the strength to continue with no hint of pathos, Chetrit’s Child is real, disciplined and infinitely touching, and Oshrat Ingedeshat impresses as a compassionate Dead Child. As the Woman Born for Love and the faceless Governor’s Wife, Asarsai is beginning to realize the promise she showed in Woyzzek while Norman Issa chills as the rapacious Captain.

Perhaps Child’s greatness best comes through in this exchange between the Lame Youth (Shlomi Avraham) and a Bum (Eran Sarel): “You wrote those poems to make an impact/And now you try to impress by tearing them up./It’s too dramatic, excessive, unnecessary/. . . You will yet learn to despair/More quietly, more modestly/In silence. As you ought.”

[Readers should note that The Child Dreams was written long before the current refugee and immigrant crises that have enveloped Europe (mostly from the Syrian war against ISIS and the simultaneous civil war) and the United States (because of Donald Trumps immigration policies concerning our southern border). Though the Cameri/Habima production seems especially relevant to the latter issue right now, it was obviously planned and scheduled long before the Mexican-border crisis involving separating migrant children from their incarcerated parents developed here.

[This is Helen’s fifteenth installment of “Dispatches from Israel”; her last collection of reviews was posted on Rick On Theater on 18 April.  Helen’s also contributed several other articles for this blog, but the list of her guest blogs has grown so long, I won’t include it here.  Instead, I refer interested readers to “Dispatches 10” (11 November 2016) for the dates of Helen’s posts up to then—look down in the afterword—and add numbers 11 (17 June 2017), 12 (27 October 2017), 13 (27 February 2018) , and 14.]